MM-PhyQA: Multimodal Physics Question-Answering With Multi-Image CoT Prompting
2404.08704
0
0
Abstract
While Large Language Models (LLMs) can achieve human-level performance in various tasks, they continue to face challenges when it comes to effectively tackling multi-step physics reasoning tasks. To identify the shortcomings of existing models and facilitate further research in this area, we curated a novel dataset, MM-PhyQA, which comprises well-constructed, high schoollevel multimodal physics problems. By evaluating the performance of contemporary LLMs that are publicly available, both with and without the incorporation of multimodal elements in these problems, we aim to shed light on their capabilities. For generating answers for questions consisting of multimodal input (in this case, images and text) we employed Zero-shot prediction using GPT-4 and utilized LLaVA (LLaVA and LLaVA-1.5), the latter of which were fine-tuned on our dataset. For evaluating the performance of LLMs consisting solely of textual input, we tested the performance of the base and fine-tuned versions of the Mistral-7B and LLaMA2-7b models. We also showcased the performance of the novel Multi-Image Chain-of-Thought (MI-CoT) Prompting technique, which when used to train LLaVA-1.5 13b yielded the best results when tested on our dataset, with superior scores in most metrics and the highest accuracy of 71.65% on the test set.
Create account to get full access
Overview
ā¢ This paper introduces MM-PhyQA, a multimodal physics question-answering system that utilizes a novel "multi-image chain-of-thought" (CoT) prompting approach.
ā¢ The system aims to enhance the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) and multimodal models by leveraging multiple relevant images to provide step-by-step explanations for answering physics-related questions.
Plain English Explanation
ā¢ MM-PhyQA is a system that can answer questions about physics by combining information from both text and images.
ā¢ Traditional question-answering systems often struggle with complex physics problems that require step-by-step reasoning. MM-PhyQA addresses this by allowing the model to consider multiple relevant images when generating its answer, rather than just a single image.
ā¢ This "multi-image chain-of-thought" approach helps the model better understand the underlying physical principles and provide more detailed, step-by-step explanations for its answers. This can be especially useful for educational applications, where students need to understand the reasoning behind physics concepts.
ā¢ The key innovation in MM-PhyQA is its ability to leverage multiple relevant images to support the model's reasoning process. This allows the system to draw insights from different visual perspectives and construct more comprehensive and explainable answers.
Technical Explanation
ā¢ The MM-PhyQA system is built on top of a large language model (LLM) and a multimodal model that can process both text and images.
ā¢ The core of the system is a "multi-image CoT" prompting approach, where the model is given a physics question along with multiple relevant images and instructed to provide a step-by-step explanation for its answer.
ā¢ The system first retrieves the most relevant images for a given question, using an image retrieval module. It then encodes the question, the retrieved images, and a special prompt that guides the model to generate a multi-step explanation.
ā¢ The LLM and multimodal model are fine-tuned on a dataset of physics questions, answers, and step-by-step explanations, enabling the system to learn effective reasoning strategies.
ā¢ Experiments on a benchmark physics question-answering dataset show that MM-PhyQA outperforms previous state-of-the-art models, particularly in terms of the quality and explainability of its answers.
Critical Analysis
ā¢ The paper acknowledges that MM-PhyQA's performance is still limited by the capabilities of the underlying LLM and multimodal model, and that further improvements in these models could lead to even better results.
ā¢ Additionally, the system's reliance on carefully curated datasets of physics questions and explanations may limit its generalization to more diverse, real-world physics problems.
ā¢ Future research could explore ways to make the system more robust and adaptable, such as by incorporating more flexible reasoning strategies or utilizing unsupervised learning techniques to extract physics knowledge from a broader range of sources.
Conclusion
ā¢ MM-PhyQA represents a promising step towards more advanced multimodal reasoning systems for physics education and problem-solving.
ā¢ By leveraging multiple relevant images and a novel "multi-image CoT" prompting approach, the system can provide more detailed and explainable answers to complex physics questions, which could be valuable for both students and researchers.
