Model Compression in Practice: Lessons Learned from Practitioners Creating On-device Machine Learning Experiences

Read original: arXiv:2310.04621 - Published 4/5/2024 by Fred Hohman, Mary Beth Kery, Donghao Ren, Dominik Moritz

📈

Overview

This paper explores the practical lessons learned by practitioners who create on-device machine learning experiences.
The researchers conducted interviews with 18 ML practitioners to understand the challenges and design considerations involved in deploying efficient ML models on mobile and edge devices.
Key insights include the importance of balancing model accuracy, size, and latency, as well as the need for tools and workflows to support the unique requirements of on-device ML development.

Plain English Explanation

Building machine learning (ML) models that can run effectively on smartphones, tablets, and other small devices is a significant challenge. These "on-device" ML systems need to be highly efficient, with small file sizes and fast response times, while still maintaining good accuracy.

The researchers in this paper talked to 18 experienced ML practitioners to learn about the real-world problems they face when creating on-device ML experiences. They found that practitioners must carefully balance the tradeoffs between model size, speed, and accuracy. Smaller, faster models may lose some performance compared to larger, more complex ones.

Additionally, the practitioners highlighted the need for better tools and workflows to support the unique requirements of on-device ML development. Typical ML tools are often designed for powerful servers, not resource-constrained edge devices. New methods are required to efficiently compress and optimize models for deployment on mobile platforms.

Overall, this research provides important insights into the practical challenges of bringing powerful ML capabilities to the fingertips of everyday users through their personal devices. By understanding the perspectives of experienced practitioners, the findings can help guide the development of more user-friendly and efficient on-device ML systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper reports on a qualitative interview study with 18 ML practitioners who have experience developing on-device machine learning applications. The goal was to understand the practical challenges and design considerations involved in creating efficient ML models that can run directly on mobile and edge devices.

The researchers conducted semi-structured interviews covering topics such as model compression techniques, performance optimization strategies, workflow and tool requirements, and overall design priorities. Key insights from the thematic analysis include:

The need to carefully balance model accuracy, size, and latency to meet the constraints of on-device deployment. Practitioners described the tradeoffs involved in compressing models while maintaining acceptable performance.
The importance of developing specialized tools and workflows to support the unique requirements of on-device ML development. Existing ML toolchains are often designed for server-side deployment, necessitating new approaches.
The criticality of considering the end-user experience when designing on-device ML systems. Factors like responsiveness, privacy, and interpretability were highlighted as important design considerations.
Challenges around managing model updates, retraining, and deployment to ensure a seamless experience for users after the initial app installation.

The findings provide valuable guidance for researchers and practitioners working to bring the power of machine learning to the edge through mobile and embedded devices. The insights can inform the development of more efficient and user-friendly on-device ML solutions.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a well-designed and thorough investigation of the practical challenges faced by ML practitioners in the on-device domain. The interview methodology allows the researchers to capture rich, nuanced insights directly from experienced professionals working on these real-world problems.

One potential limitation is the relatively small sample size of 18 interviewees, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Additional research with a larger and more diverse set of practitioners could help validate and expand upon the themes identified in this study.

The paper also does not delve deeply into the technical details of the various model compression and optimization techniques used by the practitioners. Further exploration of the specific methods and their tradeoffs could provide additional value to the research community.

Furthermore, while the paper highlights the importance of the end-user experience, it does not extensively explore the user-centric design considerations from the perspective of the practitioners. Investigating this angle more thoroughly could yield additional insights to guide the development of on-device ML systems that truly meet the needs of end-users.

Overall, this research represents an important step in understanding the practical challenges and design priorities for creating efficient on-device machine learning experiences. The findings provide a solid foundation for further exploration and innovation in this critical domain.

Conclusion

This paper offers valuable insights into the real-world challenges faced by practitioners who develop on-device machine learning applications. Through in-depth interviews, the researchers uncover the key tradeoffs and design considerations involved in building efficient ML models that can run directly on mobile and edge devices.

The study highlights the need to balance model accuracy, size, and latency, as well as the importance of developing specialized tools and workflows to support the unique requirements of on-device ML deployment. Importantly, the findings also emphasize the critical role of the end-user experience in shaping the design of these systems.

