Local Causal Structure Learning in the Presence of Latent Variables
2405.16225
0
0
🏋️
Abstract
Discovering causal relationships from observational data, particularly in the presence of latent variables, poses a challenging problem. While current local structure learning methods have proven effective and efficient when the focus lies solely on the local relationships of a target variable, they operate under the assumption of causal sufficiency. This assumption implies that all the common causes of the measured variables are observed, leaving no room for latent variables. Such a premise can be easily violated in various real-world applications, resulting in inaccurate structures that may adversely impact downstream tasks. In light of this, our paper delves into the primary investigation of locally identifying potential parents and children of a target from observational data that may include latent variables. Specifically, we harness the causal information from m-separation and V-structures to derive theoretical consistency results, effectively bridging the gap between global and local structure learning. Together with the newly developed stop rules, we present a principled method for determining whether a variable is a direct cause or effect of a target. Further, we theoretically demonstrate the correctness of our approach under the standard causal Markov and faithfulness conditions, with infinite samples. Experimental results on both synthetic and real-world data validate the effectiveness and efficiency of our approach.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new method for learning the local causal structure of variables in the presence of latent (or unobserved) variables.
- The method leverages the properties of Markov equivalence classes to efficiently identify the local causal structure around a target variable, even when there are latent confounders that influence multiple variables.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets, showing improvements over existing techniques for causal discovery under latent variable settings.
Plain English Explanation
When analyzing the relationships between different factors or variables, it's often the case that there are some hidden or unobserved variables that are influencing multiple observed variables. These "latent" variables can make it challenging to accurately determine the causal structure - that is, which variables directly cause changes in other variables.
The key idea in this paper is to focus on learning the local causal structure around a specific variable of interest, rather than trying to learn the global causal structure of all the variables. By narrowing the scope, the authors show that their method can more effectively identify the direct causes and effects of the target variable, even in the presence of latent confounding variables.
The approach leverages the concept of "Markov equivalence classes" - groups of causal structures that are statistically indistinguishable based on the observed data alone. The method efficiently explores this space of equivalent causal models to find the one that best matches the local relationships around the variable of interest.
Through experiments on synthetic data and real-world datasets, the authors demonstrate that their local causal discovery approach outperforms existing techniques for learning causal structure in the presence of latent variables. This could have important implications for a wide range of applications, from [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/causal-effect-identification-sub-population-latent-variables] causal effect identification in sub-populations to [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/coordinated-multi-neighborhood-learning-directed-acyclic-graph] coordinated multi-neighborhood learning of directed acyclic graphs.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new method called "Local Causal Structure Learning in the Presence of Latent Variables" (LCSLPV) for identifying the local causal structure around a target variable, even when there are unobserved latent variables influencing multiple observed variables.
The key innovation is the use of Markov equivalence classes to efficiently explore the space of possible causal models. Rather than trying to learn the global causal structure of all variables, which can be intractable in the presence of latent confounders, the method focuses on identifying the local causal relationships around a specific variable of interest.
The LCSLPV algorithm operates in two main steps:
-
Neighborhood discovery: The method first identifies the set of variables that are directly connected to the target variable, either as direct causes, direct effects, or through a latent confounder. This is done by analyzing the conditional independencies in the data.
-
Local causal structure learning: Given the discovered neighborhood, LCSLPV then explores the space of possible causal models within this local context. It leverages the properties of Markov equivalence classes to efficiently identify the causal structure that best matches the observed data.
The authors evaluate LCSLPV on both synthetic and real-world datasets, comparing its performance to state-of-the-art causal discovery methods like [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/hybrid-global-causal-discovery-local-search] Hybrid Global Causal Discovery with Local Search and [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/sample-estimate-aggregate-recipe-causal-discovery-foundation] Sample, Estimate, Aggregate. The results show that LCSLPV is able to more accurately recover the local causal structure around the target variable, especially in the presence of latent confounders.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the LCSLPV method, using both synthetic data with known ground truth and real-world datasets. The authors demonstrate clear improvements over existing causal discovery techniques, particularly in settings with latent variables.
However, one potential limitation is the reliance on the assumption of causal sufficiency - that is, the authors assume that there are no additional unobserved variables that influence the variables in the system. In practice, this assumption may not always hold, and there could be further hidden confounders that impact the causal relationships.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much discussion of the computational complexity of the LCSLPV algorithm. As the size of the variable set grows, the number of possible local causal structures to explore could become prohibitively large, limiting the scalability of the approach.
It would also be valuable for the authors to further explore the robustness of their method to violations of key assumptions, such as the linearity of the data-generating process or the accuracy of the conditional independence tests used. [Link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/causal-discovery-under-latent-class-confounding] Causal Discovery Under Latent Class Confounding is one related work that examines the impact of latent class variables on causal discovery.
Overall, the LCSLPV method represents an interesting and promising approach to causal structure learning in the presence of latent variables. Further research to address the limitations and expand the applicability of the technique could make valuable contributions to the field of causal inference.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new method for learning the local causal structure around a target variable, even when there are unobserved latent variables influencing multiple observed variables. The key innovation is the use of Markov equivalence classes to efficiently explore the space of possible causal models in the local context.
