Learning When the Concept Shifts: Confounding, Invariance, and Dimension Reduction
2406.15904
0
0
Abstract
Practitioners often deploy a learned prediction model in a new environment where the joint distribution of covariate and response has shifted. In observational data, the distribution shift is often driven by unobserved confounding factors lurking in the environment, with the underlying mechanism unknown. Confounding can obfuscate the definition of the best prediction model (concept shift) and shift covariates to domains yet unseen (covariate shift). Therefore, a model maximizing prediction accuracy in the source environment could suffer a significant accuracy drop in the target environment. This motivates us to study the domain adaptation problem with observational data: given labeled covariate and response pairs from a source environment, and unlabeled covariates from a target environment, how can one predict the missing target response reliably? We root the adaptation problem in a linear structural causal model to address endogeneity and unobserved confounding. We study the necessity and benefit of leveraging exogenous, invariant covariate representations to cure concept shifts and improve target prediction. This further motivates a new representation learning method for adaptation that optimizes for a lower-dimensional linear subspace and, subsequently, a prediction model confined to that subspace. The procedure operates on a non-convex objective-that naturally interpolates between predictability and stability/invariance-constrained on the Stiefel manifold. We study the optimization landscape and prove that, when the regularization is sufficient, nearly all local optima align with an invariant linear subspace resilient to both concept and covariate shift. In terms of predictability, we show a model that uses the learned lower-dimensional subspace can incur a nearly ideal gap between target and source risk. Three real-world data sets are investigated to validate our method and theory.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the challenges of learning predictive models when the underlying data distribution shifts, known as the concept shift problem.
- The authors propose a structural causal model to analyze the sources of concept shift, including confounding variables, invariant features, and changes in the data dimensionality.
- They demonstrate how these factors can impact model performance and introduce techniques to mitigate the effects of concept shift, such as dimension reduction and transfer learning.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models are often trained on data from one setting or time period, but then deployed in a different context where the underlying patterns in the data may have changed. This shift in the data distribution, known as concept shift, can seriously degrade model performance.
The authors of this paper propose a causal model to better understand the sources of concept shift. They identify three key factors:
- Confounding variables: Hidden factors that influence both the input features and the target variable, leading to spurious correlations that may not hold in a new context.
- Invariant features: Aspects of the data that remain constant across different situations, which can be leveraged to build more robust models.
- Dimensionality changes: Shifts in the number or type of relevant features, which can necessitate dimension reduction techniques to maintain model performance.
By modeling these sources of concept shift, the authors develop strategies to adapt models to new contexts, such as identifying invariant features and using transfer learning to leverage knowledge from related domains.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by framing the concept shift problem using a structural causal model (SCM). The SCM represents the underlying data-generating process, showing how input features, confounding variables, and the target variable are related through a set of structural equations.
The authors then analyze how changes in the SCM can lead to concept shift, focusing on three key factors:
- Confounding variables: If the relationship between the input features and the target variable is mediated by unobserved confounding variables, then a shift in the distribution of these confounders can lead to a change in the observed associations, even if the underlying causal mechanisms remain the same.
- Invariant features: Some aspects of the input data may remain constant across different contexts. By identifying and leveraging these invariant features, the authors show how models can be made more robust to concept shift.
- Dimensionality changes: Shifts in the number or type of relevant features can necessitate the use of dimension reduction techniques to maintain model performance in the face of concept shift.
The paper then explores several strategies for adapting models to new contexts, including transfer learning approaches that leverage knowledge from related domains and unsupervised domain adaptation techniques that align the feature distributions across contexts.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a comprehensive theoretical framework for understanding the sources of concept shift, which is a critical challenge in many real-world machine learning applications. However, the paper focuses primarily on the conceptual analysis and does not include a detailed empirical evaluation of the proposed techniques.
While the authors discuss several strategies for mitigating concept shift, such as leveraging invariant features and using dimension reduction, more research is needed to understand the practical effectiveness of these approaches across a variety of domains and datasets. Additionally, the paper does not address how to identify the underlying causal structure in complex, high-dimensional data, which is a key prerequisite for applying the proposed methods.
Furthermore, the authors acknowledge that their analysis assumes the availability of a structural causal model, which may not be feasible in many real-world scenarios where the underlying data-generating process is unknown or difficult to specify. Developing techniques that can effectively handle concept shift without relying on such strong modeling assumptions would be a valuable direction for future research.
Conclusion
This paper presents a rigorous theoretical framework for understanding the challenges of learning predictive models in the face of concept shift, a common problem in many real-world machine learning applications. By modeling the underlying causal structure of the data, the authors identify key factors that can contribute to concept shift, including confounding variables, invariant features, and changes in data dimensionality.
While the proposed strategies for mitigating concept shift, such as leveraging invariant features and using dimension reduction, show promise, more empirical evaluation is needed to assess their practical effectiveness. Additionally, further research is required to develop techniques that can handle concept shift without relying on the availability of a structural causal model, which may not be feasible in many real-world scenarios.
