Causal Inference with Latent Variables: Recent Advances and Future Prospectives
2406.13966
0
0
Abstract
Causality lays the foundation for the trajectory of our world. Causal inference (CI), which aims to infer intrinsic causal relations among variables of interest, has emerged as a crucial research topic. Nevertheless, the lack of observation of important variables (e.g., confounders, mediators, exogenous variables, etc.) severely compromises the reliability of CI methods. The issue may arise from the inherent difficulty in measuring the variables. Additionally, in observational studies where variables are passively recorded, certain covariates might be inadvertently omitted by the experimenter. Depending on the type of unobserved variables and the specific CI task, various consequences can be incurred if these latent variables are carelessly handled, such as biased estimation of causal effects, incomplete understanding of causal mechanisms, lack of individual-level causal consideration, etc. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive review of recent developments in CI with latent variables. We start by discussing traditional CI techniques when variables of interest are assumed to be fully observed. Afterward, under the taxonomy of circumvention and inference-based methods, we provide an in-depth discussion of various CI strategies to handle latent variables, covering the tasks of causal effect estimation, mediation analysis, counterfactual reasoning, and causal discovery. Furthermore, we generalize the discussion to graph data where interference among units may exist. Finally, we offer fresh aspects for further advancement of CI with latent variables, especially new opportunities in the era of large language models (LLMs).
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper discusses recent advances and future prospects in causal inference with latent variables.
- It covers topics like confounding analysis, causal discovery under latent class confounding, and identifiable causal inference with noisy treatment and no side information.
- The paper aims to provide a comprehensive review of the latest research in this area and highlight promising future directions.
Plain English Explanation
Causal inference is the study of how changes in one factor (the "cause") lead to changes in another factor (the "effect"). This is an important area of research with applications in fields like medicine, social science, and economics.
However, real-world data often contains "latent variables" - factors that influence the causal relationships but are not directly observed. This can make it challenging to accurately infer causal effects.
This paper examines recent progress in addressing these challenges. For example, it discusses methods for learning discrete concepts from latent hierarchical models and causal discovery via conditional independence testing with proxy variables.
The paper also explores more advanced topics, like causal discovery under latent class confounding and identifiable causal inference with noisy treatment and no side information.
Overall, this research aims to improve our ability to draw reliable causal conclusions from complex, real-world data - an important goal with many practical applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing an overview of the key concepts in causal inference with latent variables. It introduces the challenges posed by latent confounding, where unobserved factors influence both the "treatment" and "outcome" variables of interest.
The authors then review recent methodological advances in this area. For example, they discuss approaches for learning the underlying causal structure in the presence of latent variables, which can help identify the causal pathways.
The paper also covers techniques for causal discovery under latent class confounding, where the confounding factors are not observed directly but manifest as distinct latent classes in the data. Methods for identifiable causal inference with noisy treatment and no side information are also discussed, addressing settings where the treatment variable is measured with error and no auxiliary variables are available.
Throughout the technical review, the authors highlight the key insights, assumptions, and limitations of the various approaches. They also discuss promising future research directions, such as extending these methods to more complex data structures and exploring the interplay between causal inference and representation learning.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art in causal inference with latent variables, a topic of growing importance as researchers seek to draw reliable causal conclusions from increasingly complex, high-dimensional data.
One potential limitation is that the technical details of the reviewed methods may still be challenging for a general audience to fully grasp. The authors could have perhaps included more illustrative examples or intuitive explanations to bridge the gap between the mathematical formalism and practical understanding.
Additionally, while the paper covers a wide range of recent advances, it does not delve deeply into the comparative merits and drawbacks of the different approaches. A more critical analysis of the trade-offs, such as computational efficiency, robustness to model misspecification, and ease of interpretability, could have provided readers with a more comprehensive evaluation of the state of the field.
Nevertheless, the paper serves as a valuable reference for researchers and practitioners interested in the latest developments in causal inference with latent variables. It highlights the significant progress made in this area and points to exciting future avenues of exploration.
Conclusion
This paper provides a thorough review of recent advances in causal inference with latent variables, a crucial topic for drawing reliable causal conclusions from complex, real-world data. The authors cover a range of cutting-edge methods, from causal structure learning to causal discovery under latent confounding, and discuss their theoretical insights and practical implications.
While the technical details may still be challenging for some readers, the paper serves as an important resource for researchers and practitioners in this rapidly evolving field. By highlighting the latest breakthroughs and outlining promising future directions, the authors contribute to the ongoing efforts to improve our understanding of causal relationships in the presence of unobserved factors.
