More Samples or More Prompts? Exploring Effective In-Context Sampling for LLM Few-Shot Prompt Engineering
2311.09782
0
0
🌿
Abstract
While most existing works on LLM prompting techniques focus only on how to select a better set of data samples inside one single prompt input (In-Context Learning or ICL), why can not we design and leverage multiple prompts together to further improve the LLM's performance? In this work, we propose In-Context Sampling (ICS), a low-resource LLM prompting technique to produce confident predictions by optimizing the construction of multiple ICL prompt inputs. Extensive experiments with three open-source LLMs (FlanT5-XL, Mistral-7B, and Mixtral-8x7B) on four NLI datasets (e-SNLI, Multi-NLI, ANLI, and Contract-NLI) and one QA dataset (CommonsenseQA) illustrate that ICS can consistently enhance LLMs' performance. An in-depth evaluation with three data similarity-based ICS strategies suggests that these strategies can further elevate LLM's performance, which sheds light on a new yet promising future research direction.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Existing research on language model (LLM) prompting techniques has focused on selecting better data samples within a single prompt input (In-Context Learning or ICL).
- This paper proposes a new approach called In-Context Sampling (ICS) that leverages multiple prompts together to further improve LLM performance, especially in low-resource settings.
- Extensive experiments with three open-source LLMs and several datasets show that ICS can consistently enhance performance compared to using a single prompt.
- The paper also evaluates different data similarity-based strategies for constructing ICS prompts, finding that these strategies can further elevate LLM performance, suggesting a promising future research direction.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a new way to improve the performance of large language models (LLMs) on various tasks, such as natural language inference and question answering. Most existing research has looked at how to choose the best set of example data to include within a single prompt that is given to the LLM.
This paper proposes a different approach called "In-Context Sampling" (ICS). The key idea is to create not just one prompt, but multiple prompts, and then have the LLM consider all of them together when generating its output. The researchers find that this multi-prompt approach can consistently lead to better performance compared to using a single prompt, especially when the available training data is limited.
The paper also explores different strategies for how to construct these multiple prompts, based on the similarity of the data used in each prompt. The results suggest that more sophisticated prompt construction methods can further boost the LLM's performance, opening up a new and promising area for future research.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel prompting technique called In-Context Sampling (ICS) that aims to improve the performance of language models, especially in low-resource settings. While existing work has focused on selecting a better set of data samples within a single prompt (In-Context Learning or ICL), this paper hypothesizes that jointly optimizing the construction of multiple prompts can further enhance language model performance.
The ICS approach involves dynamically generating multiple prompts from the available training data and then having the language model consider all of these prompts together when generating its output. The paper evaluates ICS using three open-source language models (FlanT5-XL, Mistral-7B, and Mixtral-8x7B) on four natural language inference (NLI) datasets (e-SNLI, Multi-NLI, ANLI, and Contract-NLI) and one question answering (QA) dataset (CommonsenseQA).
The experiments demonstrate that the ICS approach can consistently outperform using a single prompt across these diverse tasks and language models. Furthermore, the paper explores three data similarity-based strategies for constructing the multiple prompts within the ICS framework. The results suggest that these more sophisticated prompt construction methods can further elevate the language model's performance, pointing to a promising new research direction.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed study that rigorously evaluates the proposed ICS prompting technique across multiple language models and datasets. The extensive experiments provide compelling evidence that leveraging multiple prompts can indeed enhance language model performance, especially in low-resource settings.
One limitation mentioned in the paper is that the ICS approach may require more computational resources than using a single prompt, as the language model needs to consider multiple prompts. The authors acknowledge this trade-off and suggest that future work could explore ways to balance the performance gains with computational efficiency.
Additionally, the paper focuses on evaluating ICS on relatively well-established NLI and QA tasks. It would be interesting to see how the ICS approach generalizes to other language understanding and generation tasks, such as dialogue, summarization, or commonsense reasoning.
While the paper provides a thorough exploration of data similarity-based prompt construction strategies, there may be other promising approaches worth investigating, such as using reinforcement learning or meta-learning to automatically optimize the prompt generation process.
Overall, the paper makes a compelling case for the potential of the ICS prompting technique and opens up a new and exciting research direction for further improving the capabilities of large language models.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel prompting technique called In-Context Sampling (ICS) that leverages multiple prompts to enhance the performance of large language models, particularly in low-resource settings. Extensive experiments across diverse tasks and language models demonstrate the consistent advantages of the ICS approach over using a single prompt.
The paper also explores different strategies for constructing the multiple prompts within the ICS framework, suggesting that more sophisticated prompt construction methods can further elevate language model performance. These findings point to a promising new research direction that could lead to significant advancements in language understanding and generation capabilities.
