Measuring the Redundancy of Information from a Source Failure Perspective
2404.01470
0
0
📉
Abstract
In this paper, we define a new measure of the redundancy of information from a fault tolerance perspective. The partial information decomposition (PID) emerged last decade as a framework for decomposing the multi-source mutual information $I(T;X_1, ..., X_n)$ into atoms of redundant, synergistic, and unique information. It built upon the notion of redundancy/synergy from McGill's interaction information (McGill 1954). Separately, the redundancy of system components has served as a principle of fault tolerant engineering, for sensing, routing, and control applications. Here, redundancy is understood as the level of duplication necessary for the fault tolerant performance of a system. With these two perspectives in mind, we propose a new PID-based measure of redundancy $I_{text{ft}}$, based upon the presupposition that redundant information is robust to individual source failures. We demonstrate that this new measure satisfies the common PID axioms from (Williams 2010). In order to do so, we establish an order-reversing correspondence between collections of source-fallible instantiations of a system, on the one hand, and the PID lattice from (Williams 2010), on the other.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new approach to measuring the redundancy of information from a source failure perspective.
- It introduces the concept of "partial information decomposition" to analyze the redundancy and synergy in multi-source information.
- The research explores how this redundancy measure can be used to understand fault tolerance and interaction information in complex systems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a new way to quantify the redundancy or overlap of information coming from different sources. Imagine you have multiple sensors or data sources that are all giving you information about the same thing. How much of that information is duplicated or redundant across the different sources?
The researchers use a concept called "partial information decomposition" to break down the total information into distinct components - the unique information from each source, the redundant information shared across sources, and the synergistic information that arises from the interaction between sources.
Understanding this redundancy is important for designing fault-tolerant systems. If one sensor or data source fails, how much of that information can be recovered from the other sources? The redundancy measure provides a way to quantify this resilience. It also offers insights into the underlying interactions and dependencies between the different information sources.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a framework for measuring the redundancy and synergy of information in multi-source systems. It builds on the partial information decomposition (PID) approach, which decomposes the total mutual information between a target variable and a set of source variables into four non-negative and interpretable components:
- Unique information: The information about the target that is provided by each source individually.
- Shared information: The redundant information that is common across all sources.
- Complementary information: The synergistic information that arises from the interaction between the sources.
- Co-information: A measure of redundancy that cannot be attributed to any individual source.
The authors show how this PID framework can be used to quantify the fault tolerance and interaction information in complex systems. They demonstrate the approach on a set of synthetic examples as well as real-world brain imaging data.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous mathematical foundation for understanding the redundancy and synergy of information in multi-source systems. The PID-based approach offers a principled way to decompose and measure these different information-theoretic properties.
One potential limitation is the computational complexity of calculating the PID measures, especially for high-dimensional systems. The authors note that scalable approximation methods are an area of active research.
Additionally, the interpretation of the PID components can be nuanced, and care must be taken in relating them to real-world concepts like fault tolerance. Further empirical validation across diverse application domains would strengthen the practical implications of this framework.
Overall, this work presents an important step forward in quantifying the redundancy and synergy of information sources. The insights it provides could inform the design of more robust and fault-tolerant systems in a variety of contexts.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new approach to measuring the redundancy of information from a source failure perspective. By leveraging partial information decomposition, it provides a principled way to analyze the unique, redundant, and synergistic components of information in multi-source systems.
The redundancy measure offers insights into the fault tolerance and interaction information of complex systems, which could have significant implications for the design of robust and resilient technologies. While further research is needed to address computational and interpretational challenges, this work represents an important contribution to the understanding of information dynamics in real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Partial information decomposition as information bottleneck
Artemy Kolchinsky
0
0
The partial information decomposition (PID) aims to quantify the amount of redundant information that a set of sources provides about a target. Here, we show that this goal can be formulated as a type of information bottleneck (IB) problem, termed the redundancy bottleneck (RB). The RB formalizes a tradeoff between prediction and compression: it extracts information from the sources that best predict the target, without revealing which source provided the information. It can be understood as a generalization of Blackwell redundancy, which we previously proposed as a principled measure of PID redundancy. The RB curve quantifies the prediction--compression tradeoff at multiple scales. This curve can also be quantified for individual sources, allowing subsets of redundant sources to be identified without combinatorial optimization. We provide an efficient iterative algorithm for computing the RB curve.
6/28/2024
Quantifying Spuriousness of Biased Datasets Using Partial Information Decomposition
Barproda Halder, Faisal Hamman, Pasan Dissanayake, Qiuyi Zhang, Ilia Sucholutsky, Sanghamitra Dutta
0
0
Spurious patterns refer to a mathematical association between two or more variables in a dataset that are not causally related. However, this notion of spuriousness, which is usually introduced due to sampling biases in the dataset, has classically lacked a formal definition. To address this gap, this work presents the first information-theoretic formalization of spuriousness in a dataset (given a split of spurious and core features) using a mathematical framework called Partial Information Decomposition (PID). Specifically, we disentangle the joint information content that the spurious and core features share about another target variable (e.g., the prediction label) into distinct components, namely unique, redundant, and synergistic information. We propose the use of unique information, with roots in Blackwell Sufficiency, as a novel metric to formally quantify dataset spuriousness and derive its desirable properties. We empirically demonstrate how higher unique information in the spurious features in a dataset could lead a model into choosing the spurious features over the core features for inference, often having low worst-group-accuracy. We also propose a novel autoencoder-based estimator for computing unique information that is able to handle high-dimensional image data. Finally, we also show how this unique information in the spurious feature is reduced across several dataset-based spurious-pattern-mitigation techniques such as data reweighting and varying levels of background mixing, demonstrating a novel tradeoff between unique information (spuriousness) and worst-group-accuracy.
7/2/2024
📊
Partial Information Decomposition for Data Interpretability and Feature Selection
Charles Westphal, Stephen Hailes, Mirco Musolesi
0
0
In this paper, we introduce Partial Information Decomposition of Features (PIDF), a new paradigm for simultaneous data interpretability and feature selection. Contrary to traditional methods that assign a single importance value, our approach is based on three metrics per feature: the mutual information shared with the target variable, the feature's contribution to synergistic information, and the amount of this information that is redundant. In particular, we develop a novel procedure based on these three metrics, which reveals not only how features are correlated with the target but also the additional and overlapping information provided by considering them in combination with other features. We extensively evaluate PIDF using both synthetic and real-world data, demonstrating its potential applications and effectiveness, by considering case studies from genetics and neuroscience.
6/10/2024
🧠
Which Information Matters? Dissecting Human-written Multi-document Summaries with Partial Information Decomposition
Laura Mascarell, Yan L'Homme, Majed El Helou
0
0
Understanding the nature of high-quality summaries is crucial to further improve the performance of multi-document summarization. We propose an approach to characterize human-written summaries using partial information decomposition, which decomposes the mutual information provided by all source documents into union, redundancy, synergy, and unique information. Our empirical analysis on different MDS datasets shows that there is a direct dependency between the number of sources and their contribution to the summary.
5/24/2024