Mixture of Weak & Strong Experts on Graphs
0
🏷️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Realistic graphs contain both rich node features and informative neighborhood structures, which are typically handled jointly by Graph Neural Networks (GNNs).
- The authors propose a Mixture of Weak and Strong Experts (Mowst) model that decouples these two modalities.
- The weak expert is a lightweight Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP), while the strong expert is an off-the-shelf GNN.
- A confidence mechanism based on the dispersion of the weak expert's prediction logits is used to conditionally activate the strong expert.
- The training algorithm encourages the specialization of each expert by effectively generating a soft splitting of the graph.
- Mowst achieves strong expressive power with a computation cost comparable to a single GNN.
Plain English Explanation
Graphs, which represent connections between objects, can contain rich information about the objects themselves (node features) and the way they are connected (neighborhood structures). Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are typically used to handle both of these aspects jointly.
In this paper, the researchers propose a new approach called Mixture of Weak and Strong Experts (Mowst), which separates these two types of information. The "weak" expert is a simple, lightweight Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) that focuses on the node features. The "strong" expert is a more powerful GNN that specializes in capturing the neighborhood structure.
To decide when to use the weak or strong expert for a given node, Mowst uses a "confidence" mechanism. If the weak expert is unsure about a node's classification, the strong GNN expert is activated. This allows Mowst to leverage the strengths of both models, using the simple MLP when it can and the more complex GNN when necessary.
The training process encourages the weak and strong experts to specialize in different parts of the graph, effectively splitting the graph into regions that each expert handles best. This division of labor allows Mowst to achieve high performance with a computation cost similar to a single GNN.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose the Mixture of Weak and Strong Experts (Mowst) model to decouple the two modalities of rich node features and informative neighborhood structures in realistic graphs. Mowst consists of a weak expert, which is a lightweight Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP), and a strong expert, which is an off-the-shelf GNN.
To adapt the experts' collaboration to different target nodes, Mowst employs a confidence mechanism based on the dispersion of the weak expert's prediction logits. When the weak expert has low confidence, the strong GNN expert is conditionally activated. This occurs when either the node's classification relies on neighborhood information, or the weak expert has low model quality.
The training algorithm for Mowst encourages the specialization of each expert by effectively generating a soft splitting of the graph. The confidence design also imposes a desirable bias toward the strong expert, allowing Mowst to benefit from the GNN's better generalization capability.
Empirically, the authors show that Mowst can be applied to 4 backbone GNN architectures and achieves significant accuracy improvements on 6 standard node classification benchmarks, including both homophilous and heterophilous graphs.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough analysis of the training dynamics and the influence of the confidence function on the loss function. This provides valuable insights into how the model encourages the specialization of the weak and strong experts.
However, the paper does not address the potential limitations of the Mowst approach. For example, it is unclear how the model would perform on graphs with very sparse or highly complex neighborhood structures, where the weak expert may struggle to capture the relevant information.
Additionally, the authors do not discuss the potential interpretability challenges of the Mowst model, as the division of labor between the weak and strong experts may make it more difficult to understand the reasoning behind the model's predictions.
Further research could explore the robustness of the Mowst approach to noisy or adversarial inputs, as well as its scalability to larger and more diverse graph datasets.
Conclusion
The Mixture of Weak and Strong Experts (Mowst) model proposed in this paper offers a novel approach to handling the dual challenges of rich node features and informative neighborhood structures in realistic graphs. By decoupling these two modalities and using a confidence-based mechanism to selectively activate the strong GNN expert, Mowst achieves strong performance with a computational cost comparable to a single GNN.
