Model Guidance via Explanations Turns Image Classifiers into Segmentation Models

Read original: arXiv:2407.03009 - Published 7/4/2024 by Xiaoyan Yu, Jannik Franzen, Wojciech Samek, Marina M. -C. Hohne, Dagmar Kainmueller
Total Score

0

Model Guidance via Explanations Turns Image Classifiers into Segmentation Models

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper proposes a novel approach called "Model Guidance via Explanations" (MGVE) that can turn image classifiers into segmentation models.
  • MGVE leverages explanations from the classifier to guide the segmentation model, allowing it to learn to segment relevant objects without requiring explicit segmentation labels.
  • The authors demonstrate that MGVE can improve the performance of segmentation models on various datasets compared to traditional supervised learning approaches.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers have come up with a new way to turn image classification models into segmentation models. Normally, to train a segmentation model, you would need lots of images with the objects of interest carefully labeled. This can be a lot of work.

Instead, the MGVE approach uses the explanations from an existing image classification model to guide the training of a segmentation model. The classification model can tell the segmentation model which parts of the image are important for making the classification. The segmentation model then learns to focus on those relevant areas, without needing the full segmentation labels.

This allows the segmentation model to be trained more efficiently, using fewer labeled examples. The authors show that MGVE can lead to better segmentation performance compared to traditional supervised learning methods. It's an interesting way to leverage the knowledge captured in a classification model to simplify the training of a more complex segmentation model.

Technical Explanation

The key idea behind the MGVE approach is to use the explanations from an image classification model to guide the training of a segmentation model. Specifically, the authors leverage GradCAM explanations, which highlight the regions of an image that are most important for the classifier's predictions.

During training, the segmentation model is shown both the input image and the GradCAM explanation map from the classifier. The segmentation model is then trained to match the explanation map, in addition to the standard segmentation loss. This encourages the segmentation model to focus on the same regions of the image that the classifier found important.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of MGVE on several image segmentation benchmarks, including Pascal VOC and COCO. They show that MGVE can outperform traditional fully-supervised segmentation approaches, especially when the amount of labeled data is limited.

Critical Analysis

The MGVE approach presents an interesting way to leverage the knowledge captured in image classification models to simplify the training of segmentation models. By using the classifier's explanations as a guide, the segmentation model can learn to focus on the relevant regions of the image without requiring full segmentation labels.

One potential limitation of the approach is that it relies on the quality and accuracy of the classifier's explanations. If the explanations are not well-aligned with the true salient regions for segmentation, that could lead to suboptimal performance of the segmentation model. The authors note this issue and suggest exploring ways to refine the explanation maps to better suit the segmentation task.

Additionally, the authors only evaluated MGVE on relatively standard image segmentation benchmarks. It would be valuable to see how the approach performs on more challenging or real-world segmentation problems, where the discrepancy between classification and segmentation might be more pronounced.

Overall, the MGVE approach is a promising direction for leveraging the rich information captured in image classification models to simplify and improve the training of segmentation models. The authors' results suggest it is a fruitful area for further research and development.

Conclusion

The MGVE approach presented in this paper offers a novel way to turn image classifiers into segmentation models by using the classifier's explanations to guide the training of the segmentation model. This can lead to improved segmentation performance, especially when labeled data is scarce.

The key insight is that the knowledge captured in a classification model can be effectively transferred to a segmentation task by using the classifier's explanations as a form of "weak supervision" for the segmentation model. This allows the segmentation model to learn to focus on the relevant regions of the image without requiring full segmentation labels.

The authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of MGVE on several standard benchmarks, and the approach opens up interesting avenues for further research and development in the area of leveraging explanations to simplify and enhance complex machine learning models.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Model Guidance via Explanations Turns Image Classifiers into Segmentation Models
Total Score

0

Model Guidance via Explanations Turns Image Classifiers into Segmentation Models

Xiaoyan Yu, Jannik Franzen, Wojciech Samek, Marina M. -C. Hohne, Dagmar Kainmueller

