Model Inversion Robustness: Can Transfer Learning Help?
2405.05588
0
0
📈
Abstract
Model Inversion (MI) attacks aim to reconstruct private training data by abusing access to machine learning models. Contemporary MI attacks have achieved impressive attack performance, posing serious threats to privacy. Meanwhile, all existing MI defense methods rely on regularization that is in direct conflict with the training objective, resulting in noticeable degradation in model utility. In this work, we take a different perspective, and propose a novel and simple Transfer Learning-based Defense against Model Inversion (TL-DMI) to render MI-robust models. Particularly, by leveraging TL, we limit the number of layers encoding sensitive information from private training dataset, thereby degrading the performance of MI attack. We conduct an analysis using Fisher Information to justify our method. Our defense is remarkably simple to implement. Without bells and whistles, we show in extensive experiments that TL-DMI achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) MI robustness. Our code, pre-trained models, demo and inverted data are available at: https://hosytuyen.github.io/projects/TL-DMI
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Model Inversion (MI) attacks aim to reconstruct private training data from machine learning models.
- Existing MI defense methods rely on regularization, which can degrade model utility.
- This work proposes a novel Transfer Learning-based Defense against Model Inversion (TL-DMI) to make models more robust against MI attacks.
Plain English Explanation
Model Inversion (MI) attacks are a type of privacy threat where attackers try to reconstruct the private data used to train a machine learning model. These attacks have become increasingly sophisticated, posing serious risks to data privacy.
Existing defenses against MI attacks rely on a technique called regularization, which adds constraints to the model during training. However, this can negatively impact the model's overall performance and utility.
In this work, the researchers take a different approach. They propose a novel method called Transfer Learning-based Defense against Model Inversion (TL-DMI). The key idea is to leverage transfer learning, a technique where a model trained on one task is reused for a different task. By limiting the number of layers that encode sensitive information from the private training data, the researchers make it harder for attackers to reconstruct that data through MI attacks.
The paper provides an analysis using Fisher Information to explain the rationale behind this approach. Importantly, the TL-DMI defense is relatively simple to implement, and the researchers show that it achieves state-of-the-art performance in resisting MI attacks without significantly degrading the model's utility.
Technical Explanation
The researchers propose a novel Transfer Learning-based Defense against Model Inversion (TL-DMI) to address the limitations of existing MI defense methods. By leveraging transfer learning, they limit the number of layers that encode sensitive information from the private training dataset, thereby degrading the performance of MI attacks.
The researchers conduct an analysis using Fisher Information to justify their method. Fisher Information is a measure of the amount of information that an observable random variable (in this case, the model parameters) carries about an unknown parameter (in this case, the sensitive training data). By reducing the Fisher Information between the model parameters and the private training data, the researchers can make it harder for MI attacks to succeed.
In their extensive experiments, the researchers show that the TL-DMI defense achieves state-of-the-art MI robustness without significant degradation in model utility. This is in contrast to existing MI defense methods, which rely on regularization and often result in noticeable performance trade-offs.
The researchers make their code, pre-trained models, demo, and inverted data available online, allowing others to build upon their work.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge that their TL-DMI defense is not a silver bullet against all MI attacks. There may still be limitations or edge cases where it may not be as effective. For example, the paper mentions that advanced MI attacks like GI-SMN may still pose challenges.
Additionally, the researchers' analysis using Fisher Information provides theoretical justification for their approach, but there may be other factors or attack strategies that are not fully accounted for. Further research and real-world testing would be needed to evaluate the broader applicability and long-term effectiveness of the TL-DMI defense.
It would also be valuable to explore additional defenses that could complement or enhance the TL-DMI approach, potentially leading to even stronger privacy protections for machine learning models.
Conclusion
The researchers have presented a novel and promising approach to defending against Model Inversion (MI) attacks. By leveraging transfer learning, their TL-DMI defense can make machine learning models more robust to these privacy-compromising attacks without significant degradation in model utility.
