Laue Indexing with Optimal Transport
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new method for Laue indexing, which is the process of determining the crystal structure of a material based on the diffraction pattern it creates when exposed to X-rays.
- The key innovation is the use of optimal transport to match the observed diffraction pattern to a simulated pattern, allowing for more accurate and robust indexing.
- The method is demonstrated on both simulated and experimental Laue diffraction data, showing improved performance over existing techniques.
Plain English Explanation
When a material is exposed to X-rays, the atoms in the material's crystal structure cause the X-rays to diffract, or bend and scatter, in a pattern that is unique to the material. Laue crystallography is the process of studying this diffraction pattern to determine the underlying crystal structure of the material.
The key challenge in Laue indexing is accurately matching the observed diffraction pattern to a simulated pattern in order to identify the crystal structure. This paper presents a new method that uses optimal transport, a mathematical technique for comparing and aligning two different distributions of data, to perform this matching process more effectively.
By framing Laue indexing as an optimal transport problem, the researchers were able to develop a more robust and accurate method for determining the crystal structure of materials based on their X-ray diffraction patterns. This could lead to improvements in materials science, crystallography, and other fields that rely on X-ray analysis of crystal structures.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new approach to Laue indexing that uses optimal transport to match observed diffraction patterns to simulated patterns. The key steps are:
- Preprocessing the observed Laue diffraction pattern to extract relevant features and convert it into a probability distribution.
- Generating a set of simulated diffraction patterns for different possible crystal structures and converting them into probability distributions.
- Using optimal transport to find the best match between the observed and simulated distributions, which indicates the crystal structure of the material.
The optimal transport formulation allows the method to be robust to noise, experimental uncertainties, and other factors that can make Laue indexing challenging with traditional techniques. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on both simulated and experimental Laue diffraction data, showing improved performance over existing indexing methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the proposed optimal transport-based Laue indexing method. The authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for future work, including:
- The need for more extensive testing on a wider range of experimental Laue diffraction data to further validate the method's performance.
- Potential challenges in scaling the optimal transport computation to handle very large sets of simulated diffraction patterns.
- Opportunities to incorporate additional physical constraints or prior knowledge into the optimal transport formulation to further improve indexing accuracy.
Additionally, while the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the optimal transport approach, it would be helpful to have a more detailed discussion of the tradeoffs compared to alternative indexing techniques, such as their computational complexity, memory requirements, or ease of implementation.
Overall, this paper presents a compelling new method for Laue indexing that leverages the power of optimal transport to tackle a longstanding challenge in crystallography. The results are promising, and the critical analysis highlights avenues for further research and refinement.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach to Laue indexing that uses optimal transport to match observed X-ray diffraction patterns to simulated patterns, enabling more accurate and robust determination of crystal structures. By framing Laue indexing as an optimal transport problem, the researchers were able to develop a method that is resilient to noise and experimental uncertainties, which are common challenges in this field.
The demonstrated improvements in indexing performance, coupled with the potential for further refinements and extensions, suggest that this optimal transport-based approach could have a significant impact on materials science, crystallography, and other areas that rely on X-ray analysis of crystal structures. As the authors note, additional research is needed to fully validate the method and explore its broader applicability, but this paper represents an important step forward in the field of Laue crystallography.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Laue Indexing with Optimal Transport
Tomasz Kacprzak, Stavros Samothrakitis, Camilla Buhl Larsen, Jarom'ir Kopev{c}ek, Markus Strobl, Efthymios Polatidis, Guillaume Obozinski
Laue tomography experiments retrieve the positions and orientations of crystal grains in a polycrystalline samples from diffraction patterns recorded at multiple viewing angles. The use of a broad wavelength spectrum beam can greatly reduce the experimental time, but poses a difficult challenge for the indexing of diffraction peaks in polycrystalline samples; the information about the wavelength of these Bragg peaks is absent and the diffraction patterns from multiple grains are superimposed. To date, no algorithms exist capable of indexing samples with more than about 500 grains efficiently. To address this need we present a novel method: Laue indexing with Optimal Transport (LaueOT). We create a probabilistic description of the multi-grain indexing problem and propose a solution based on Sinkhorn Expectation-Maximization method, which allows to efficiently find the maximum of the likelihood thanks to the assignments being calculated using Optimal Transport. This is a non-convex optimization problem, where the orientations and positions of grains are optimized simultaneously with grain-to-spot assignments, while robustly handling the outliers. The selection of initial prototype grains to consider in the optimization problem are also calculated within the Optimal Transport framework. LaueOT can rapidly and effectively index up to 1000 grains on a single large memory GPU within less than 30 minutes. We demonstrate the performance of LaueOT on simulations with variable numbers of grains, spot position measurement noise levels, and outlier fractions. The algorithm recovers the correct number of grains even for high noise levels and up to 70% outliers in our experiments. We compare the results of indexing with LaueOT to existing algorithms both on synthetic and real neutron diffraction data from well-characterized samples.
