Marrying Causal Representation Learning with Dynamical Systems for Science
2405.13888
0
0
👀
Abstract
Causal representation learning promises to extend causal models to hidden causal variables from raw entangled measurements. However, most progress has focused on proving identifiability results in different settings, and we are not aware of any successful real-world application. At the same time, the field of dynamical systems benefited from deep learning and scaled to countless applications but does not allow parameter identification. In this paper, we draw a clear connection between the two and their key assumptions, allowing us to apply identifiable methods developed in causal representation learning to dynamical systems. At the same time, we can leverage scalable differentiable solvers developed for differential equations to build models that are both identifiable and practical. Overall, we learn explicitly controllable models that isolate the trajectory-specific parameters for further downstream tasks such as out-of-distribution classification or treatment effect estimation. We experiment with a wind simulator with partially known factors of variation. We also apply the resulting model to real-world climate data and successfully answer downstream causal questions in line with existing literature on climate change.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the connection between causal representation learning and dynamical systems, aiming to develop models that are both identifiable (can isolate the underlying causal factors) and practical (can be applied to real-world data).
- It builds on recent progress in causal representation learning, which has focused on proving identifiability results, and the field of dynamical systems, which has benefited from deep learning but lacks the ability to identify model parameters.
- The key idea is to apply the identifiability methods from causal representation learning to dynamical systems, while leveraging scalable differentiable solvers for differential equations to make the models practical.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers are trying to bridge the gap between two different areas of research: causal representation learning and dynamical systems.
Causal representation learning is about finding the underlying causal factors that drive observed data, even when the data is entangled and the causal factors are hidden. The researchers in this field have made a lot of progress in proving that their methods can actually identify the true causal factors, but they haven't really been able to apply these methods to real-world problems yet.
On the other hand, the field of dynamical systems has seen a lot of success in using deep learning to model complex systems, like the weather or the stock market. These dynamical systems models can make accurate predictions, but they don't actually tell you what the underlying causal factors are.
In this paper, the researchers found a way to combine the best of both worlds. They take the identifiability methods from causal representation learning and apply them to dynamical systems models. This allows them to build models that not only make accurate predictions, but also isolate the key causal factors that are driving the system.
The researchers test their approach on a wind simulator with partially known factors, as well as real-world climate data. They show that their models are able to capture the underlying causal structure and answer downstream causal questions, which could be useful for things like understanding the effects of climate change.
Technical Explanation
The key contribution of this paper is the connection it draws between causal representation learning and dynamical systems. Causal representation learning has made progress in proving the identifiability of latent causal variables from raw, entangled measurements. Meanwhile, the field of dynamical systems has benefited greatly from deep learning techniques to model complex systems, but lacks the ability to identify the underlying model parameters.
By bridging these two areas, the researchers are able to develop models that are both identifiable (can isolate the causal factors) and practical (can be applied to real-world data). They do this by applying the identifiability methods from causal representation learning to dynamical systems, while leveraging scalable differentiable solvers for differential equations.
The researchers experiment with a wind simulator with partially known factors of variation, as well as real-world climate data. Their models are able to learn explicitly controllable representations that isolate the trajectory-specific parameters, allowing them to answer downstream causal questions in line with existing literature on climate change.
Critical Analysis
The researchers have made an important step in bridging the gap between causal representation learning and dynamical systems modeling. By combining the strengths of both approaches, they have developed models that are both identifiable and practical, which is a significant achievement.
However, the paper does acknowledge some limitations. The experiments are still relatively simple, and it remains to be seen how well the approach will scale to more complex, high-dimensional real-world systems. Additionally, the paper does not address the potential challenges in obtaining accurate and comprehensive data for training these models, which is often a significant hurdle in real-world applications.
Furthermore, while the paper demonstrates the ability to answer downstream causal questions, it does not provide a comprehensive evaluation of the model's performance in this regard. It would be valuable to see a more thorough assessment of the model's causal reasoning capabilities, including potential biases or errors that may arise.
Despite these limitations, the researchers have made a compelling case for the potential of this approach, and their work opens up exciting avenues for further research and development in this area.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach that combines the strengths of causal representation learning and dynamical systems modeling. By applying the identifiability methods from causal representation learning to dynamical systems, the researchers have developed models that can not only make accurate predictions, but also isolate the underlying causal factors driving the system.
The successful application of this approach to both a wind simulator and real-world climate data demonstrates its potential for addressing complex, real-world problems. The ability to learn explicitly controllable representations and answer downstream causal questions could have far-reaching implications for fields such as climate science, decision-making, and policy development.