This work highlights the importance of addressing privacy concerns in the development of machine learning systems. As these technologies become more ubiquitous, it is crucial to find effective ways to protect sensitive data and ensure the responsible deployment of AI. The TL-DMI defense represents a step in this direction, and the researchers' open-source contributions can help accelerate further advancements in this important field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Distributional Black-Box Model Inversion Attack with Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning
Huan Bao, Kaimin Wei, Yongdong Wu, Jin Qian, Robert H. Deng
0
0
A Model Inversion (MI) attack based on Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN) aims to recover the private training data from complex deep learning models by searching codes in the latent space. However, they merely search a deterministic latent space such that the found latent code is usually suboptimal. In addition, the existing distributional MI schemes assume that an attacker can access the structures and parameters of the target model, which is not always viable in practice. To overcome the above shortcomings, this paper proposes a novel Distributional Black-Box Model Inversion (DBB-MI) attack by constructing the probabilistic latent space for searching the target privacy data. Specifically, DBB-MI does not need the target model parameters or specialized GAN training. Instead, it finds the latent probability distribution by combining the output of the target model with multi-agent reinforcement learning techniques. Then, it randomly chooses latent codes from the latent probability distribution for recovering the private data. As the latent probability distribution closely aligns with the target privacy data in latent space, the recovered data will leak the privacy of training samples of the target model significantly. Abundant experiments conducted on diverse datasets and networks show that the present DBB-MI has better performance than state-of-the-art in attack accuracy, K-nearest neighbor feature distance, and Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio.
4/23/2024
Data Reconstruction Attacks and Defenses: A Systematic Evaluation
Sheng Liu, Zihan Wang, Yuxiao Chen, Qi Lei
0
0
Reconstruction attacks and defenses are essential in understanding the data leakage problem in machine learning. However, prior work has centered around empirical observations of gradient inversion attacks, lacks theoretical justifications, and cannot disentangle the usefulness of defending methods from the computational limitation of attacking methods. In this work, we propose to view the problem as an inverse problem, enabling us to theoretically, quantitatively, and systematically evaluate the data reconstruction problem. On various defense methods, we derived the algorithmic upper bound and the matching (in feature dimension and model width) information-theoretical lower bound on the reconstruction error for two-layer neural networks. To complement the theoretical results and investigate the utility-privacy trade-off, we defined a natural evaluation metric of the defense methods with similar utility loss among the strongest attacks. We further propose a strong reconstruction attack that helps update some previous understanding of the strength of defense methods under our proposed evaluation metric.
6/28/2024
🤯
MIST: Defending Against Membership Inference Attacks Through Membership-Invariant Subspace Training
Jiacheng Li, Ninghui Li, Bruno Ribeiro
0
0
In Member Inference (MI) attacks, the adversary try to determine whether an instance is used to train a machine learning (ML) model. MI attacks are a major privacy concern when using private data to train ML models. Most MI attacks in the literature take advantage of the fact that ML models are trained to fit the training data well, and thus have very low loss on training instances. Most defenses against MI attacks therefore try to make the model fit the training data less well. Doing so, however, generally results in lower accuracy. We observe that training instances have different degrees of vulnerability to MI attacks. Most instances will have low loss even when not included in training. For these instances, the model can fit them well without concerns of MI attacks. An effective defense only needs to (possibly implicitly) identify instances that are vulnerable to MI attacks and avoids overfitting them. A major challenge is how to achieve such an effect in an efficient training process. Leveraging two distinct recent advancements in representation learning: counterfactually-invariant representations and subspace learning methods, we introduce a novel Membership-Invariant Subspace Training (MIST) method to defend against MI attacks. MIST avoids overfitting the vulnerable instances without significant impact on other instances. We have conducted extensive experimental studies, comparing MIST with various other state-of-the-art (SOTA) MI defenses against several SOTA MI attacks. We find that MIST outperforms other defenses while resulting in minimal reduction in testing accuracy.
5/30/2024
🏋️
Transpose Attack: Stealing Datasets with Bidirectional Training
Guy Amit, Mosh Levy, Yisroel Mirsky
0
0
Deep neural networks are normally executed in the forward direction. However, in this work, we identify a vulnerability that enables models to be trained in both directions and on different tasks. Adversaries can exploit this capability to hide rogue models within seemingly legitimate models. In addition, in this work we show that neural networks can be taught to systematically memorize and retrieve specific samples from datasets. Together, these findings expose a novel method in which adversaries can exfiltrate datasets from protected learning environments under the guise of legitimate models. We focus on the data exfiltration attack and show that modern architectures can be used to secretly exfiltrate tens of thousands of samples with high fidelity, high enough to compromise data privacy and even train new models. Moreover, to mitigate this threat we propose a novel approach for detecting infected models.
5/20/2024