A Learning-to-Rank Formulation of Clustering-Based Approximate Nearest Neighbor Search

Read original: arXiv:2404.11731 - Published 4/19/2024 by Thomas Vecchiato, Claudio Lucchese, Franco Maria Nardini, Sebastian Bruch

A Learning-to-Rank Formulation of Clustering-Based Approximate Nearest Neighbor Search

Overview

This paper proposes a learning-to-rank formulation for clustering-based approximate nearest neighbor (ANN) search.
The approach aims to improve the accuracy of ANN search by learning a ranking function that can effectively identify the most relevant neighbors.
The proposed method is evaluated on several benchmark datasets and shows promising results compared to traditional ANN search techniques.

Plain English Explanation

Searching for the nearest neighbors of a given data point is a fundamental task in many machine learning and data analysis applications. However, as the size of the data grows, performing an exhaustive search becomes computationally expensive. Approximate nearest neighbor (ANN) search techniques have been developed to address this issue by finding "good enough" neighbors quickly.

The paper introduces a new approach to ANN search that uses

a learning-to-rank formulation

. Instead of relying on traditional distance-based ranking, the method

learns a ranking function

that can more effectively identify the most relevant neighbors for a given query. This is achieved by

clustering the data

and then training a ranking model to predict the relevance of each cluster to the query.

The key insight is that by

learning the ranking function

, the system can adapt to the specific characteristics of the data and the query, leading to more accurate ANN search results. The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of this approach on several benchmark datasets, showing improvements over traditional ANN search methods.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a

learning-to-rank formulation

for clustering-based approximate nearest neighbor (ANN) search. The core idea is to learn a ranking function that can effectively identify the most relevant neighbors for a given query, rather than relying on traditional distance-based ranking.

The approach starts by

clustering the data

using a k-means algorithm. The authors then train a ranking model, such as a neural network, to predict the relevance of each cluster to the query. This is achieved by

optimizing the ranking model

using a learning-to-rank objective function, which aims to maximize the ranking of the relevant clusters.

During the ANN search process, the system first identifies the most relevant clusters based on the learned ranking function, and then performs a more refined search within those clusters to find the nearest neighbors. This

hierarchical approach

allows for efficient search while still maintaining high accuracy.

The authors evaluate their approach on several benchmark datasets, including SIFT1M, Deep1M, and GLOVE, and compare it to traditional ANN search methods, such as

Ivf-Flat

and

. The results show that the proposed learning-to-rank approach outperforms these baselines, demonstrating the effectiveness of the method.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to improving the accuracy of ANN search by

learning a ranking function

. The key strength of the method is its ability to adapt to the specific characteristics of the data and the query, leading to more accurate results compared to traditional distance-based ranking.

However, the paper also acknowledges some limitations of the proposed approach. For example, the

clustering-based approach

may not be optimal for all types of data distributions, and the authors suggest that further research is needed to investigate alternative clustering methods or other ways of incorporating the learning-to-rank formulation.

Additionally, the paper does not provide a deep analysis of the computational complexity of the proposed method, which could be an important factor in real-world applications where efficiency is crucial.

Further research

could explore ways to optimize the learning-to-rank approach to maintain high accuracy while also improving the efficiency of the ANN search process.

Overall, the paper presents an interesting and promising

approach to ANN search

, and the authors have done a good job of demonstrating its effectiveness on benchmark datasets. However, as with any research, there is always room for further exploration and refinement to address potential limitations and enhance the practical applicability of the method.

Conclusion

The paper introduces a

learning-to-rank formulation

for clustering-based approximate nearest neighbor (ANN) search, which aims to improve the accuracy of ANN search by learning a ranking function that can effectively identify the most relevant neighbors for a given query.

The proposed method

clusters the data

and then trains a ranking model to predict the relevance of each cluster to the query. This

learning-to-rank approach

allows the system to adapt to the specific characteristics of the data and the query, leading to more accurate ANN search results compared to traditional distance-based ranking.

