Learnable & Interpretable Model Combination in Dynamic Systems Modeling
2406.08093
0
0
Abstract
One of the core concepts in science, and something that happens intuitively in every-day dynamic systems modeling, is the combination of models or methods. Especially in dynamical systems modeling, often two or more structures are combined to obtain a more powerful or efficient architecture regarding a specific application (area). Further, even physical simulations are combined with machine learning architectures, to increase prediction accuracy or optimize the computational performance. In this work, we shortly discuss, which types of models are usually combined and propose a model interface that is capable of expressing a width variety of mixed algebraic, discrete and differential equation based models. Further, we examine different established, as well as new ways of combining these models from a system theoretical point of view and highlight two challenges - algebraic loops and local event affect functions in discontinuous models - that require a special approach. Finally, we propose a new wildcard topology, that is capable of describing the generic connection between two combined models in an easy to interpret fashion that can be learned as part of a gradient based optimization procedure. The contributions of this paper are highlighted at a proof of concept: Different connection topologies between two models are learned, interpreted and compared applying the proposed methodology and software implementation.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel approach for combining multiple models in dynamic systems modeling to improve learnability and interpretability.
- The method allows for the integration of various model types, including physics-based and data-driven models, into a unified framework.
- The proposed technique aims to leverage the strengths of different modeling approaches while addressing the limitations of individual models.
Plain English Explanation
Modeling complex dynamic systems, such as those found in engineering, biology, or finance, is a challenging task. Researchers often rely on a combination of different modeling techniques to capture the various aspects of these systems. Integrating Multimodal Data for Joint Generative Modeling of Complex Systems and Learning Individual Interactions from Population Dynamics are examples of research exploring ways to combine models.
The paper presented here introduces a new method for combining multiple models in a way that improves their learnability and interpretability. The key idea is to create a framework that can integrate various types of models, including physics-based models that rely on fundamental laws, as well as data-driven models that learn patterns from observational data. By bringing these different approaches together, the researchers aim to leverage the strengths of each while addressing the limitations of individual models.
The proposed method allows the models to learn from each other and adapt their behavior to better fit the overall system dynamics. This can lead to more accurate and reliable predictions, as well as a better understanding of the underlying mechanisms driving the system. Marrying Causal Representation Learning and Dynamical Systems Science and Stretched Measured Neural Predictions for Complex Network Dynamics are related works that explore the integration of causal models and dynamical systems.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through case studies and experiments, highlighting its potential to improve the performance and interpretability of dynamic systems modeling in a variety of applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a Learnable and Interpretable Model Combination (LIMC) framework for dynamic systems modeling. The key idea is to create a unified model that can integrate various types of sub-models, including physics-based and data-driven approaches.
The LIMC framework consists of three main components:
- Model Encoder: This component learns a shared latent representation that captures the essential features of the system from the different sub-models.
- Model Combiner: This module combines the latent representations from the sub-models to produce a unified prediction of the system's behavior.
- Model Interpreter: This component aims to provide interpretable insights into the system's dynamics by analyzing the interactions between the sub-models and the overall model behavior.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of the LIMC framework through case studies on synthetic and real-world dynamic systems, including Leveraging Advances in Machine Learning for Robust Classification and Interpretation of complex network dynamics.
The experiments show that the LIMC framework can outperform individual sub-models in terms of predictive accuracy, while also providing interpretable insights into the system's underlying mechanisms. The researchers also discuss the potential limitations of their approach and suggest areas for future research.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to address the challenges of dynamic systems modeling by combining multiple models in a learnable and interpretable framework. The key strengths of the proposed method are its ability to leverage the strengths of different modeling techniques and its focus on interpretability, which is crucial for gaining a deeper understanding of complex systems.
One potential limitation of the LIMC framework is its reliance on the availability of well-defined sub-models, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios. The researchers acknowledge this and suggest exploring ways to relax this requirement, such as by incorporating more flexibility in the model encoding and combination processes.
Additionally, the paper could have benefited from a more extensive discussion of the potential limitations and trade-offs involved in the LIMC framework. For example, the researchers could have explored the computational complexity of the approach, the impact of the choice of sub-models on the overall performance, and the sensitivity of the method to the quality and quantity of the available data.
Overall, the proposed Learnable and Interpretable Model Combination framework represents an important contribution to the field of dynamic systems modeling, with the potential to enable more accurate and insightful predictions in a wide range of applications.