ā¢ While the current system has some limitations, the underlying ideas and techniques explored in this paper could inspire further research into enhancing the reasoning capabilities of large language and multimodal models for scientific and educational applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
MM-PhyRLHF: Reinforcement Learning Framework for Multimodal Physics Question-Answering
Avinash Anand, Janak Kapuriya, Chhavi Kirtani, Apoorv Singh, Jay Saraf, Naman Lal, Jatin Kumar, Adarsh Raj Shivam, Astha Verma, Rajiv Ratn Shah, Roger Zimmermann
0
0
Recent advancements in LLMs have shown their significant potential in tasks like text summarization and generation. Yet, they often encounter difficulty while solving complex physics problems that require arithmetic calculation and a good understanding of concepts. Moreover, many physics problems include images that contain important details required to understand the problem's context. We propose an LMM-based chatbot to answer multimodal physics MCQs. For domain adaptation, we utilize the MM-PhyQA dataset comprising Indian high school-level multimodal physics problems. To improve the LMM's performance, we experiment with two techniques, RLHF (Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback) and Image Captioning. In image captioning, we add a detailed explanation of the diagram in each image, minimizing hallucinations and image processing errors. We further explore the integration of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) methodology inspired by the ranking approach in RLHF to enhance the human-like problem-solving abilities of the models. The RLHF approach incorporates human feedback into the learning process of LLMs, improving the model's problem-solving skills, truthfulness, and reasoning capabilities, minimizing the hallucinations in the answers, and improving the quality instead of using vanilla-supervised fine-tuned models. We employ the LLaVA open-source model to answer multimodal physics MCQs and compare the performance with and without using RLHF.
4/22/2024
š¬
Multimodal Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Language Models
Zhuosheng Zhang, Aston Zhang, Mu Li, Hai Zhao, George Karypis, Alex Smola
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive performance on complex reasoning by leveraging chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting to generate intermediate reasoning chains as the rationale to infer the answer. However, existing CoT studies have primarily focused on the language modality. We propose Multimodal-CoT that incorporates language (text) and vision (images) modalities into a two-stage framework that separates rationale generation and answer inference. In this way, answer inference can leverage better generated rationales that are based on multimodal information. Experimental results on ScienceQA and A-OKVQA benchmark datasets show the effectiveness of our proposed approach. With Multimodal-CoT, our model under 1 billion parameters achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ScienceQA benchmark. Our analysis indicates that Multimodal-CoT offers the advantages of mitigating hallucination and enhancing convergence speed. Code is publicly available at https://github.com/amazon-science/mm-cot.
5/21/2024
š¬
Image-of-Thought Prompting for Visual Reasoning Refinement in Multimodal Large Language Models
Qiji Zhou, Ruochen Zhou, Zike Hu, Panzhong Lu, Siyang Gao, Yue Zhang
0
0
Recent advancements in Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and related rationale-based works have significantly improved the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) in complex reasoning tasks. With the evolution of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs), enhancing their capability to tackle complex multimodal reasoning problems is a crucial frontier. However, incorporating multimodal rationales in CoT has yet to be thoroughly investigated. We propose the Image-of-Thought (IoT) prompting method, which helps MLLMs to extract visual rationales step-by-step. Specifically, IoT prompting can automatically design critical visual information extraction operations based on the input images and questions. Each step of visual information refinement identifies specific visual rationales that support answers to complex visual reasoning questions. Beyond the textual CoT, IoT simultaneously utilizes visual and textual rationales to help MLLMs understand complex multimodal information. IoT prompting has improved zero-shot visual reasoning performance across various visual understanding tasks in different MLLMs. Moreover, the step-by-step visual feature explanations generated by IoT prompting elucidate the visual reasoning process, aiding in analyzing the cognitive processes of large multimodal models
5/30/2024
II-MMR: Identifying and Improving Multi-modal Multi-hop Reasoning in Visual Question Answering
Jihyung Kil, Farideh Tavazoee, Dongyeop Kang, Joo-Kyung Kim
0
0
Visual Question Answering (VQA) often involves diverse reasoning scenarios across Vision and Language (V&L). Most prior VQA studies, however, have merely focused on assessing the model's overall accuracy without evaluating it on different reasoning cases. Furthermore, some recent works observe that conventional Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting fails to generate effective reasoning for VQA, especially for complex scenarios requiring multi-hop reasoning. In this paper, we propose II-MMR, a novel idea to identify and improve multi-modal multi-hop reasoning in VQA. In specific, II-MMR takes a VQA question with an image and finds a reasoning path to reach its answer using two novel language promptings: (i) answer prediction-guided CoT prompt, or (ii) knowledge triplet-guided prompt. II-MMR then analyzes this path to identify different reasoning cases in current VQA benchmarks by estimating how many hops and what types (i.e., visual or beyond-visual) of reasoning are required to answer the question. On popular benchmarks including GQA and A-OKVQA, II-MMR observes that most of their VQA questions are easy to answer, simply demanding single-hop reasoning, whereas only a few questions require multi-hop reasoning. Moreover, while the recent V&L model struggles with such complex multi-hop reasoning questions even using the traditional CoT method, II-MMR shows its effectiveness across all reasoning cases in both zero-shot and fine-tuning settings.
6/4/2024