While the current implementation has some limitations, the researchers have laid the groundwork for further advancements in this promising area of research. By continuing to bridge the gap between causal representation learning and dynamical systems, the field may unlock new possibilities for understanding and manipulating complex systems in ways that were previously out of reach.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔎
Identifiable Causal Representation Learning: Unsupervised, Multi-View, and Multi-Environment
Julius von Kugelgen
0
0
Causal models provide rich descriptions of complex systems as sets of mechanisms by which each variable is influenced by its direct causes. They support reasoning about manipulating parts of the system and thus hold promise for addressing some of the open challenges of artificial intelligence (AI), such as planning, transferring knowledge in changing environments, or robustness to distribution shifts. However, a key obstacle to more widespread use of causal models in AI is the requirement that the relevant variables be specified a priori, which is typically not the case for the high-dimensional, unstructured data processed by modern AI systems. At the same time, machine learning (ML) has proven quite successful at automatically extracting useful and compact representations of such complex data. Causal representation learning (CRL) aims to combine the core strengths of ML and causality by learning representations in the form of latent variables endowed with causal model semantics. In this thesis, we study and present new results for different CRL settings. A central theme is the question of identifiability: Given infinite data, when are representations satisfying the same learning objective guaranteed to be equivalent? This is an important prerequisite for CRL, as it formally characterises if and when a learning task is, at least in principle, feasible. Since learning causal models, even without a representation learning component, is notoriously difficult, we require additional assumptions on the model class or rich data beyond the classical i.i.d. setting. By partially characterising identifiability for different settings, this thesis investigates what is possible for CRL without direct supervision, and thus contributes to its theoretical foundations. Ideally, the developed insights can help inform data collection practices or inspire the design of new practical estimation methods.
6/21/2024
🤯
From latent dynamics to meaningful representations
Dedi Wang, Yihang Wang, Luke Evans, Pratyush Tiwary
0
0
While representation learning has been central to the rise of machine learning and artificial intelligence, a key problem remains in making the learned representations meaningful. For this, the typical approach is to regularize the learned representation through prior probability distributions. However, such priors are usually unavailable or are ad hoc. To deal with this, recent efforts have shifted towards leveraging the insights from physical principles to guide the learning process. In this spirit, we propose a purely dynamics-constrained representation learning framework. Instead of relying on predefined probabilities, we restrict the latent representation to follow overdamped Langevin dynamics with a learnable transition density - a prior driven by statistical mechanics. We show this is a more natural constraint for representation learning in stochastic dynamical systems, with the crucial ability to uniquely identify the ground truth representation. We validate our framework for different systems including a real-world fluorescent DNA movie dataset. We show that our algorithm can uniquely identify orthogonal, isometric and meaningful latent representations.
4/11/2024
Causal Representation Learning from Multiple Distributions: A General Setting
Kun Zhang, Shaoan Xie, Ignavier Ng, Yujia Zheng
0
0
In many problems, the measured variables (e.g., image pixels) are just mathematical functions of the hidden causal variables (e.g., the underlying concepts or objects). For the purpose of making predictions in changing environments or making proper changes to the system, it is helpful to recover the hidden causal variables $Z_i$ and their causal relations represented by graph $mathcal{G}_Z$. This problem has recently been known as causal representation learning. This paper is concerned with a general, completely nonparametric setting of causal representation learning from multiple distributions (arising from heterogeneous data or nonstationary time series), without assuming hard interventions behind distribution changes. We aim to develop general solutions in this fundamental case; as a by product, this helps see the unique benefit offered by other assumptions such as parametric causal models or hard interventions. We show that under the sparsity constraint on the recovered graph over the latent variables and suitable sufficient change conditions on the causal influences, interestingly, one can recover the moralized graph of the underlying directed acyclic graph, and the recovered latent variables and their relations are related to the underlying causal model in a specific, nontrivial way. In some cases, each latent variable can even be recovered up to component-wise transformations. Experimental results verify our theoretical claims.
4/11/2024
🔎
Causal Representation Learning Made Identifiable by Grouping of Observational Variables
Hiroshi Morioka, Aapo Hyvarinen
0
0
A topic of great current interest is Causal Representation Learning (CRL), whose goal is to learn a causal model for hidden features in a data-driven manner. Unfortunately, CRL is severely ill-posed since it is a combination of the two notoriously ill-posed problems of representation learning and causal discovery. Yet, finding practical identifiability conditions that guarantee a unique solution is crucial for its practical applicability. Most approaches so far have been based on assumptions on the latent causal mechanisms, such as temporal causality, or existence of supervision or interventions; these can be too restrictive in actual applications. Here, we show identifiability based on novel, weak constraints, which requires no temporal structure, intervention, nor weak supervision. The approach is based on assuming the observational mixing exhibits a suitable grouping of the observational variables. We also propose a novel self-supervised estimation framework consistent with the model, prove its statistical consistency, and experimentally show its superior CRL performances compared to the state-of-the-art baselines. We further demonstrate its robustness against latent confounders and causal cycles.
6/10/2024