Mixture of Experts Meets Prompt-Based Continual Learning
2405.14124
0
0
🐍
Abstract
Exploiting the power of pre-trained models, prompt-based approaches stand out compared to other continual learning solutions in effectively preventing catastrophic forgetting, even with very few learnable parameters and without the need for a memory buffer. While existing prompt-based continual learning methods excel in leveraging prompts for state-of-the-art performance, they often lack a theoretical explanation for the effectiveness of prompting. This paper conducts a theoretical analysis to unravel how prompts bestow such advantages in continual learning, thus offering a new perspective on prompt design. We first show that the attention block of pre-trained models like Vision Transformers inherently encodes a special mixture of experts architecture, characterized by linear experts and quadratic gating score functions. This realization drives us to provide a novel view on prefix tuning, reframing it as the addition of new task-specific experts, thereby inspiring the design of a novel gating mechanism termed Non-linear Residual Gates (NoRGa). Through the incorporation of non-linear activation and residual connection, NoRGa enhances continual learning performance while preserving parameter efficiency. The effectiveness of NoRGa is substantiated both theoretically and empirically across diverse benchmarks and pretraining paradigms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of prompts to improve continual learning, where AI models learn new tasks without forgetting previous ones.
- The researchers provide a theoretical analysis to understand why prompts are effective in continual learning, even with few learnable parameters and without the need for a memory buffer.
- The paper introduces a novel gating mechanism called Non-linear Residual Gates (NoRGa) that enhances continual learning performance while preserving parameter efficiency.
Plain English Explanation
Continual learning is an important challenge in AI, where models need to learn new tasks without forgetting what they've learned before. Existing prompt-based continual learning methods have shown promise in addressing this, but the reasons behind their effectiveness have been unclear.
This paper takes a closer look at how prompts work in continual learning. The researchers found that the attention mechanism in pre-trained models like Vision Transformers already has a special "mixture of experts" architecture built-in. This insight led them to develop a new gating mechanism called NoRGa, which adds new task-specific experts and uses non-linear activation and residual connections to improve continual learning performance without needing a lot of extra parameters.
The key idea is that by leveraging the inherent structure of pre-trained models and adding these new task-specific components, the model can learn new tasks more effectively without forgetting previous ones. This is important because it allows for continual learning with fewer resources compared to other methods.
Technical Explanation
The paper starts by analyzing the attention block of pre-trained models like Vision Transformers and shows that it inherently encodes a "mixture of experts" architecture, with linear experts and quadratic gating score functions. This realization leads the researchers to reframe prefix tuning as the addition of new task-specific experts.
Building on this, the paper introduces a novel gating mechanism called Non-linear Residual Gates (NoRGa). NoRGa enhances continual learning performance by incorporating non-linear activation and residual connections into the gating process. This allows the model to learn new tasks more effectively without forgetting previous ones, while still maintaining parameter efficiency.
The researchers provide both theoretical and empirical analyses to demonstrate the effectiveness of NoRGa. They evaluate the approach on diverse benchmarks and pre-training paradigms, showing improvements over existing prompt-based continual learning methods and other continual learning techniques.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a robust theoretical analysis and empirical evaluation of the proposed NoRGa approach. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- The analysis is focused on Vision Transformers, and it would be valuable to explore the generalization of the findings to other pre-trained models, such as language models.
- The paper does not extensively compare NoRGa to more recent continual learning approaches that leverage pre-trained models, which could provide additional insights.
- While the parameter efficiency of NoRGa is a strength, the paper does not delve into the scalability of the approach as the number of tasks increases, which could be an important consideration in real-world applications.