Read more4/10/2024
0
Distributional Preference Alignment of LLMs via Optimal Transport
Igor Melnyk, Youssef Mroueh, Brian Belgodere, Mattia Rigotti, Apoorva Nitsure, Mikhail Yurochkin, Kristjan Greenewald, Jiri Navratil, Jerret Ross
Current LLM alignment techniques use pairwise human preferences at a sample level, and as such, they do not imply an alignment on the distributional level. We propose in this paper Alignment via Optimal Transport (AOT), a novel method for distributional preference alignment of LLMs. AOT aligns LLMs on unpaired preference data by making the reward distribution of the positive samples stochastically dominant in the first order on the distribution of negative samples. We introduce a convex relaxation of this first-order stochastic dominance and cast it as an optimal transport problem with a smooth and convex cost. Thanks to the one-dimensional nature of the resulting optimal transport problem and the convexity of the cost, it has a closed-form solution via sorting on empirical measures. We fine-tune LLMs with this AOT objective, which enables alignment by penalizing the violation of the stochastic dominance of the reward distribution of the positive samples on the reward distribution of the negative samples. We analyze the sample complexity of AOT by considering the dual of the OT problem and show that it converges at the parametric rate. Empirically, we show on a diverse set of alignment datasets and LLMs that AOT leads to state-of-the-art models in the 7B family of models when evaluated with Open LLM Benchmarks and AlpacaEval.
Read more6/11/2024
🗣️
0
Linear Optimal Partial Transport Embedding
Yikun Bai, Ivan Medri, Rocio Diaz Martin, Rana Muhammad Shahroz Khan, Soheil Kolouri
Optimal transport (OT) has gained popularity due to its various applications in fields such as machine learning, statistics, and signal processing. However, the balanced mass requirement limits its performance in practical problems. To address these limitations, variants of the OT problem, including unbalanced OT, Optimal partial transport (OPT), and Hellinger Kantorovich (HK), have been proposed. In this paper, we propose the Linear optimal partial transport (LOPT) embedding, which extends the (local) linearization technique on OT and HK to the OPT problem. The proposed embedding allows for faster computation of OPT distance between pairs of positive measures. Besides our theoretical contributions, we demonstrate the LOPT embedding technique in point-cloud interpolation and PCA analysis.
Read more4/24/2024
0
Submodular Framework for Structured-Sparse Optimal Transport
Piyushi Manupriya, Pratik Jawanpuria, Karthik S. Gurumoorthy, SakethaNath Jagarlapudi, Bamdev Mishra
Unbalanced optimal transport (UOT) has recently gained much attention due to its flexible framework for handling un-normalized measures and its robustness properties. In this work, we explore learning (structured) sparse transport plans in the UOT setting, i.e., transport plans have an upper bound on the number of non-sparse entries in each column (structured sparse pattern) or in the whole plan (general sparse pattern). We propose novel sparsity-constrained UOT formulations building on the recently explored maximum mean discrepancy based UOT. We show that the proposed optimization problem is equivalent to the maximization of a weakly submodular function over a uniform matroid or a partition matroid. We develop efficient gradient-based discrete greedy algorithms and provide the corresponding theoretical guarantees. Empirically, we observe that our proposed greedy algorithms select a diverse support set and we illustrate the efficacy of the proposed approach in various applications.
Read more6/10/2024