Mean-Field Approximation of Cooperative Constrained Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (CMARL)

Read original: arXiv:2209.07437 - Published 9/11/2024 by Washim Uddin Mondal, Vaneet Aggarwal, Satish V. Ukkusuri

🏅

Overview

Mean-Field Control (MFC) is a scalable tool for solving large-scale multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) problems.
Previous studies focused on unconstrained cumulative reward maximization, but this paper shows MFC can also handle constrained MARL problems.
The paper provides theoretical guarantees on the error between the constrained MARL problem and the associated constrained MFC problem.
A Natural Policy Gradient algorithm is presented that can solve the constrained MARL problem within the error bound.

Plain English Explanation

Mean-Field Control (MFC) is a powerful technique for tackling large-scale multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) problems. These are situations where multiple intelligent agents, like robots or autonomous vehicles, need to learn how to interact and cooperate to achieve a common goal.

Previous research has shown that MFC can be used to approximately solve these MARL problems, but the focus was typically on maximizing an overall reward without any constraints. In this paper, the researchers demonstrate that MFC can also be applied to MARL problems that have constraints, such as resource limitations or safety requirements.

They prove that an N-agent constrained MARL problem can be approximated by an associated constrained MFC problem, with an error that decreases as the number of agents increases. Specifically, the error is bounded by a term that depends on the sizes of the state and action spaces of the individual agents, divided by the square root of the number of agents.

In a special case where the reward, cost, and state transition functions don't depend on the overall action distribution of the agents, the researchers show the error can be further improved to depend only on the size of the state space, divided by the square root of the number of agents.

Additionally, the paper presents a Natural Policy Gradient algorithm that can solve the constrained MARL problem within the error bound, with a sample complexity that also decreases as the error gets smaller.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contributions of the paper are as follows:

Constrained MARL Formulation: The researchers consider an N-agent MARL problem with state and action spaces of sizes |X| and |U| respectively for each agent. The problem includes constraints on the agents' behavior, in addition to the goal of maximizing cumulative reward.
Constrained MFC Approximation: The paper shows that the N-agent constrained MARL problem can be approximated by an associated constrained MFC problem, with an error bounded by O(([sqrt(|X|) + sqrt(|U|)]/sqrt(N))).
Improved Bound for Independent Dynamics: In the special case where the reward, cost, and state transition functions are independent of the overall action distribution, the error bound can be improved to O(sqrt(|X|)/sqrt(N)).
Natural Policy Gradient Algorithm: The researchers provide a Natural Policy Gradient algorithm that can solve the constrained MARL problem within the error bound, with a sample complexity of O(e^-6), where e is the error.

The key insight is that by using the MFC approach, the complexity of the MARL problem can be reduced from exponential in the number of agents to linear, making it scalable to large-scale settings. The theoretical guarantees provided in the paper quantify the accuracy of this approximation.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of using MFC to solve constrained MARL problems, which is an important extension of previous work that focused on the unconstrained case.

However, the analysis relies on several assumptions, such as the state and action spaces being finite and the reward, cost, and state transition functions satisfying certain smoothness and boundedness conditions. It would be valuable to explore the robustness of the results to relaxations of these assumptions.

Additionally, the paper only considers a cooperative MARL setting, where all agents share a common objective. It would be interesting to investigate how the MFC approach can be adapted to handle competitive or mixed cooperative-competitive multi-agent scenarios.

While the Natural Policy Gradient algorithm is presented as a practical solution, the sample complexity result assumes access to an oracle that can generate samples from the true MARL problem. Developing practical sample-efficient algorithms that can be deployed in real-world settings would be an important next step.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that the powerful Mean-Field Control (MFC) approach can be leveraged to approximately solve large-scale multi-agent reinforcement learning problems, even in the presence of constraints. The theoretical guarantees provided offer insights into the accuracy of the MFC approximation and the scalability of the solution.