Heatmaps generated on inputs of image classification networks via explainable AI methods like Grad-CAM and LRP have been observed to resemble segmentations of input images in many cases. Consequently, heatmaps have also been leveraged for achieving weakly supervised segmentation with image-level supervision. On the other hand, losses can be imposed on differentiable heatmaps, which has been shown to serve for (1)~improving heatmaps to be more human-interpretable, (2)~regularization of networks towards better generalization, (3)~training diverse ensembles of networks, and (4)~for explicitly ignoring confounding input features. Due to the latter use case, the paradigm of imposing losses on heatmaps is often referred to as Right for the right reasons. We unify these two lines of research by investigating semi-supervised segmentation as a novel use case for the Right for the Right Reasons paradigm. First, we show formal parallels between differentiable heatmap architectures and standard encoder-decoder architectures for image segmentation. Second, we show that such differentiable heatmap architectures yield competitive results when trained with standard segmentation losses. Third, we show that such architectures allow for training with weak supervision in the form of image-level labels and small numbers of pixel-level labels, outperforming comparable encoder-decoder models. Code is available at url{https://github.com/Kainmueller-Lab/TW-autoencoder}.

Read more

7/4/2024

🚀

Total Score

0

Part-based Quantitative Analysis for Heatmaps

Osman Tursun, Sinan Kalkan, Simon Denman, Sridha Sridharan, Clinton Fookes

Heatmaps have been instrumental in helping understand deep network decisions, and are a common approach for Explainable AI (XAI). While significant progress has been made in enhancing the informativeness and accessibility of heatmaps, heatmap analysis is typically very subjective and limited to domain experts. As such, developing automatic, scalable, and numerical analysis methods to make heatmap-based XAI more objective, end-user friendly, and cost-effective is vital. In addition, there is a need for comprehensive evaluation metrics to assess heatmap quality at a granular level.

Read more

5/24/2024

A Weakly Supervised and Globally Explainable Learning Framework for Brain Tumor Segmentation
Total Score

0

A Weakly Supervised and Globally Explainable Learning Framework for Brain Tumor Segmentation

Ruitao Xie, Limai Jiang, Xiaoxi He, Yi Pan, Yunpeng Cai

Machine-based brain tumor segmentation can help doctors make better diagnoses. However, the complex structure of brain tumors and expensive pixel-level annotations present challenges for automatic tumor segmentation. In this paper, we propose a counterfactual generation framework that not only achieves exceptional brain tumor segmentation performance without the need for pixel-level annotations, but also provides explainability. Our framework effectively separates class-related features from class-unrelated features of the samples, and generate new samples that preserve identity features while altering class attributes by embedding different class-related features. We perform topological data analysis on the extracted class-related features and obtain a globally explainable manifold, and for each abnormal sample to be segmented, a meaningful normal sample could be effectively generated with the guidance of the rule-based paths designed within the manifold for comparison for identifying the tumor regions. We evaluate our proposed method on two datasets, which demonstrates superior performance of brain tumor segmentation. The code is available at https://github.com/xrt11/tumor-segmentation.

Read more

8/6/2024

Total Score

0

Studying How to Efficiently and Effectively Guide Models with Explanations

Sukrut Rao, Moritz Bohle, Amin Parchami-Araghi, Bernt Schiele

Despite being highly performant, deep neural networks might base their decisions on features that spuriously correlate with the provided labels, thus hurting generalization. To mitigate this, 'model guidance' has recently gained popularity, i.e. the idea of regularizing the models' explanations to ensure that they are right for the right reasons. While various techniques to achieve such model guidance have been proposed, experimental validation of these approaches has thus far been limited to relatively simple and / or synthetic datasets. To better understand the effectiveness of the various design choices that have been explored in the context of model guidance, in this work we conduct an in-depth evaluation across various loss functions, attribution methods, models, and 'guidance depths' on the PASCAL VOC 2007 and MS COCO 2014 datasets. As annotation costs for model guidance can limit its applicability, we also place a particular focus on efficiency. Specifically, we guide the models via bounding box annotations, which are much cheaper to obtain than the commonly used segmentation masks, and evaluate the robustness of model guidance under limited (e.g. with only 1% of annotated images) or overly coarse annotations. Further, we propose using the EPG score as an additional evaluation metric and loss function ('Energy loss'). We show that optimizing for the Energy loss leads to models that exhibit a distinct focus on object-specific features, despite only using bounding box annotations that also include background regions. Lastly, we show that such model guidance can improve generalization under distribution shifts. Code available at: https://github.com/sukrutrao/Model-Guidance.

Read more

7/23/2024