Learning telic-controllable state representations
2406.14476
0
0
Abstract
Computational accounts of purposeful behavior consist of descriptive and normative aspects. The former enable agents to ascertain the current (or future) state of affairs in the world and the latter to evaluate the desirability, or lack thereof, of these states with respect to the agent's goals. In Reinforcement Learning, the normative aspect (reward and value functions) is assumed to depend on a pre-defined and fixed descriptive one (state representation). Alternatively, these two aspects may emerge interdependently: goals can be, and indeed often are, expressed in terms of state representation features, but they may also serve to shape state representations themselves. Here, we illustrate a novel theoretical framing of state representation learning in bounded agents, coupling descriptive and normative aspects via the notion of goal-directed, or telic, states. We define a new controllability property of telic state representations to characterize the tradeoff between their granularity and the policy complexity capacity required to reach all telic states. We propose an algorithm for learning controllable state representations and demonstrate it using a simple navigation task with changing goals. Our framework highlights the crucial role of deliberate ignorance - knowing what to ignore - for learning state representations that are both goal-flexible and simple. More broadly, our work provides a concrete step towards a unified theoretical view of natural and artificial learning through the lens of goals.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new approach for learning "telic-controllable" state representations, which are representations that capture the intended goals or effects of actions.
- The key idea is to learn a state representation that separates the current state of the world from the intended future state that an agent is trying to achieve through its actions.
- This allows the agent to reason more effectively about its goals and plan actions that will achieve the desired outcomes.
Plain English Explanation
The paper proposes a new way for AI agents to learn how to represent the state of the world around them. Typically, an agent might learn a representation that simply captures the current situation, like the positions of objects or the agent's own location. However, the authors argue that it's also important for the agent to learn a representation that captures its
For example, imagine a robot that is trying to tidy up a room. Rather than just learning a representation of where all the objects currently are, the robot could also learn a representation of the
The authors call this type of representation a "telic-controllable" state, because it captures the agent's
Technical Explanation
The paper formalizes the notion of a "telic-controllable" state representation, which separates the current state of the world s from the intended future state or "goal" g that an agent is trying to achieve through its actions a. The key idea is to learn a representation z = f(s, g) that encodes both the current state and the desired goal state, allowing the agent to reason about how its actions can transform the current state into the goal state.
The authors propose a machine learning framework to train agents to learn these telic-controllable representations. The core component is an encoder network f(s, g) that takes in the current state s and the goal state g, and learns to produce a latent representation z that captures both. This is trained alongside a dynamics model p(s' | s, a) that predicts the next state s' given the current state s and action a.
The training objective encourages the latent representation z to be s into the desired goal state g by taking appropriate actions. The authors demonstrate this approach on a range of simulated environments, showing that agents trained with telic-controllable representations can plan more effectively to achieve their goals.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of learning representations that capture an agent's intended goals, in addition to just the current state of the world. This provides a richer and more meaningful state representation that can support more effective planning and decision-making.
However, the authors acknowledge that their approach has some limitations. Firstly, the requirement to explicitly specify the goal state g during training may be impractical in many real-world scenarios where the goals are more open-ended or difficult to define a priori. Techniques like goal-conditioned reinforcement learning may be needed to address this.
Additionally, the paper focuses on relatively simple environments with discrete actions and state spaces. Extending this approach to more complex, continuous domains with high-dimensional state representations and more complex dynamics may require significant additional research and development.
Some other open questions include: How can these telic-controllable representations be effectively used for downstream tasks like planning and decision-making? How robust are they to changes in the environment or the agent's objectives? And how might they interact with other recent advances in representation learning, like learning action-based representations or bridging state and history representations?
Overall, this paper takes an important step towards more intentional and goal-directed representations in reinforcement learning, but there is still significant room for further research and development in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces the concept of "telic-controllable" state representations, which separate the current state of the world from the intended future state or goal that an agent is trying to achieve. The authors propose a machine learning framework to train agents to learn these kinds of representations, which can support more effective planning and decision-making.