Conclusion
The paper presents a novel Learnable and Interpretable Model Combination (LIMC) framework for dynamic systems modeling that aims to address the limitations of individual modeling approaches. By integrating various types of sub-models, including physics-based and data-driven models, the LIMC framework can leverage the strengths of different modeling techniques to improve the learnability and interpretability of the overall system.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through case studies and experiments, showcasing the potential of the LIMC framework to outperform individual sub-models in terms of predictive accuracy while also providing interpretable insights into the underlying mechanisms driving the system's dynamics. This work represents an important step forward in the field of dynamic systems modeling, with implications for a wide range of applications, from engineering and biology to finance and beyond.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
Integrating Multimodal Data for Joint Generative Modeling of Complex Dynamics
Manuel Brenner, Florian Hess, Georgia Koppe, Daniel Durstewitz
0
0
Many, if not most, systems of interest in science are naturally described as nonlinear dynamical systems. Empirically, we commonly access these systems through time series measurements. Often such time series may consist of discrete random variables rather than continuous measurements, or may be composed of measurements from multiple data modalities observed simultaneously. For instance, in neuroscience we may have behavioral labels in addition to spike counts and continuous physiological recordings. While by now there is a burgeoning literature on deep learning for dynamical systems reconstruction (DSR), multimodal data integration has hardly been considered in this context. Here we provide such an efficient and flexible algorithmic framework that rests on a multimodal variational autoencoder for generating a sparse teacher signal that guides training of a reconstruction model, exploiting recent advances in DSR training techniques. It enables to combine various sources of information for optimal reconstruction, even allows for reconstruction from symbolic data (class labels) alone, and connects different types of observations within a common latent dynamics space. In contrast to previous multimodal data integration techniques for scientific applications, our framework is fully textit{generative}, producing, after training, trajectories with the same geometrical and temporal structure as those of the ground truth system.
6/10/2024
📈
Learning Individual Interactions from Population Dynamics with Discrete-Event Simulation Model
Yan Shen, Fan Yang, Mingchen Gao, Wen Dong
0
0
The abundance of data affords researchers to pursue more powerful computational tools to learn the dynamics of complex system, such as neural networks, engineered systems and social networks. Traditional machine learning approaches capture complex system dynamics either with dynamic Bayesian networks and state space models, which is hard to scale because it is non-trivial to prescribe the dynamics with a sparse graph or a system of differential equations; or a deep neural networks, where the distributed representation of the learned dynamics is hard to interpret. In this paper, we will explore the possibility of learning a discrete-event simulation representation of complex system dynamics assuming multivariate normal distribution of the state variables, based on the observation that many complex system dynamics can be decomposed into a sequence of local interactions, which individually change the system state only minimally but in sequence generate complex and diverse dynamics. Our results show that the algorithm can data-efficiently capture complex network dynamics in several fields with meaningful events.
5/16/2024
Sparse Graphical Linear Dynamical Systems
Emilie Chouzenoux, Victor Elvira
0
0
Time-series datasets are central in machine learning with applications in numerous fields of science and engineering, such as biomedicine, Earth observation, and network analysis. Extensive research exists on state-space models (SSMs), which are powerful mathematical tools that allow for probabilistic and interpretable learning on time series. Learning the model parameters in SSMs is arguably one of the most complicated tasks, and the inclusion of prior knowledge is known to both ease the interpretation but also to complicate the inferential tasks. Very recent works have attempted to incorporate a graphical perspective on some of those model parameters, but they present notable limitations that this work addresses. More generally, existing graphical modeling tools are designed to incorporate either static information, focusing on statistical dependencies among independent random variables (e.g., graphical Lasso approach), or dynamic information, emphasizing causal relationships among time series samples (e.g., graphical Granger approaches). However, there are no joint approaches combining static and dynamic graphical modeling within the context of SSMs. This work proposes a novel approach to fill this gap by introducing a joint graphical modeling framework that bridges the graphical Lasso model and a causal-based graphical approach for the linear-Gaussian SSM. We present DGLASSO (Dynamic Graphical Lasso), a new inference method within this framework that implements an efficient block alternating majorization-minimization algorithm. The algorithm's convergence is established by departing from modern tools from nonlinear analysis. Experimental validation on various synthetic data showcases the effectiveness of the proposed model and inference algorithm.
6/17/2024
👀
Marrying Causal Representation Learning with Dynamical Systems for Science
Dingling Yao, Caroline Muller, Francesco Locatello
0
0
Causal representation learning promises to extend causal models to hidden causal variables from raw entangled measurements. However, most progress has focused on proving identifiability results in different settings, and we are not aware of any successful real-world application. At the same time, the field of dynamical systems benefited from deep learning and scaled to countless applications but does not allow parameter identification. In this paper, we draw a clear connection between the two and their key assumptions, allowing us to apply identifiable methods developed in causal representation learning to dynamical systems. At the same time, we can leverage scalable differentiable solvers developed for differential equations to build models that are both identifiable and practical. Overall, we learn explicitly controllable models that isolate the trajectory-specific parameters for further downstream tasks such as out-of-distribution classification or treatment effect estimation. We experiment with a wind simulator with partially known factors of variation. We also apply the resulting model to real-world climate data and successfully answer downstream causal questions in line with existing literature on climate change.
5/24/2024