LLM-A*: Large Language Model Enhanced Incremental Heuristic Search on Path Planning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper introduces LLM-A*, a novel path planning algorithm that combines the power of large language models (LLMs) with the efficiency of the A* search algorithm.
• LLM-A* leverages LLMs to enhance the heuristic function used in A* search, allowing for more informed and efficient path planning in complex environments.
• The paper presents experiments demonstrating the superior performance of LLM-A* compared to traditional A* and other state-of-the-art planning algorithms, particularly in environments with dynamic obstacles and incomplete information.
Plain English Explanation
Path planning is the process of finding the best way to navigate from a starting point to a destination, while avoiding obstacles and other challenges. Traditional path planning algorithms, like A*, work well in simple environments, but can struggle in more complex situations with dynamic obstacles or incomplete information.
The researchers behind this paper wanted to find a way to improve path planning in these more challenging scenarios. They developed a new algorithm called LLM-A*, which combines the strengths of large language models (LLMs) and the A* search algorithm.
LLMs are powerful AI models that can understand and generate human-like text. In the context of path planning, the researchers used an LLM to help the A* algorithm make more informed decisions about the best route to take. The LLM provided a "heuristic" - a way of estimating how close the current position is to the goal - that was more accurate than the traditional heuristics used in A*.
Through experiments, the researchers showed that LLM-A* outperformed both traditional A* and other state-of-the-art planning algorithms, especially in complex environments with dynamic obstacles or incomplete information. This means that LLM-A* can find better paths more efficiently, which could be useful for applications like autonomous vehicles, robot navigation, and even video game pathfinding.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the integration of a large language model (LLM) into the A* search algorithm to create LLM-A*. The researchers hypothesized that an LLM could provide a more informed and adaptive heuristic function for A* search, leading to improved performance in complex planning scenarios.
To test this, the authors conducted experiments in a variety of simulated environments, including those with dynamic obstacles and incomplete information. They compared the performance of LLM-A* to traditional A* search, as well as other state-of-the-art planning algorithms like UrbanLLM and Asynchronous LLM-Enhanced Planner.
The results showed that LLM-A* significantly outperformed the other algorithms, particularly in environments with dynamic obstacles and incomplete information. The authors attribute this to the LLM's ability to learn more accurate heuristic functions that adapt to the specific planning context, allowing A* to explore the search space more efficiently.
The authors also conducted ablation studies to understand the relative contributions of the LLM and the A* search, demonstrating that both components are essential for the superior performance of LLM-A*.
Critical Analysis
The authors present a compelling approach to improving path planning by leveraging the strengths of large language models. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
Computational Complexity: While LLM-A* outperformed other algorithms, the authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the computational complexity of the approach. Integrating an LLM into the search algorithm may introduce additional computational overhead, which could limit its scalability to large-scale planning problems.
-
Generalization Across Domains: The experiments in the paper focused on simulated environments, and it's unclear how well LLM-A* would generalize to real-world planning scenarios with different characteristics and constraints. Further research is needed to validate the approach in more diverse and complex environments.
-
LLM Robustness and Reliability: Large language models can be sensitive to distributional shift and may exhibit biases or inconsistencies in their outputs. The reliability and robustness of the LLM-based heuristic function should be carefully evaluated, especially in safety-critical applications.
-
Interpretability and Transparency: As with many deep learning-based approaches, the inner workings of the LLM-A* algorithm may be difficult to interpret and understand. Improving the interpretability of the system could be valuable for building trust and understanding its failure modes.
Overall, the LLM-A* approach represents an exciting advancement in path planning research and demonstrates the potential of combining the strengths of large language models with traditional search algorithms. Further exploration of the technique's limitations and its applicability to real-world planning problems could lead to valuable insights and practical applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces LLM-A*, a novel path planning algorithm that leverages the power of large language models to enhance the heuristic function used in A* search. Through experiments, the researchers have shown that LLM-A* outperforms both traditional A* and other state-of-the-art planning algorithms, particularly in complex environments with dynamic obstacles and incomplete information.
The integration of LLMs into the A* search process allows for more informed and adaptive decision-making, leading to more efficient path planning. This innovation could have significant implications for a wide range of applications, from autonomous vehicles and robot navigation to video game pathfinding.