While the approach has some limitations, it represents an important step towards more intentional and goal-directed representations in reinforcement learning. As AI systems become increasingly capable, being able to reason about their objectives and plan actions to achieve desired outcomes will be crucial. Techniques like those explored in this paper, combined with other advances in representation learning and planning, could help pave the way for more capable and reliable AI agents that can robustly pursue their goals in complex, dynamic environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📉
PcLast: Discovering Plannable Continuous Latent States
Anurag Koul, Shivakanth Sujit, Shaoru Chen, Ben Evans, Lili Wu, Byron Xu, Rajan Chari, Riashat Islam, Raihan Seraj, Yonathan Efroni, Lekan Molu, Miro Dudik, John Langford, Alex Lamb
0
0
Goal-conditioned planning benefits from learned low-dimensional representations of rich observations. While compact latent representations typically learned from variational autoencoders or inverse dynamics enable goal-conditioned decision making, they ignore state reachability, hampering their performance. In this paper, we learn a representation that associates reachable states together for effective planning and goal-conditioned policy learning. We first learn a latent representation with multi-step inverse dynamics (to remove distracting information), and then transform this representation to associate reachable states together in $ell_2$ space. Our proposals are rigorously tested in various simulation testbeds. Numerical results in reward-based settings show significant improvements in sampling efficiency. Further, in reward-free settings this approach yields layered state abstractions that enable computationally efficient hierarchical planning for reaching ad hoc goals with zero additional samples.
6/12/2024
Learning Action-based Representations Using Invariance
Max Rudolph, Caleb Chuck, Kevin Black, Misha Lvovsky, Scott Niekum, Amy Zhang
0
0
Robust reinforcement learning agents using high-dimensional observations must be able to identify relevant state features amidst many exogeneous distractors. A representation that captures controllability identifies these state elements by determining what affects agent control. While methods such as inverse dynamics and mutual information capture controllability for a limited number of timesteps, capturing long-horizon elements remains a challenging problem. Myopic controllability can capture the moment right before an agent crashes into a wall, but not the control-relevance of the wall while the agent is still some distance away. To address this we introduce action-bisimulation encoding, a method inspired by the bisimulation invariance pseudometric, that extends single-step controllability with a recursive invariance constraint. By doing this, action-bisimulation learns a multi-step controllability metric that smoothly discounts distant state features that are relevant for control. We demonstrate that action-bisimulation pretraining on reward-free, uniformly random data improves sample efficiency in several environments, including a photorealistic 3D simulation domain, Habitat. Additionally, we provide theoretical analysis and qualitative results demonstrating the information captured by action-bisimulation.
6/26/2024
🤔
Bridging State and History Representations: Understanding Self-Predictive RL
Tianwei Ni, Benjamin Eysenbach, Erfan Seyedsalehi, Michel Ma, Clement Gehring, Aditya Mahajan, Pierre-Luc Bacon
0
0
Representations are at the core of all deep reinforcement learning (RL) methods for both Markov decision processes (MDPs) and partially observable Markov decision processes (POMDPs). Many representation learning methods and theoretical frameworks have been developed to understand what constitutes an effective representation. However, the relationships between these methods and the shared properties among them remain unclear. In this paper, we show that many of these seemingly distinct methods and frameworks for state and history abstractions are, in fact, based on a common idea of self-predictive abstraction. Furthermore, we provide theoretical insights into the widely adopted objectives and optimization, such as the stop-gradient technique, in learning self-predictive representations. These findings together yield a minimalist algorithm to learn self-predictive representations for states and histories. We validate our theories by applying our algorithm to standard MDPs, MDPs with distractors, and POMDPs with sparse rewards. These findings culminate in a set of preliminary guidelines for RL practitioners.
4/23/2024
Probabilistic Subgoal Representations for Hierarchical Reinforcement learning
Vivienne Huiling Wang, Tinghuai Wang, Wenyan Yang, Joni-Kristian Kamarainen, Joni Pajarinen
0
0
In goal-conditioned hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL), a high-level policy specifies a subgoal for the low-level policy to reach. Effective HRL hinges on a suitable subgoal represen tation function, abstracting state space into latent subgoal space and inducing varied low-level behaviors. Existing methods adopt a subgoal representation that provides a deterministic mapping from state space to latent subgoal space. Instead, this paper utilizes Gaussian Processes (GPs) for the first probabilistic subgoal representation. Our method employs a GP prior on the latent subgoal space to learn a posterior distribution over the subgoal representation functions while exploiting the long-range correlation in the state space through learnable kernels. This enables an adaptive memory that integrates long-range subgoal information from prior planning steps allowing to cope with stochastic uncertainties. Furthermore, we propose a novel learning objective to facilitate the simultaneous learning of probabilistic subgoal representations and policies within a unified framework. In experiments, our approach outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in standard benchmarks but also in environments with stochastic elements and under diverse reward conditions. Additionally, our model shows promising capabilities in transferring low-level policies across different tasks.
6/26/2024