Looking Right is Sometimes Right: Investigating the Capabilities of Decoder-only LLMs for Sequence Labeling
2401.14556
0
0
Abstract
Pre-trained language models based on masked language modeling (MLM) excel in natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. While fine-tuned MLM-based encoders consistently outperform causal language modeling decoders of comparable size, recent decoder-only large language models (LLMs) perform on par with smaller MLM-based encoders. Although their performance improves with scale, LLMs fall short of achieving state-of-the-art results in information extraction (IE) tasks, many of which are formulated as sequence labeling (SL). We hypothesize that LLMs' poor SL performance stems from causal masking, which prevents the model from attending to tokens on the right of the current token. Yet, how exactly and to what extent LLMs' performance on SL can be improved remains unclear. We explore techniques for improving the SL performance of open LLMs on IE tasks by applying layer-wise removal of the causal mask (CM) during LLM fine-tuning. This approach yields performance gains competitive with state-of-the-art SL models, matching or outperforming the results of CM removal from all blocks. Our findings hold for diverse SL tasks, demonstrating that open LLMs with layer-dependent CM removal outperform strong MLM-based encoders and even instruction-tuned LLMs.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the capabilities of decoder-based large language models (LLMs) for sequence labeling tasks, which involve assigning labels to individual elements in a sequence of data.
- The researchers explore whether these powerful LLMs, typically used for text generation, can also be effectively applied to sequence labeling problems without requiring significant architectural changes.
- The findings have implications for the versatility and broad applicability of LLMs, as well as potential trade-offs between accuracy and efficiency when adapting these models to different tasks.
Plain English Explanation
Decoder-based large language models (LLMs) are artificial intelligence systems that are incredibly good at generating human-like text. These models, such as GPT-3, have become increasingly powerful and versatile.
In this paper, the researchers wanted to see if these LLMs could also be used for a different type of task: sequence labeling. Sequence labeling involves taking a sequence of data, such as a sentence, and assigning labels to each individual element in the sequence. For example, in a sentence about a person, you might label each word as either a person's name, a location, or something else.
Traditionally, sequence labeling tasks have been tackled using specialized models that are designed for that specific purpose. The researchers were curious to see if the powerful LLMs could handle these sequence labeling tasks without requiring major changes to their architecture.
Their findings suggest that LLMs can indeed be effective for sequence labeling, but there may be trade-offs in terms of accuracy and efficiency compared to more specialized models. This is an important insight, as it shows the versatility of LLMs and opens up new possibilities for how these powerful AI systems can be applied to a variety of real-world problems.
Technical Explanation
The researchers in this paper investigate the capabilities of decoder-based large language models (LLMs) for sequence labeling tasks. Sequence labeling involves assigning labels to individual elements in a sequence of data, such as words in a sentence.
Traditionally, sequence labeling tasks have been tackled using specialized models that are designed for that specific purpose. However, the researchers were interested in exploring whether powerful LLMs, which are typically used for text generation, could also be effectively applied to sequence labeling problems without requiring significant architectural changes.
To explore this, the researchers conducted a series of experiments using the LLAMA LLM as a base model. They fine-tuned LLAMA on various sequence labeling benchmarks, including named entity recognition, part-of-speech tagging, and semantic role labeling.
The results of their experiments suggest that LLMs can indeed be effective for sequence labeling tasks, achieving competitive performance compared to specialized models. However, the researchers also note that there may be trade-offs in terms of accuracy and efficiency when using LLMs for these tasks, compared to models designed specifically for sequence labeling.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides an interesting and important exploration of the capabilities of decoder-based LLMs for sequence labeling tasks. The researchers' findings suggest that these powerful language models can be effectively applied to a wider range of problems beyond their traditional text generation use case.
However, the paper also acknowledges some potential limitations and trade-offs. While LLMs can achieve competitive performance on sequence labeling tasks, the researchers note that specialized models may still outperform them in terms of accuracy and efficiency. This is an important caveat that readers should keep in mind when considering the implications of this research.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the interpretability of the LLM's sequence labeling decisions, which could be an important consideration for real-world applications. Understanding how these models arrive at their predictions may be crucial for ensuring transparency and trust in their use.
Further research could also investigate the generalization of these findings to a broader range of sequence labeling tasks and datasets, as well as explore potential architectural or fine-tuning approaches that could enhance the performance of LLMs in these domains.
Conclusion
This paper presents an insightful exploration of the capabilities of decoder-based large language models (LLMs) for sequence labeling tasks. The researchers' findings suggest that these powerful AI systems can be effectively applied to a wider range of problems beyond their traditional text generation use case.
The results highlight the versatility of LLMs and open up new possibilities for how these models can be leveraged to tackle real-world challenges. However, the paper also notes potential trade-offs in terms of accuracy and efficiency compared to specialized sequence labeling models, which is an important consideration for practitioners and researchers alike.