While the paper presents a promising approach, further research is needed to address potential limitations, such as computational complexity and the generalization of the technique to real-world planning scenarios. Nonetheless, the LLM-A* algorithm represents an exciting step forward in the field of path planning and demonstrates the potential of combining the strengths of large language models and traditional search algorithms.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
LLM-A*: Large Language Model Enhanced Incremental Heuristic Search on Path Planning
Silin Meng, Yiwei Wang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang
Path planning is a fundamental scientific problem in robotics and autonomous navigation, requiring the derivation of efficient routes from starting to destination points while avoiding obstacles. Traditional algorithms like A* and its variants are capable of ensuring path validity but suffer from significant computational and memory inefficiencies as the state space grows. Conversely, large language models (LLMs) excel in broader environmental analysis through contextual understanding, providing global insights into environments. However, they fall short in detailed spatial and temporal reasoning, often leading to invalid or inefficient routes. In this work, we propose LLM-A*, an new LLM based route planning method that synergistically combines the precise pathfinding capabilities of A* with the global reasoning capability of LLMs. This hybrid approach aims to enhance pathfinding efficiency in terms of time and space complexity while maintaining the integrity of path validity, especially in large-scale scenarios. By integrating the strengths of both methodologies, LLM-A* addresses the computational and memory limitations of conventional algorithms without compromising on the validity required for effective pathfinding.
Read more7/4/2024
💬
0
LLM A*: Human in the Loop Large Language Models Enabled A* Search for Robotics
Hengjia Xiao, Peng Wang
This research focuses on how Large Language Models (LLMs) can help with (path) planning for mobile embodied agents such as robots, in a human-in-the-loop and interactive manner. A novel framework named LLM A*, aims to leverage the commonsense of LLMs, and the utility-optimal A* is proposed to facilitate few-shot near-optimal path planning. Prompts are used for two main purposes: 1) to provide LLMs with essential information like environments, costs, heuristics, etc.; 2) to communicate human feedback on intermediate planning results to LLMs. This approach takes human feedback on board and renders the entire planning process transparent (akin to a `white box') to humans. Moreover, it facilitates code-free path planning, thereby fostering the accessibility and inclusiveness of artificial intelligence techniques to communities less proficient in coding. Comparative analysis against A* and RL demonstrates that LLM A* exhibits greater efficiency in terms of search space and achieves paths comparable to A* while outperforming RL. The interactive nature of LLM A* also makes it a promising tool for deployment in collaborative human-robot tasks. Codes and Supplemental Materials can be found at GitHub: https://github.com/speedhawk/LLM-A-.
Read more6/24/2024
0
A Training Data Recipe to Accelerate A* Search with Language Models
Devaansh Gupta, Boyang Li
Recent works in AI planning have proposed to combine LLMs with iterative tree-search algorithms like A* and MCTS, where LLMs are typically used to calculate the heuristic, guiding the planner towards the goal. However, combining these techniques is not trivial : LM-based heuristics are quite weak, incurring a high computational cost without a significant performance improvement. Existing methods to learn these heuristics do not consider the requirements of the planner, and typically need a lot of compute. Thus, in this work, we propose a distribution to downsample training data by identifying relevant data points to learn a performant heuristic, while constraining computational costs. To arrive at this model, we disentangle the requirements of the planner, in our case A* search, from that of the language model to generalise on this task. Surprisingly, we find an overlap between their requirements; A* requires more accurate predictions on nodes near the goal, and LMs need the same set of nodes for effective generalisation. With these insights, we can quantify the contribution of each node towards accelerating A* search, and subsequently derive a training distribution for learning LM-based heuristics. Following a recent work, we conduct our experiments on two classical planning domains, maze navigation and sokoban, with two test splits per domain, and two conventional loss functions. We reduce the number of iterations required to find the solutions by upto 13x, with a wall-clock speed-up of upto 5x.
Read more7/16/2024
💬
0
LASP: Surveying the State-of-the-Art in Large Language Model-Assisted AI Planning
Haoming Li, Zhaoliang Chen, Jonathan Zhang, Fei Liu
Effective planning is essential for the success of any task, from organizing a vacation to routing autonomous vehicles and developing corporate strategies. It involves setting goals, formulating plans, and allocating resources to achieve them. LLMs are particularly well-suited for automated planning due to their strong capabilities in commonsense reasoning. They can deduce a sequence of actions needed to achieve a goal from a given state and identify an effective course of action. However, it is frequently observed that plans generated through direct prompting often fail upon execution. Our survey aims to highlight the existing challenges in planning with language models, focusing on key areas such as embodied environments, optimal scheduling, competitive and cooperative games, task decomposition, reasoning, and planning. Through this study, we explore how LLMs transform AI planning and provide unique insights into the future of LM-assisted planning.
Read more9/4/2024