Mining the Explainability and Generalization: Fact Verification Based on Self-Instruction

Overview

• The paper proposes a novel self-instruction-based fine-tuning approach for fact-checking using large language models (LLMs).
• This approach aims to balance accuracy and explainability, addressing the limitations of existing commercial LLM-based fact-checking methods.
• The method involves data augmentation and an improved DPO (Differentiable Parameterized Objective) fine-tuning technique.
• The authors evaluate their approach on challenging fact-checking datasets and compare it to traditional fine-tuning and few-shot learning methods.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on a problem called fact-checking, which is the process of verifying the truthfulness of claims or statements. The researchers noticed that while some existing fact-checking methods using large language models (LLMs) offer high explainability, they tend to be less accurate than traditional fine-tuning approaches. Additionally, data security is a significant concern with these methods.

To address these issues, the researchers propose a new approach that combines self-instruction and fine-tuning. The self-instruction part involves teaching the model to generate both positive and negative explanations for claim-evidence pairs and labels. Then, the researchers use these generated samples to fine-tune the model using an improved version of a technique called DPO (Differentiable Parameterized Objective).

The researchers evaluate their approach on two challenging fact-checking datasets and compare it to traditional fine-tuning and few-shot learning methods. They find that their approach not only maintains accuracy comparable to or even better than traditional methods, but also generates fluent explanation text. Additionally, the approach exhibits strong generalization performance.

This is the first time researchers have leveraged self-supervised learning for fact-checking and combined contrastive learning with improved DPO to fine-tune LLMs, as demonstrated in the experiments.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a self-instruction-based fine-tuning approach for fact-checking using large language models (LLMs). The method consists of two key components:

1. Data Augmentation: The researchers start by instructing the model to generate both positive and negative explanations based on claim-evidence pairs and labels. They then sample the dataset according to their customized difficulty standards, creating a more diverse and challenging training set.

2. Improved DPO Fine-tuning: The researchers employ an improved version of the Differentiable Parameterized Objective (DPO) fine-tuning technique to train the model using the generated samples.

The authors fine-tune the smallest-scale LLaMA-7B model and evaluate it on the FEVEROUS and HOVER fact-checking datasets. They compare their approach to four fine-tuning methods and three few-shot learning methods.

The experiments demonstrate that the proposed approach not only retains accuracy comparable to or even surpassing traditional fine-tuning methods, but also generates fluent explanation text. Moreover, the method exhibits high generalization performance.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to fact-checking using LLMs. The researchers' focus on balancing accuracy and explainability is commendable, as explainability is a crucial aspect of fact-checking systems.

However, the paper does not provide much detail on the specific implementation of the data augmentation and improved DPO fine-tuning techniques. It would be helpful to have a more comprehensive description of these methods to understand their full scope and potential limitations.

Additionally, the paper could have explored the scalability and computational efficiency of the proposed approach, as efficiency is a key concern for fact-checking systems that need to operate in real-time.

Finally, the researchers could have discussed the potential ethical implications of their approach, such as its use in multimodal fact-checking systems or its impact on the broader landscape of automated fact-checking.

Conclusion

The paper presents a novel self-instruction-based fine-tuning approach for fact-checking using large language models. This method aims to balance accuracy and explainability, addressing the limitations of existing commercial LLM-based fact-checking techniques.

The key innovations of the proposed approach are the data augmentation and improved DPO fine-tuning techniques, which demonstrate strong performance on challenging fact-checking datasets. This work is a significant step forward in leveraging the power of LLMs for reliable and explainable fact-checking, with potential applications in various domains, such as public health and multimodal fact-checking.