As language models continue to play an increasingly important role in various applications, techniques like ICS that can improve their performance, especially in resource-constrained scenarios, could have far-reaching implications for the field of natural language processing and its real-world impact.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌿
A Survey on In-context Learning
Qingxiu Dong, Lei Li, Damai Dai, Ce Zheng, Jingyuan Ma, Rui Li, Heming Xia, Jingjing Xu, Zhiyong Wu, Baobao Chang, Xu Sun, Lei Li, Zhifang Sui
0
0
With the increasing capabilities of large language models (LLMs), in-context learning (ICL) has emerged as a new paradigm for natural language processing (NLP), where LLMs make predictions based on contexts augmented with a few examples. It has been a significant trend to explore ICL to evaluate and extrapolate the ability of LLMs. In this paper, we aim to survey and summarize the progress and challenges of ICL. We first present a formal definition of ICL and clarify its correlation to related studies. Then, we organize and discuss advanced techniques, including training strategies, prompt designing strategies, and related analysis. Additionally, we explore various ICL application scenarios, such as data engineering and knowledge updating. Finally, we address the challenges of ICL and suggest potential directions for further research. We hope that our work can encourage more research on uncovering how ICL works and improving ICL.
6/19/2024
🛠️
Prompt Optimization via Adversarial In-Context Learning
Xuan Long Do, Yiran Zhao, Hannah Brown, Yuxi Xie, James Xu Zhao, Nancy F. Chen, Kenji Kawaguchi, Michael Shieh, Junxian He
0
0
We propose a new method, Adversarial In-Context Learning (adv-ICL), to optimize prompt for in-context learning (ICL) by employing one LLM as a generator, another as a discriminator, and a third as a prompt modifier. As in traditional adversarial learning, adv-ICL is implemented as a two-player game between the generator and discriminator, where the generator tries to generate realistic enough output to fool the discriminator. In each round, given an input prefixed by task instructions and several exemplars, the generator produces an output. The discriminator is then tasked with classifying the generator input-output pair as model-generated or real data. Based on the discriminator loss, the prompt modifier proposes possible edits to the generator and discriminator prompts, and the edits that most improve the adversarial loss are selected. We show that adv-ICL results in significant improvements over state-of-the-art prompt optimization techniques for both open and closed-source models on 11 generation and classification tasks including summarization, arithmetic reasoning, machine translation, data-to-text generation, and the MMLU and big-bench hard benchmarks. In addition, because our method uses pre-trained models and updates only prompts rather than model parameters, it is computationally efficient, easy to extend to any LLM and task, and effective in low-resource settings.
6/26/2024
Privacy Preserving Prompt Engineering: A Survey
Kennedy Edemacu, Xintao Wu
0
0
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have demonstrated significant proficiency in solving a wide range of general natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Researchers have observed a direct correlation between the performance of these models and their sizes. As a result, the sizes of these models have notably expanded in recent years, persuading researchers to adopt the term large language models (LLMs) to characterize the larger-sized PLMs. The size expansion comes with a distinct capability called in-context learning (ICL), which represents a special form of prompting and allows the models to be utilized through the presentation of demonstration examples without modifications to the model parameters. Although interesting, privacy concerns have become a major obstacle in its widespread usage. Multiple studies have examined the privacy risks linked to ICL and prompting in general, and have devised techniques to alleviate these risks. Thus, there is a necessity to organize these mitigation techniques for the benefit of the community. This survey provides a systematic overview of the privacy protection methods employed during ICL and prompting in general. We review, analyze, and compare different methods under this paradigm. Furthermore, we provide a summary of the resources accessible for the development of these frameworks. Finally, we discuss the limitations of these frameworks and offer a detailed examination of the promising areas that necessitate further exploration.
4/12/2024
🌿
Let's Learn Step by Step: Enhancing In-Context Learning Ability with Curriculum Learning
Yinpeng Liu, Jiawei Liu, Xiang Shi, Qikai Cheng, Yong Huang, Wei Lu
0
0
Demonstration ordering, which is an important strategy for in-context learning (ICL), can significantly affects the performance of large language models (LLMs). However, most of the current approaches of ordering require high computational costs to introduce the priori knowledge. In this paper, inspired by the human learning process, we propose a simple but effective demonstration ordering method for ICL, named the few-shot In-Context Curriculum Learning (ICCL). The ICCL implies gradually increasing the complexity of prompt demonstrations during the inference process. The difficulty can be assessed by human experts or LLMs-driven metrics, such as perplexity. Then we design extensive experiments to discuss the effectiveness of the ICCL at both corpus-level and instance-level. Moreover, we also investigate the formation mechanism of LLM's ICCL capability. Experimental results demonstrate that ICCL, developed during the instruction-tuning stage, is effective for representative open-source LLMs. To facilitate further research and applications by other scholars, we make the code publicly available.
6/18/2024