Overall, this paper provides a valuable foundation for understanding and addressing the problem of concept shift, which remains a critical challenge in the field of machine learning with significant implications for the deployment of predictive models in dynamic, real-world environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🖼️
Blessings and Curses of Covariate Shifts: Adversarial Learning Dynamics, Directional Convergence, and Equilibria
Tengyuan Liang
0
0
Covariate distribution shifts and adversarial perturbations present robustness challenges to the conventional statistical learning framework: mild shifts in the test covariate distribution can significantly affect the performance of the statistical model learned based on the training distribution. The model performance typically deteriorates when extrapolation happens: namely, covariates shift to a region where the training distribution is scarce, and naturally, the learned model has little information. For robustness and regularization considerations, adversarial perturbation techniques are proposed as a remedy; however, careful study needs to be carried out about what extrapolation region adversarial covariate shift will focus on, given a learned model. This paper precisely characterizes the extrapolation region, examining both regression and classification in an infinite-dimensional setting. We study the implications of adversarial covariate shifts to subsequent learning of the equilibrium -- the Bayes optimal model -- in a sequential game framework. We exploit the dynamics of the adversarial learning game and reveal the curious effects of the covariate shift to equilibrium learning and experimental design. In particular, we establish two directional convergence results that exhibit distinctive phenomena: (1) a blessing in regression, the adversarial covariate shifts in an exponential rate to an optimal experimental design for rapid subsequent learning; (2) a curse in classification, the adversarial covariate shifts in a subquadratic rate to the hardest experimental design trapping subsequent learning.
5/21/2024
🔎
Domain Generalisation for Object Detection under Covariate and Concept Shift
Karthik Seemakurthy, Erchan Aptoula, Charles Fox, Petra Bosilj
0
0
Domain generalisation aims to promote the learning of domain-invariant features while suppressing domain-specific features, so that a model can generalise better to previously unseen target domains. An approach to domain generalisation for object detection is proposed, the first such approach applicable to any object detection architecture. Based on a rigorous mathematical analysis, we extend approaches based on feature alignment with a novel component for performing class conditional alignment at the instance level, in addition to aligning the marginal feature distributions across domains at the image level. This allows us to fully address both components of domain shift, i.e. covariate and concept shift, and learn a domain agnostic feature representation. We perform extensive evaluation with both one-stage (FCOS, YOLO) and two-stage (FRCNN) detectors, on a newly proposed benchmark comprising several different datasets for autonomous driving applications (Cityscapes, BDD10K, ACDC, IDD) as well as the GWHD dataset for precision agriculture, and show consistent improvements to the generalisation and localisation performance over baselines and state-of-the-art.
6/18/2024
Algorithmic Fairness Generalization under Covariate and Dependence Shifts Simultaneously
Chen Zhao, Kai Jiang, Xintao Wu, Haoliang Wang, Latifur Khan, Christan Grant, Feng Chen
0
0
The endeavor to preserve the generalization of a fair and invariant classifier across domains, especially in the presence of distribution shifts, becomes a significant and intricate challenge in machine learning. In response to this challenge, numerous effective algorithms have been developed with a focus on addressing the problem of fairness-aware domain generalization. These algorithms are designed to navigate various types of distribution shifts, with a particular emphasis on covariate and dependence shifts. In this context, covariate shift pertains to changes in the marginal distribution of input features, while dependence shift involves alterations in the joint distribution of the label variable and sensitive attributes. In this paper, we introduce a simple but effective approach that aims to learn a fair and invariant classifier by simultaneously addressing both covariate and dependence shifts across domains. We assert the existence of an underlying transformation model can transform data from one domain to another, while preserving the semantics related to non-sensitive attributes and classes. By augmenting various synthetic data domains through the model, we learn a fair and invariant classifier in source domains. This classifier can then be generalized to unknown target domains, maintaining both model prediction and fairness concerns. Extensive empirical studies on four benchmark datasets demonstrate that our approach surpasses state-of-the-art methods.
5/22/2024
🔄
An adaptive transfer learning perspective on classification in non-stationary environments
Henry W J Reeve
0
0
We consider a semi-supervised classification problem with non-stationary label-shift in which we observe a labelled data set followed by a sequence of unlabelled covariate vectors in which the marginal probabilities of the class labels may change over time. Our objective is to predict the corresponding class-label for each covariate vector, without ever observing the ground-truth labels, beyond the initial labelled data set. Previous work has demonstrated the potential of sophisticated variants of online gradient descent to perform competitively with the optimal dynamic strategy (Bai et al. 2022). In this work we explore an alternative approach grounded in statistical methods for adaptive transfer learning. We demonstrate the merits of this alternative methodology by establishing a high-probability regret bound on the test error at any given individual test-time, which adapt automatically to the unknown dynamics of the marginal label probabilities. Further more, we give bounds on the average dynamic regret which match the average guarantees of the online learning perspective for any given time interval.
5/29/2024