Overall, this paper offers a novel perspective on prompt-based continual learning and introduces a promising gating mechanism that could have significant implications for efficient and effective continual learning systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a theoretical analysis that sheds light on the effectiveness of prompt-based approaches for continual learning. By reframing prefix tuning as the addition of new task-specific experts and introducing the Non-linear Residual Gates (NoRGa) mechanism, the researchers have developed a continual learning solution that can leverage the inherent structure of pre-trained models to learn new tasks effectively without forgetting previous ones, while maintaining parameter efficiency. The findings of this work could have broad implications for the design of continual learning systems that can adapt to new challenges over time without catastrophic forgetting.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Convolutional Prompting meets Language Models for Continual Learning
Anurag Roy, Riddhiman Moulick, Vinay K. Verma, Saptarshi Ghosh, Abir Das
0
0
Continual Learning (CL) enables machine learning models to learn from continuously shifting new training data in absence of data from old tasks. Recently, pretrained vision transformers combined with prompt tuning have shown promise for overcoming catastrophic forgetting in CL. These approaches rely on a pool of learnable prompts which can be inefficient in sharing knowledge across tasks leading to inferior performance. In addition, the lack of fine-grained layer specific prompts does not allow these to fully express the strength of the prompts for CL. We address these limitations by proposing ConvPrompt, a novel convolutional prompt creation mechanism that maintains layer-wise shared embeddings, enabling both layer-specific learning and better concept transfer across tasks. The intelligent use of convolution enables us to maintain a low parameter overhead without compromising performance. We further leverage Large Language Models to generate fine-grained text descriptions of each category which are used to get task similarity and dynamically decide the number of prompts to be learned. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of ConvPrompt and improves SOTA by ~3% with significantly less parameter overhead. We also perform strong ablation over various modules to disentangle the importance of different components.
4/1/2024
Visual Prompt Tuning in Null Space for Continual Learning
Yue Lu, Shizhou Zhang, De Cheng, Yinghui Xing, Nannan Wang, Peng Wang, Yanning Zhang
0
0
Existing prompt-tuning methods have demonstrated impressive performances in continual learning (CL), by selecting and updating relevant prompts in the vision-transformer models. On the contrary, this paper aims to learn each task by tuning the prompts in the direction orthogonal to the subspace spanned by previous tasks' features, so as to ensure no interference on tasks that have been learned to overcome catastrophic forgetting in CL. However, different from the orthogonal projection in the traditional CNN architecture, the prompt gradient orthogonal projection in the ViT architecture shows completely different and greater challenges, i.e., 1) the high-order and non-linear self-attention operation; 2) the drift of prompt distribution brought by the LayerNorm in the transformer block. Theoretically, we have finally deduced two consistency conditions to achieve the prompt gradient orthogonal projection, which provide a theoretical guarantee of eliminating interference on previously learned knowledge via the self-attention mechanism in visual prompt tuning. In practice, an effective null-space-based approximation solution has been proposed to implement the prompt gradient orthogonal projection. Extensive experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of anti-forgetting on four class-incremental benchmarks with diverse pre-trained baseline models, and our approach achieves superior performances to state-of-the-art methods. Our code is available at https://github.com/zugexiaodui/VPTinNSforCL.
6/12/2024
🏷️
Prompt Customization for Continual Learning
Yong Dai, Xiaopeng Hong, Yabin Wang, Zhiheng Ma, Dongmei Jiang, Yaowei Wang
0
0
Contemporary continual learning approaches typically select prompts from a pool, which function as supplementary inputs to a pre-trained model. However, this strategy is hindered by the inherent noise of its selection approach when handling increasing tasks. In response to these challenges, we reformulate the prompting approach for continual learning and propose the prompt customization (PC) method. PC mainly comprises a prompt generation module (PGM) and a prompt modulation module (PMM). In contrast to conventional methods that employ hard prompt selection, PGM assigns different coefficients to prompts from a fixed-sized pool of prompts and generates tailored prompts. Moreover, PMM further modulates the prompts by adaptively assigning weights according to the correlations between input data and corresponding prompts. We evaluate our method on four benchmark datasets for three diverse settings, including the class, domain, and task-agnostic incremental learning tasks. Experimental results demonstrate consistent improvement (by up to 16.2%), yielded by the proposed method, over the state-of-the-art (SOTA) techniques.
4/30/2024
Choice of PEFT Technique in Continual Learning: Prompt Tuning is Not All You Need
Martin Wistuba, Prabhu Teja Sivaprasad, Lukas Balles, Giovanni Zappella
0
0
Recent Continual Learning (CL) methods have combined pretrained Transformers with prompt tuning, a parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) technique. We argue that the choice of prompt tuning in prior works was an undefended and unablated decision, which has been uncritically adopted by subsequent research, but warrants further research to understand its implications. In this paper, we conduct this research and find that the choice of prompt tuning as a PEFT method hurts the overall performance of the CL system. To illustrate this, we replace prompt tuning with LoRA in two state-of-the-art continual learning methods: Learning to Prompt and S-Prompts. These variants consistently achieve higher accuracy across a wide range of domain-incremental and class-incremental benchmarks, while being competitive in inference speed. Our work highlights a crucial argument: unexamined choices can hinder progress in the field, and rigorous ablations, such as the PEFT method, are required to drive meaningful adoption of CL techniques in real-world applications.
6/6/2024