As the field of AI continues to advance, this work contributes to our understanding of the strengths and limitations of LLMs, and it encourages further exploration of how these technologies can be adapted and applied to a diverse array of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
Exploration of Masked and Causal Language Modelling for Text Generation
Nicolo Micheletti, Samuel Belkadi, Lifeng Han, Goran Nenadic
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionised the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and have achieved state-of-the-art performance in practically every task in this field. However, the prevalent approach used in text generation, Causal Language Modelling (CLM), which generates text sequentially from left to right, inherently limits the freedom of the model, which does not decide when and where each token is generated. In contrast, Masked Language Modelling (MLM), primarily used for language understanding tasks, can generate tokens anywhere in the text and any order. This paper conducts an extensive comparison of MLM and CLM approaches for text generation tasks. To do so, we pre-train several language models of comparable sizes on three different datasets, namely 1) medical discharge summaries, 2) movie plot synopses, and 3) authorship verification datasets. To assess the quality of the generations, we first employ quantitative metrics and then perform a qualitative human evaluation to analyse coherence and grammatical correctness. In addition, we evaluate the usefulness of the generated texts by using them in three different downstream tasks: 1) Entity Recognition, 2) Text Classification, and 3) Authorship Verification. The results show that MLM consistently outperforms CLM in text generation across all datasets, with higher quantitative scores and better coherence in the generated text. The study also finds textit{no strong correlation} between the quality of the generated text and the performance of the models in the downstream tasks. With this study, we show that MLM for text generation has great potential for future research and provides direction for future studies in this area.
5/22/2024
LLM2Vec: Large Language Models Are Secretly Powerful Text Encoders
Parishad BehnamGhader, Vaibhav Adlakha, Marius Mosbach, Dzmitry Bahdanau, Nicolas Chapados, Siva Reddy
0
0
Large decoder-only language models (LLMs) are the state-of-the-art models on most of today's NLP tasks and benchmarks. Yet, the community is only slowly adopting these models for text embedding tasks, which require rich contextualized representations. In this work, we introduce LLM2Vec, a simple unsupervised approach that can transform any decoder-only LLM into a strong text encoder. LLM2Vec consists of three simple steps: 1) enabling bidirectional attention, 2) masked next token prediction, and 3) unsupervised contrastive learning. We demonstrate the effectiveness of LLM2Vec by applying it to 3 popular LLMs ranging from 1.3B to 7B parameters and evaluate the transformed models on English word- and sequence-level tasks. We outperform encoder-only models by a large margin on word-level tasks and reach a new unsupervised state-of-the-art performance on the Massive Text Embeddings Benchmark (MTEB). Moreover, when combining LLM2Vec with supervised contrastive learning, we achieve state-of-the-art performance on MTEB among models that train only on publicly available data. Our strong empirical results and extensive analysis demonstrate that LLMs can be effectively transformed into universal text encoders in a parameter-efficient manner without the need for expensive adaptation or synthetic GPT-4 generated data.
4/10/2024
A Thorough Examination of Decoding Methods in the Era of LLMs
Chufan Shi, Haoran Yang, Deng Cai, Zhisong Zhang, Yifan Wang, Yujiu Yang, Wai Lam
0
0
Decoding methods play an indispensable role in converting language models from next-token predictors into practical task solvers. Prior research on decoding methods, primarily focusing on task-specific models, may not extend to the current era of general-purpose large language models (LLMs). Moreover, the recent influx of decoding strategies has further complicated this landscape. This paper provides a comprehensive and multifaceted analysis of various decoding methods within the context of LLMs, evaluating their performance, robustness to hyperparameter changes, and decoding speeds across a wide range of tasks, models, and deployment environments. Our findings reveal that decoding method performance is notably task-dependent and influenced by factors such as alignment, model size, and quantization. Intriguingly, sensitivity analysis exposes that certain methods achieve superior performance at the cost of extensive hyperparameter tuning, highlighting the trade-off between attaining optimal results and the practicality of implementation in varying contexts.
6/18/2024
Adapting LLaMA Decoder to Vision Transformer
Jiahao Wang, Wenqi Shao, Mengzhao Chen, Chengyue Wu, Yong Liu, Taiqiang Wu, Kaipeng Zhang, Songyang Zhang, Kai Chen, Ping Luo
0
0
This work examines whether decoder-only Transformers such as LLaMA, which were originally designed for large language models (LLMs), can be adapted to the computer vision field. We first LLaMAfy a standard ViT step-by-step to align with LLaMA's architecture, and find that directly applying a causal mask to the self-attention brings an attention collapse issue, resulting in the failure to the network training. We suggest to reposition the class token behind the image tokens with a post-sequence class token technique to overcome this challenge, enabling causal self-attention to efficiently capture the entire image's information. Additionally, we develop a soft mask strategy that gradually introduces a causal mask to the self-attention at the onset of training to facilitate the optimization behavior. The tailored model, dubbed as image LLaMA (iLLaMA), is akin to LLaMA in architecture and enables direct supervised learning. Its causal self-attention boosts computational efficiency and learns complex representation by elevating attention map ranks. iLLaMA rivals the performance with its encoder-only counterparts, achieving 75.1% ImageNet top-1 accuracy with only 5.7M parameters. Scaling the model to $sim$310M and pre-training on ImageNet-21K further enhances the accuracy to 86.0%. Extensive experiments demonstrate iLLaMA's reliable properties: shape-texture bias, calibration, quantization compatibility, ADE20K segmentation and CIFAR transfer learning. We hope our study can kindle fresh views to visual architectures in the wave of LLMs and inspire the development of unified multimodal models. Pre-trained models and codes are available https://github.com/techmonsterwang/iLLaMA.
5/28/2024