Mitigating Urban-Rural Disparities in Contrastive Representation Learning with Satellite Imagery

Overview

• Satellite imagery is being used for critical tasks like climate, economics, and public health.
• Models can show different performance across geographic areas due to landscape heterogeneity.
• This paper examines the risk of urban-rural disparities in land cover feature identification using semantic segmentation.
• The proposed method, Fair Dense Representation with Contrastive Learning (FairDCL), aims to de-bias the multi-level latent space of convolutional neural network models.

Plain English Explanation

Satellite images are being used to tackle important real-world problems like understanding climate change, tracking economic activity, and monitoring public health. However, the performance of the computer vision models used for these tasks can vary greatly depending on the geographic area. This is because the appearance of things like roads, buildings, and vegetation can look quite different in urban versus rural settings.

To address this issue of geographic disparities in model performance, the researchers propose a new technique called Fair Dense Representation with Contrastive Learning (FairDCL). FairDCL works by removing problematic patterns in the internal representations learned by the model that are specific to urban or rural areas. This is achieved through an unsupervised pre-training process that encourages the model to learn more generalizable and fair features.

The key idea is to make the model's understanding of the satellite imagery less dependent on whether a region is urban or rural. This helps the model perform more consistently across different geographic settings, which is crucial for ensuring these powerful AI tools can be reliably used to address important societal challenges.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on the task of semantic segmentation, which involves labeling different regions of an image according to what they depict (e.g. roads, buildings, vegetation). The authors note that while semantic segmentation models trained on satellite imagery can achieve high average accuracy, they often exhibit disparate performance across urban and rural areas.

To address this issue, the researchers propose the Fair Dense Representation with Contrastive Learning (FairDCL) method. FairDCL aims to learn image representations that are more robust to urban-rural differences by removing spurious correlations in the model's internal feature representations.

The key steps of the FairDCL approach are:

1. Contrastive Pre-training: The model is pre-trained in an unsupervised manner using a contrastive learning objective. This encourages the model to learn representations that capture the most generalizable and discriminative features of the satellite imagery.

2. Urban-Rural De-biasing: The pre-trained representation is then fine-tuned using an additional contrastive objective that explicitly encourages the removal of urban-rural related biases from the model's internal feature maps.

3. Downstream Task Fine-tuning: Finally, the de-biased representation is used to fine-tune the model for the target semantic segmentation task.

Experiments on real-world satellite image datasets show that the FairDCL method outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in terms of mitigating urban-rural prediction disparities, while maintaining strong overall performance. Detailed ablation studies and embedding space evaluations further demonstrate the robustness of the approach.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of addressing geographic disparities in the performance of computer vision models applied to satellite imagery. The authors rightly point out that simply optimizing for average accuracy is not sufficient, as the societal impact of these systems depends on their ability to perform well across diverse geographic contexts.

One potential limitation of the work is the reliance on manual urban-rural labels for the contrastive pre-training step. While this approach is reasonable given the current state of the field, it would be interesting to explore how the method could be further extended to learn de-biased representations in a fully unsupervised manner.

Additionally, the paper focuses on urban-rural disparities, but there may be other important geographic factors, such as socioeconomic status or climate, that could also lead to performance differences. Expanding the scope of the fairness analysis to consider a wider range of geographic attributes could be a valuable direction for future research.

Overall, this work makes an important contribution by highlighting the need for more robust and equitable satellite imagery analysis tools. As the authors note, metrics beyond just average accuracy should be considered when evaluating the real-world impact of these systems.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel method, Fair Dense Representation with Contrastive Learning (FairDCL), for mitigating urban-rural disparities in the performance of semantic segmentation models applied to satellite imagery. By explicitly removing urban-rural biases from the internal feature representations of the model, FairDCL is able to achieve more consistent performance across geographic contexts while maintaining strong overall accuracy.

As satellite imagery analysis becomes increasingly central to addressing critical societal challenges, ensuring the fairness and robustness of these AI-powered tools is of paramount importance. The insights and techniques developed in this work represent an important step towards building more equitable and reliable computer vision systems for geographic applications.