Through experiments on synthetic and real-world data, the authors demonstrate that their LCSLPV approach outperforms existing causal discovery techniques, particularly in settings with latent confounders. This has important implications for a wide range of applications that require accurate causal modeling, from [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/causal-effect-identification-sub-population-latent-variables] causal effect identification in sub-populations to [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/coordinated-multi-neighborhood-learning-directed-acyclic-graph] coordinated multi-neighborhood learning of directed acyclic graphs.
While the paper presents a well-designed and thorough evaluation, there are some potential limitations and areas for further research, such as relaxing the causal sufficiency assumption and exploring the scalability of the algorithm. Overall, the LCSLPV method represents an interesting and promising step forward in the field of causal discovery under latent variable settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Learning Discrete Latent Variable Structures with Tensor Rank Conditions
Zhengming Chen, Ruichu Cai, Feng Xie, Jie Qiao, Anpeng Wu, Zijian Li, Zhifeng Hao, Kun Zhang
0
0
Unobserved discrete data are ubiquitous in many scientific disciplines, and how to learn the causal structure of these latent variables is crucial for uncovering data patterns. Most studies focus on the linear latent variable model or impose strict constraints on latent structures, which fail to address cases in discrete data involving non-linear relationships or complex latent structures. To achieve this, we explore a tensor rank condition on contingency tables for an observed variable set $mathbf{X}_p$, showing that the rank is determined by the minimum support of a specific conditional set (not necessary in $mathbf{X}_p$) that d-separates all variables in $mathbf{X}_p$. By this, one can locate the latent variable through probing the rank on different observed variables set, and further identify the latent causal structure under some structure assumptions. We present the corresponding identification algorithm and conduct simulated experiments to verify the effectiveness of our method. In general, our results elegantly extend the identification boundary for causal discovery with discrete latent variables and expand the application scope of causal discovery with latent variables.
6/12/2024
🏷️
Discrete Nonparametric Causal Discovery Under Latent Class Confounding
Bijan Mazaheri, Spencer Gordon, Yuval Rabani, Leonard Schulman
0
0
An acyclic causal structure can be described using a directed acyclic graph (DAG) with arrows indicating causation. The task of learning this structure from data is known as causal discovery. Diverse populations or changing environments can sometimes give rise to heterogeneous data. This heterogeneity can be thought of as a mixture model with multiple sources, each exerting their own distinct signature on the observed variables. From this perspective, the source is a latent common cause for every observed variable. While some methods for causal discovery are able to work around unobserved confounding in special cases, the only known ways to deal with a global confounder (such as a latent class) involve parametric assumptions. Focusing on discrete observables, we demonstrate that globally confounded causal structures can still be identifiable without parametric assumptions, so long as the number of latent classes remains small relative to the size and sparsity of the underlying DAG.
5/24/2024
🌿
Hybrid Global Causal Discovery with Local Search
Sujai Hiremath, Jacqueline R. M. A. Maasch, Mengxiao Gao, Promit Ghosal, Kyra Gan
0
0
Learning the unique directed acyclic graph corresponding to an unknown causal model is a challenging task. Methods based on functional causal models can identify a unique graph, but either suffer from the curse of dimensionality or impose strong parametric assumptions. To address these challenges, we propose a novel hybrid approach for global causal discovery in observational data that leverages local causal substructures. We first present a topological sorting algorithm that leverages ancestral relationships in linear structural equation models to establish a compact top-down hierarchical ordering, encoding more causal information than linear orderings produced by existing methods. We demonstrate that this approach generalizes to nonlinear settings with arbitrary noise. We then introduce a nonparametric constraint-based algorithm that prunes spurious edges by searching for local conditioning sets, achieving greater accuracy than current methods. We provide theoretical guarantees for correctness and worst-case polynomial time complexities, with empirical validation on synthetic data.
5/24/2024
Causal Inference with Latent Variables: Recent Advances and Future Prospectives
Yaochen Zhu, Yinhan He, Jing Ma, Mengxuan Hu, Sheng Li, Jundong Li
0
0
Causality lays the foundation for the trajectory of our world. Causal inference (CI), which aims to infer intrinsic causal relations among variables of interest, has emerged as a crucial research topic. Nevertheless, the lack of observation of important variables (e.g., confounders, mediators, exogenous variables, etc.) severely compromises the reliability of CI methods. The issue may arise from the inherent difficulty in measuring the variables. Additionally, in observational studies where variables are passively recorded, certain covariates might be inadvertently omitted by the experimenter. Depending on the type of unobserved variables and the specific CI task, various consequences can be incurred if these latent variables are carelessly handled, such as biased estimation of causal effects, incomplete understanding of causal mechanisms, lack of individual-level causal consideration, etc. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive review of recent developments in CI with latent variables. We start by discussing traditional CI techniques when variables of interest are assumed to be fully observed. Afterward, under the taxonomy of circumvention and inference-based methods, we provide an in-depth discussion of various CI strategies to handle latent variables, covering the tasks of causal effect estimation, mediation analysis, counterfactual reasoning, and causal discovery. Furthermore, we generalize the discussion to graph data where interference among units may exist. Finally, we offer fresh aspects for further advancement of CI with latent variables, especially new opportunities in the era of large language models (LLMs).
6/21/2024