This work highlights the potential benefits of mixing different model architectures and specializations to tackle complex graph-based problems. The insights into the training dynamics and the effective soft splitting of the graph could inspire further research into multi-view and modular approaches to graph representation learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏷️
0
Mixture of Weak & Strong Experts on Graphs
Hanqing Zeng, Hanjia Lyu, Diyi Hu, Yinglong Xia, Jiebo Luo
Realistic graphs contain both (1) rich self-features of nodes and (2) informative structures of neighborhoods, jointly handled by a Graph Neural Network (GNN) in the typical setup. We propose to decouple the two modalities by Mixture of weak and strong experts (Mowst), where the weak expert is a light-weight Multi-layer Perceptron (MLP), and the strong expert is an off-the-shelf GNN. To adapt the experts' collaboration to different target nodes, we propose a confidence mechanism based on the dispersion of the weak expert's prediction logits. The strong expert is conditionally activated in the low-confidence region when either the node's classification relies on neighborhood information, or the weak expert has low model quality. We reveal interesting training dynamics by analyzing the influence of the confidence function on loss: our training algorithm encourages the specialization of each expert by effectively generating soft splitting of the graph. In addition, our confidence design imposes a desirable bias toward the strong expert to benefit from GNN's better generalization capability. Mowst is easy to optimize and achieves strong expressive power, with a computation cost comparable to a single GNN. Empirically, Mowst on 4 backbone GNN architectures show significant accuracy improvement on 6 standard node classification benchmarks, including both homophilous and heterophilous graphs (https://github.com/facebookresearch/mowst-gnn).
Read more6/26/2024
0
Graph Knowledge Distillation to Mixture of Experts
Pavel Rumiantsev, Mark Coates
In terms of accuracy, Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are the best architectural choice for the node classification task. Their drawback in real-world deployment is the latency that emerges from the neighbourhood processing operation. One solution to the latency issue is to perform knowledge distillation from a trained GNN to a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP), where the MLP processes only the features of the node being classified (and possibly some pre-computed structural information). However, the performance of such MLPs in both transductive and inductive settings remains inconsistent for existing knowledge distillation techniques. We propose to address the performance concerns by using a specially-designed student model instead of an MLP. Our model, named Routing-by-Memory (RbM), is a form of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE), with a design that enforces expert specialization. By encouraging each expert to specialize on a certain region on the hidden representation space, we demonstrate experimentally that it is possible to derive considerably more consistent performance across multiple datasets.
Read more6/19/2024
❗
0
Graph Sparsification via Mixture of Graphs
Guibin Zhang, Xiangguo Sun, Yanwei Yue, Kun Wang, Tianlong Chen, Shirui Pan
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have demonstrated superior performance across various graph learning tasks but face significant computational challenges when applied to large-scale graphs. One effective approach to mitigate these challenges is graph sparsification, which involves removing non-essential edges to reduce computational overhead. However, previous graph sparsification methods often rely on a single global sparsity setting and uniform pruning criteria, failing to provide customized sparsification schemes for each node's complex local context. In this paper, we introduce Mixture-of-Graphs (MoG), leveraging the concept of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE), to dynamically select tailored pruning solutions for each node. Specifically, MoG incorporates multiple sparsifier experts, each characterized by unique sparsity levels and pruning criteria, and selects the appropriate experts for each node. Subsequently, MoG performs a mixture of the sparse graphs produced by different experts on the Grassmann manifold to derive an optimal sparse graph. One notable property of MoG is its entirely local nature, as it depends on the specific circumstances of each individual node. Extensive experiments on four large-scale OGB datasets and two superpixel datasets, equipped with five GNN backbones, demonstrate that MoG (I) identifies subgraphs at higher sparsity levels ($8.67%sim 50.85%$), with performance equal to or better than the dense graph, (II) achieves $1.47-2.62times$ speedup in GNN inference with negligible performance drop, and (III) boosts ``top-student'' GNN performance ($1.02%uparrow$ on RevGNN+textsc{ogbn-proteins} and $1.74%uparrow$ on DeeperGCN+textsc{ogbg-ppa}).
Read more5/24/2024
0
Node-wise Filtering in Graph Neural Networks: A Mixture of Experts Approach
Haoyu Han, Juanhui Li, Wei Huang, Xianfeng Tang, Hanqing Lu, Chen Luo, Hui Liu, Jiliang Tang
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have proven to be highly effective for node classification tasks across diverse graph structural patterns. Traditionally, GNNs employ a uniform global filter, typically a low-pass filter for homophilic graphs and a high-pass filter for heterophilic graphs. However, real-world graphs often exhibit a complex mix of homophilic and heterophilic patterns, rendering a single global filter approach suboptimal. In this work, we theoretically demonstrate that a global filter optimized for one pattern can adversely affect performance on nodes with differing patterns. To address this, we introduce a novel GNN framework Node-MoE that utilizes a mixture of experts to adaptively select the appropriate filters for different nodes. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of Node-MoE on both homophilic and heterophilic graphs.
Read more6/6/2024