The Marginal Value of Momentum for Small Learning Rate SGD
2307.15196
0
0
✨
Abstract
Momentum is known to accelerate the convergence of gradient descent in strongly convex settings without stochastic gradient noise. In stochastic optimization, such as training neural networks, folklore suggests that momentum may help deep learning optimization by reducing the variance of the stochastic gradient update, but previous theoretical analyses do not find momentum to offer any provable acceleration. Theoretical results in this paper clarify the role of momentum in stochastic settings where the learning rate is small and gradient noise is the dominant source of instability, suggesting that SGD with and without momentum behave similarly in the short and long time horizons. Experiments show that momentum indeed has limited benefits for both optimization and generalization in practical training regimes where the optimal learning rate is not very large, including small- to medium-batch training from scratch on ImageNet and fine-tuning language models on downstream tasks.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the role of momentum in stochastic optimization, such as training neural networks.
- Momentum is known to accelerate the convergence of gradient descent in strongly convex settings without stochastic gradient noise.
- However, previous theoretical analyses do not find momentum to offer any provable acceleration in stochastic settings like training neural networks.
- The paper aims to clarify the role of momentum in stochastic settings where the learning rate is small and gradient noise is the dominant source of instability.
Plain English Explanation
Gradient descent is a common optimization technique used in machine learning to train models like neural networks. Momentum is a method that can speed up the convergence of gradient descent in certain situations. However, when there is a lot of noise in the gradients, as is the case when training neural networks on large datasets, the benefits of momentum become less clear.
This paper looks at the effects of momentum in these noisy, stochastic optimization settings. The authors find that, contrary to popular belief, momentum may not provide much benefit for optimizing neural networks or improving their performance. When the learning rate is not too large, SGD with and without momentum behave similarly in both the short and long term.
The researchers demonstrate this through both theoretical analysis and practical experiments, including training small- to medium-sized models on the ImageNet dataset from scratch and fine-tuning language models on downstream tasks. The results suggest that the common folklore about momentum helping deep learning optimization may not always hold true, especially in realistic training regimes.
Technical Explanation
The paper starts by noting that while momentum is known to accelerate the convergence of gradient descent in strongly convex settings without stochastic gradient noise, previous theoretical analyses do not find momentum to offer any provable acceleration in stochastic optimization settings.
The authors then provide a theoretical analysis of the role of momentum in stochastic settings where the learning rate is small and gradient noise is the dominant source of instability. Their analysis suggests that SGD with and without momentum behave similarly in both the short and long time horizons in these regimes.
To validate their theoretical findings, the researchers conduct experiments on training neural networks. They consider small- to medium-batch training from scratch on ImageNet as well as fine-tuning language models on downstream tasks. The results show that momentum indeed has limited benefits for both optimization and generalization in these practical training regimes where the optimal learning rate is not very large.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thoughtful theoretical and empirical analysis of the role of momentum in stochastic optimization, particularly in the context of training neural networks. The authors acknowledge the limitations of their work, noting that their analysis focuses on settings where the learning rate is small and gradient noise is the dominant source of instability.
It would be interesting to see further exploration of momentum's potential benefits in other stochastic optimization regimes, such as those with larger learning rates or different noise characteristics. The authors also mention the possibility of momentum being more helpful for distributed learning, which could be an area for future research.
Additionally, the paper does not address the potential benefits of momentum for improving the stability or consistency of training diffusion models, which is an active area of research. Exploring momentum's role in these types of generative models could also be a fruitful direction.
Overall, the paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of momentum in stochastic optimization, challenging some common beliefs and offering a more nuanced perspective. The findings are likely to be of interest to researchers and practitioners working on the optimization of deep learning models.
Conclusion
This paper offers a deeper understanding of the role of momentum in stochastic optimization, particularly in the context of training neural networks. The authors provide both theoretical analysis and empirical evidence that, contrary to popular belief, momentum may not offer significant benefits for optimizing and generalizing neural networks in practical training regimes where the learning rate is not very large.