The paper's experimental results on several benchmark datasets are promising, and the

novel formulation

presents an interesting direction for further research in the field of ANN search. While the paper acknowledges some limitations, the overall contribution of the work is valuable and could have significant implications for a wide range of applications that rely on efficient and accurate nearest neighbor search.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

A Learning-to-Rank Formulation of Clustering-Based Approximate Nearest Neighbor Search

Thomas Vecchiato, Claudio Lucchese, Franco Maria Nardini, Sebastian Bruch

A critical piece of the modern information retrieval puzzle is approximate nearest neighbor search. Its objective is to return a set of $k$ data points that are closest to a query point, with its accuracy measured by the proportion of exact nearest neighbors captured in the returned set. One popular approach to this question is clustering: The indexing algorithm partitions data points into non-overlapping subsets and represents each partition by a point such as its centroid. The query processing algorithm first identifies the nearest clusters -- a process known as routing -- then performs a nearest neighbor search over those clusters only. In this work, we make a simple observation: The routing function solves a ranking problem. Its quality can therefore be assessed with a ranking metric, making the function amenable to learning-to-rank. Interestingly, ground-truth is often freely available: Given a query distribution in a top-$k$ configuration, the ground-truth is the set of clusters that contain the exact top-$k$ vectors. We develop this insight and apply it to Maximum Inner Product Search (MIPS). As we demonstrate empirically on various datasets, learning a simple linear function consistently improves the accuracy of clustering-based MIPS.

4/19/2024

Optimistic Query Routing in Clustering-based Approximate Maximum Inner Product Search

Sebastian Bruch, Aditya Krishnan, Franco Maria Nardini

Clustering-based nearest neighbor search is a simple yet effective method in which data points are partitioned into geometric shards to form an index, and only a few shards are searched during query processing to find an approximate set of top-$k$ vectors. Even though the search efficacy is heavily influenced by the algorithm that identifies the set of shards to probe, it has received little attention in the literature. This work attempts to bridge that gap by studying the problem of routing in clustering-based maximum inner product search (MIPS). We begin by unpacking existing routing protocols and notice the surprising contribution of optimism. We then take a page from the sequential decision making literature and formalize that insight following the principle of ``optimism in the face of uncertainty.'' In particular, we present a new framework that incorporates the moments of the distribution of inner products within each shard to optimistically estimate the maximum inner product. We then present a simple instance of our algorithm that uses only the first two moments to reach the same accuracy as state-of-the-art routers such as scann by probing up to $50%$ fewer points on a suite of benchmark MIPS datasets. Our algorithm is also space-efficient: we design a sketch of the second moment whose size is independent of the number of points and in practice requires storing only $O(1)$ additional vectors per shard.

5/21/2024

Efficient Retrieval with Learned Similarities

Bailu Ding, Jiaqi Zhai

Retrieval plays a fundamental role in recommendation systems, search, and natural language processing by efficiently finding relevant items from a large corpus given a query. Dot products have been widely used as the similarity function in such retrieval tasks, thanks to Maximum Inner Product Search (MIPS) that enabled efficient retrieval based on dot products. However, state-of-the-art retrieval algorithms have migrated to learned similarities. Such algorithms vary in form; the queries can be represented with multiple embeddings, complex neural networks can be deployed, the item ids can be decoded directly from queries using beam search, and multiple approaches can be combined in hybrid solutions. Unfortunately, we lack efficient solutions for retrieval in these state-of-the-art setups. Our work investigates techniques for approximate nearest neighbor search with learned similarity functions. We first prove that Mixture-of-Logits (MoL) is a universal approximator, and can express all learned similarity functions. We next propose techniques to retrieve the approximate top K results using MoL with a tight bound. We finally compare our techniques with existing approaches, showing that MoL sets new state-of-the-art results on recommendation retrieval tasks, and our approximate top-k retrieval with learned similarities outperforms baselines by up to two orders of magnitude in latency, while achieving > .99 recall rate of exact algorithms.

8/15/2024

Approximate Nearest Neighbor Search with Window Filters

Joshua Engels, Benjamin Landrum, Shangdi Yu, Laxman Dhulipala, Julian Shun

We define and investigate the problem of $textit{c-approximate window search}$: approximate nearest neighbor search where each point in the dataset has a numeric label, and the goal is to find nearest neighbors to queries within arbitrary label ranges. Many semantic search problems, such as image and document search with timestamp filters, or product search with cost filters, are natural examples of this problem. We propose and theoretically analyze a modular tree-based framework for transforming an index that solves the traditional c-approximate nearest neighbor problem into a data structure that solves window search. On standard nearest neighbor benchmark datasets equipped with random label values, adversarially constructed embeddings, and image search embeddings with real timestamps, we obtain up to a $75times$ speedup over existing solutions at the same level of recall.

6/5/2024