The work represents an important step towards bridging the gap between the theoretical foundations of MFC and its practical application to real-world multi-agent systems. As the field of multi-agent learning continues to advance, techniques like the one presented in this paper will be crucial for enabling the deployment of intelligent, coordinated systems at scale.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏅

Mean-Field Approximation of Cooperative Constrained Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (CMARL)

Washim Uddin Mondal, Vaneet Aggarwal, Satish V. Ukkusuri

Mean-Field Control (MFC) has recently been proven to be a scalable tool to approximately solve large-scale multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) problems. However, these studies are typically limited to unconstrained cumulative reward maximization framework. In this paper, we show that one can use the MFC approach to approximate the MARL problem even in the presence of constraints. Specifically, we prove that, an $N$-agent constrained MARL problem, with state, and action spaces of each individual agents being of sizes $|mathcal{X}|$, and $|mathcal{U}|$ respectively, can be approximated by an associated constrained MFC problem with an error, $etriangleq mathcal{O}left([sqrt{|mathcal{X}|}+sqrt{|mathcal{U}|}]/sqrt{N}right)$. In a special case where the reward, cost, and state transition functions are independent of the action distribution of the population, we prove that the error can be improved to $e=mathcal{O}(sqrt{|mathcal{X}|}/sqrt{N})$. Also, we provide a Natural Policy Gradient based algorithm and prove that it can solve the constrained MARL problem within an error of $mathcal{O}(e)$ with a sample complexity of $mathcal{O}(e^{-6})$.

9/11/2024

🏅

Major-Minor Mean Field Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning

Kai Cui, Christian Fabian, Anam Tahir, Heinz Koeppl

Multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) remains difficult to scale to many agents. Recent MARL using Mean Field Control (MFC) provides a tractable and rigorous approach to otherwise difficult cooperative MARL. However, the strict MFC assumption of many independent, weakly-interacting agents is too inflexible in practice. We generalize MFC to instead simultaneously model many similar and few complex agents -- as Major-Minor Mean Field Control (M3FC). Theoretically, we give approximation results for finite agent control, and verify the sufficiency of stationary policies for optimality together with a dynamic programming principle. Algorithmically, we propose Major-Minor Mean Field MARL (M3FMARL) for finite agent systems instead of the limiting system. The algorithm is shown to approximate the policy gradient of the underlying M3FC MDP. Finally, we demonstrate its capabilities experimentally in various scenarios. We observe a strong performance in comparison to state-of-the-art policy gradient MARL methods.

5/9/2024

Analysis of Multiscale Reinforcement Q-Learning Algorithms for Mean Field Control Games

Andrea Angiuli, Jean-Pierre Fouque, Mathieu Lauri`ere, Mengrui Zhang

Mean Field Control Games (MFCG), introduced in [Angiuli et al., 2022a], represent competitive games between a large number of large collaborative groups of agents in the infinite limit of number and size of groups. In this paper, we prove the convergence of a three-timescale Reinforcement Q-Learning (RL) algorithm to solve MFCG in a model-free approach from the point of view of representative agents. Our analysis uses a Q-table for finite state and action spaces updated at each discrete time-step over an infinite horizon. In [Angiuli et al., 2023], we proved convergence of two-timescale algorithms for MFG and MFC separately highlighting the need to follow multiple population distributions in the MFC case. Here, we integrate this feature for MFCG as well as three rates of update decreasing to zero in the proper ratios. Our technique of proof uses a generalization to three timescales of the two-timescale analysis in [Borkar, 1997]. We give a simple example satisfying the various hypothesis made in the proof of convergence and illustrating the performance of the algorithm.

6/5/2024

Deep Reinforcement Learning for Infinite Horizon Mean Field Problems in Continuous Spaces

Andrea Angiuli, Jean-Pierre Fouque, Ruimeng Hu, Alan Raydan

We present the development and analysis of a reinforcement learning (RL) algorithm designed to solve continuous-space mean field game (MFG) and mean field control (MFC) problems in a unified manner. The proposed approach pairs the actor-critic (AC) paradigm with a representation of the mean field distribution via a parameterized score function, which can be efficiently updated in an online fashion, and uses Langevin dynamics to obtain samples from the resulting distribution. The AC agent and the score function are updated iteratively to converge, either to the MFG equilibrium or the MFC optimum for a given mean field problem, depending on the choice of learning rates. A straightforward modification of the algorithm allows us to solve mixed mean field control games (MFCGs). The performance of our algorithm is evaluated using linear-quadratic benchmarks in the asymptotic infinite horizon framework.

5/6/2024