Ultimately, this research aims to enhance our ability to make informed, evidence-based decisions in a wide range of domains, from public health interventions to economic policy-making. As such, it represents a valuable step forward in the pursuit of more robust and reliable causal inference.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
šļø
Local Causal Structure Learning in the Presence of Latent Variables
Feng Xie, Zheng Li, Peng Wu, Yan Zeng, Chunchen Liu, Zhi Geng
0
0
Discovering causal relationships from observational data, particularly in the presence of latent variables, poses a challenging problem. While current local structure learning methods have proven effective and efficient when the focus lies solely on the local relationships of a target variable, they operate under the assumption of causal sufficiency. This assumption implies that all the common causes of the measured variables are observed, leaving no room for latent variables. Such a premise can be easily violated in various real-world applications, resulting in inaccurate structures that may adversely impact downstream tasks. In light of this, our paper delves into the primary investigation of locally identifying potential parents and children of a target from observational data that may include latent variables. Specifically, we harness the causal information from m-separation and V-structures to derive theoretical consistency results, effectively bridging the gap between global and local structure learning. Together with the newly developed stop rules, we present a principled method for determining whether a variable is a direct cause or effect of a target. Further, we theoretically demonstrate the correctness of our approach under the standard causal Markov and faithfulness conditions, with infinite samples. Experimental results on both synthetic and real-world data validate the effectiveness and efficiency of our approach.
6/7/2024
Learning Discrete Concepts in Latent Hierarchical Models
Lingjing Kong, Guangyi Chen, Biwei Huang, Eric P. Xing, Yuejie Chi, Kun Zhang
0
0
Learning concepts from natural high-dimensional data (e.g., images) holds potential in building human-aligned and interpretable machine learning models. Despite its encouraging prospect, formalization and theoretical insights into this crucial task are still lacking. In this work, we formalize concepts as discrete latent causal variables that are related via a hierarchical causal model that encodes different abstraction levels of concepts embedded in high-dimensional data (e.g., a dog breed and its eye shapes in natural images). We formulate conditions to facilitate the identification of the proposed causal model, which reveals when learning such concepts from unsupervised data is possible. Our conditions permit complex causal hierarchical structures beyond latent trees and multi-level directed acyclic graphs in prior work and can handle high-dimensional, continuous observed variables, which is well-suited for unstructured data modalities such as images. We substantiate our theoretical claims with synthetic data experiments. Further, we discuss our theory's implications for understanding the underlying mechanisms of latent diffusion models and provide corresponding empirical evidence for our theoretical insights.
6/4/2024
š§Ŗ
Causal Discovery via Conditional Independence Testing with Proxy Variables
Mingzhou Liu, Xinwei Sun, Yu Qiao, Yizhou Wang
0
0
Distinguishing causal connections from correlations is important in many scenarios. However, the presence of unobserved variables, such as the latent confounder, can introduce bias in conditional independence testing commonly employed in constraint-based causal discovery for identifying causal relations. To address this issue, existing methods introduced proxy variables to adjust for the bias caused by unobserveness. However, these methods were either limited to categorical variables or relied on strong parametric assumptions for identification. In this paper, we propose a novel hypothesis-testing procedure that can effectively examine the existence of the causal relationship over continuous variables, without any parametric constraint. Our procedure is based on discretization, which under completeness conditions, is able to asymptotically establish a linear equation whose coefficient vector is identifiable under the causal null hypothesis. Based on this, we introduce our test statistic and demonstrate its asymptotic level and power. We validate the effectiveness of our procedure using both synthetic and real-world data.
5/3/2024
Latent Variable Sequence Identification for Cognitive Models with Neural Bayes Estimation
Ti-Fen Pan, Jing-Jing Li, Bill Thompson, Anne Collins
0
0
Extracting time-varying latent variables from computational cognitive models is a key step in model-based neural analysis, which aims to understand the neural correlates of cognitive processes. However, existing methods only allow researchers to infer latent variables that explain subjects' behavior in a relatively small class of cognitive models. For example, a broad class of relevant cognitive models with analytically intractable likelihood is currently out of reach from standard techniques, based on Maximum a Posteriori parameter estimation. Here, we present an approach that extends neural Bayes estimation to learn a direct mapping between experimental data and the targeted latent variable space using recurrent neural networks and simulated datasets. We show that our approach achieves competitive performance in inferring latent variable sequences in both tractable and intractable models. Furthermore, the approach is generalizable across different computational models and is adaptable for both continuous and discrete latent spaces. We then demonstrate its applicability in real world datasets. Our work underscores that combining recurrent neural networks and simulation-based inference to identify latent variable sequences can enable researchers to access a wider class of cognitive models for model-based neural analyses, and thus test a broader set of theories.
6/24/2024