By sharing the perspectives of experienced practitioners, this research can help guide the development of more user-friendly and efficient on-device ML solutions. As the demand for powerful AI capabilities on personal devices continues to grow, the insights from this paper will be invaluable in addressing the practical challenges and realizing the full potential of edge computing.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📈

Model Compression in Practice: Lessons Learned from Practitioners Creating On-device Machine Learning Experiences

Fred Hohman, Mary Beth Kery, Donghao Ren, Dominik Moritz

On-device machine learning (ML) promises to improve the privacy, responsiveness, and proliferation of new, intelligent user experiences by moving ML computation onto everyday personal devices. However, today's large ML models must be drastically compressed to run efficiently on-device, a hurtle that requires deep, yet currently niche expertise. To engage the broader human-centered ML community in on-device ML experiences, we present the results from an interview study with 30 experts at Apple that specialize in producing efficient models. We compile tacit knowledge that experts have developed through practical experience with model compression across different hardware platforms. Our findings offer pragmatic considerations missing from prior work, covering the design process, trade-offs, and technical strategies that go into creating efficient models. Finally, we distill design recommendations for tooling to help ease the difficulty of this work and bring on-device ML into to more widespread practice.

4/5/2024

On-Device Language Models: A Comprehensive Review

Jiajun Xu, Zhiyuan Li, Wei Chen, Qun Wang, Xin Gao, Qi Cai, Ziyuan Ling

The advent of large language models (LLMs) revolutionized natural language processing applications, and running LLMs on edge devices has become increasingly attractive for reasons including reduced latency, data localization, and personalized user experiences. This comprehensive review examines the challenges of deploying computationally expensive LLMs on resource-constrained devices and explores innovative solutions across multiple domains. The paper investigates the development of on-device language models, their efficient architectures, including parameter sharing and modular designs, as well as state-of-the-art compression techniques like quantization, pruning, and knowledge distillation. Hardware acceleration strategies and collaborative edge-cloud deployment approaches are analyzed, highlighting the intricate balance between performance and resource utilization. Case studies of on-device language models from major mobile manufacturers demonstrate real-world applications and potential benefits. The review also addresses critical aspects such as adaptive learning, multi-modal capabilities, and personalization. By identifying key research directions and open challenges, this paper provides a roadmap for future advancements in on-device language models, emphasizing the need for interdisciplinary efforts to realize the full potential of ubiquitous, intelligent computing while ensuring responsible and ethical deployment. For a comprehensive review of research work and educational resources on on-device large language models (LLMs), please visit https://github.com/NexaAI/Awesome-LLMs-on-device. To download and run on-device LLMs, visit https://www.nexaai.com/models.

9/4/2024

Comprehensive Study on Performance Evaluation and Optimization of Model Compression: Bridging Traditional Deep Learning and Large Language Models

Aayush Saxena, Arit Kumar Bishwas, Ayush Ashok Mishra, Ryan Armstrong

Deep learning models have achieved tremendous success in most of the industries in recent years. The evolution of these models has also led to an increase in the model size and energy requirement, making it difficult to deploy in production on low compute devices. An increase in the number of connected devices around the world warrants compressed models that can be easily deployed at the local devices with low compute capacity and power accessibility. A wide range of solutions have been proposed by different researchers to reduce the size and complexity of such models, prominent among them are, Weight Quantization, Parameter Pruning, Network Pruning, low-rank representation, weights sharing, neural architecture search, knowledge distillation etc. In this research work, we investigate the performance impacts on various trained deep learning models, compressed using quantization and pruning techniques. We implemented both, quantization and pruning, compression techniques on popular deep learning models used in the image classification, object detection, language models and generative models-based problem statements. We also explored performance of various large language models (LLMs) after quantization and low rank adaptation. We used the standard evaluation metrics (model's size, accuracy, and inference time) for all the related problem statements and concluded this paper by discussing the challenges and future work.

7/24/2024

💬

On the Compressibility of Quantized Large Language Models

Yu Mao, Weilan Wang, Hongchao Du, Nan Guan, Chun Jason Xue

Deploying Large Language Models (LLMs) on edge or mobile devices offers significant benefits, such as enhanced data privacy and real-time processing capabilities. However, it also faces critical challenges due to the substantial memory requirement of LLMs. Quantization is an effective way of reducing the model size while maintaining good performance. However, even after quantization, LLMs may still be too big to fit entirely into the limited memory of edge or mobile devices and have to be partially loaded from the storage to complete the inference. In this case, the I/O latency of model loading becomes the bottleneck of the LLM inference latency. In this work, we take a preliminary step of studying applying data compression techniques to reduce data movement and thus speed up the inference of quantized LLM on memory-constrained devices. In particular, we discussed the compressibility of quantized LLMs, the trade-off between the compressibility and performance of quantized LLMs, and opportunities to optimize both of them jointly.

5/7/2024