The findings suggest that the common folklore about momentum helping deep learning optimization may not always hold true, and that SGD with and without momentum can behave similarly in both the short and long term. These insights are likely to be useful for researchers and practitioners working on the optimization of machine learning models, encouraging them to critically evaluate the role of momentum in their specific use cases.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Role of Momentum in Smoothing Objective Function in Implicit Graduated Optimization
Naoki Sato, Hideaki Iiduka
0
0
For nonconvex objective functions, including deep neural networks, stochastic gradient descent (SGD) with momentum has fast convergence and excellent generalizability, but a theoretical explanation for this is lacking. In contrast to previous studies that defined the stochastic noise that occurs during optimization as the variance of the stochastic gradient, we define it as the gap between the search direction of the optimizer and the steepest descent direction and show that its level dominates generalizability of the model. We also show that the stochastic noise in SGD with momentum smoothes the objective function, the degree of which is determined by the learning rate, the batch size, the momentum factor, the variance of the stochastic gradient, and the upper bound of the gradient norm. By numerically deriving the stochastic noise level in SGD and SGD with momentum, we provide theoretical findings that help explain the training dynamics of SGD with momentum, which were not explained by previous studies on convergence and stability. We also provide experimental results supporting our assertion that model generalizability depends on the stochastic noise level.
5/29/2024
🏋️
Stochastic Normalized Gradient Descent with Momentum for Large-Batch Training
Shen-Yi Zhao, Chang-Wei Shi, Yin-Peng Xie, Wu-Jun Li
0
0
Stochastic gradient descent~(SGD) and its variants have been the dominating optimization methods in machine learning. Compared to SGD with small-batch training, SGD with large-batch training can better utilize the computational power of current multi-core systems such as graphics processing units~(GPUs) and can reduce the number of communication rounds in distributed training settings. Thus, SGD with large-batch training has attracted considerable attention. However, existing empirical results showed that large-batch training typically leads to a drop in generalization accuracy. Hence, how to guarantee the generalization ability in large-batch training becomes a challenging task. In this paper, we propose a simple yet effective method, called stochastic normalized gradient descent with momentum~(SNGM), for large-batch training. We prove that with the same number of gradient computations, SNGM can adopt a larger batch size than momentum SGD~(MSGD), which is one of the most widely used variants of SGD, to converge to an $epsilon$-stationary point. Empirical results on deep learning verify that when adopting the same large batch size, SNGM can achieve better test accuracy than MSGD and other state-of-the-art large-batch training methods.
4/16/2024
Random Scaling and Momentum for Non-smooth Non-convex Optimization
Qinzi Zhang, Ashok Cutkosky
0
0
Training neural networks requires optimizing a loss function that may be highly irregular, and in particular neither convex nor smooth. Popular training algorithms are based on stochastic gradient descent with momentum (SGDM), for which classical analysis applies only if the loss is either convex or smooth. We show that a very small modification to SGDM closes this gap: simply scale the update at each time point by an exponentially distributed random scalar. The resulting algorithm achieves optimal convergence guarantees. Intriguingly, this result is not derived by a specific analysis of SGDM: instead, it falls naturally out of a more general framework for converting online convex optimization algorithms to non-convex optimization algorithms.
5/17/2024
⚙️
Signal Processing Meets SGD: From Momentum to Filter
Zhipeng Yao, Guiyuan Fu, Ying Li, Yu Zhang, Dazhou Li, Rui Yu
0
0
In deep learning, stochastic gradient descent (SGD) and its momentum-based variants are widely used for optimization, but they typically suffer from slow convergence. Conversely, existing adaptive learning rate optimizers speed up convergence but often compromise generalization. To resolve this issue, we propose a novel optimization method designed to accelerate SGD's convergence without sacrificing generalization. Our approach reduces the variance of the historical gradient, improves first-order moment estimation of SGD by applying Wiener filter theory, and introduces a time-varying adaptive gain. Empirical results demonstrate that SGDF (SGD with Filter) effectively balances convergence and generalization compared to state-of-the-art optimizers.
5/24/2024