Multi-agent based modeling for investigating excess heat utilization from electrolyzer production to district heating network

Overview

• Power-to-Hydrogen is crucial for the renewable energy transition, but existing research lacks business models for the excess heat it generates.
• This study evaluates three models for selling electrolyzer-generated heat to district heating grids: constant, flexible, and renewable-source hydrogen production, with and without heat sales.
• Using agent-based modeling and multi-criteria decision-making methods, the study finds that selling excess heat can cut hydrogen production costs by 5.6%.
• The optimal model operates flexibly with electricity spot prices, includes heat sales, and maintains a hydrogen price of 3.3 EUR/kg.
• Hydrogen production from grid electricity could emit up to 13,783.8 tons of CO2 over four years, but the best economic and environmental model uses renewable sources and sells heat at 3.5 EUR/kg.

Plain English Explanation

The paper explores how Power-to-Hydrogen technology, which converts renewable electricity into hydrogen fuel, can be made more financially and environmentally viable. One key challenge is that this process also generates a significant amount of excess heat, and the researchers wanted to find effective ways to sell that heat and offset the overall costs.

The researchers looked at three different business models for selling the heat from hydrogen production:

1. Constant production: Hydrogen is produced at a fixed rate, regardless of electricity prices.
2. Flexible production: Hydrogen production is adjusted based on fluctuating electricity spot market prices.
3. Renewable-source production: Hydrogen is produced using only renewable electricity sources.

For each of these models, the researchers also considered whether the excess heat was sold to local district heating grids or not. They used computer simulations and decision-making tools to evaluate the economic and environmental impacts of these different approaches.

The key finding was that selling the excess heat could reduce the overall cost of hydrogen production by around 5.6%. The optimal model was the flexible one that adjusted production based on electricity prices and also included heat sales. This allowed them to maintain a relatively low hydrogen price of 3.3 EUR/kg.

Environmentally, the researchers found that producing hydrogen from standard grid electricity could result in significant CO2 emissions – up to 13,783.8 tons over four years. However, the best approach both economically and environmentally was the renewable-source model that sold heat at 3.5 EUR/kg.

Technical Explanation

The study used an agent-based modeling approach to simulate three different business models for Power-to-Hydrogen systems:

1. Constant hydrogen production: Electrolyzer production maintained at a fixed rate regardless of electricity prices.
2. Flexible hydrogen production: Electrolyzer production adjusted dynamically based on fluctuating electricity spot market prices.
3. Renewable-source hydrogen production: Electrolyzer production using only renewable electricity sources.

For each model, the researchers considered two scenarios: one where the excess heat generated during hydrogen production was sold to local district heating grids, and one where it was not.

To evaluate the economic and environmental performance of these models, the researchers employed multi-criteria decision-making methods including VIKOR, TOPSIS, and PROMETHEE. Key metrics included hydrogen production costs, CO2 emissions, and the selling price of hydrogen.

The results showed that selling the excess heat could reduce overall hydrogen production costs by 5.6%. The optimal model was the flexible one that adjusted production based on electricity prices and included heat sales, allowing a hydrogen price of 3.3 EUR/kg.

Environmentally, hydrogen production from standard grid electricity could result in up to 13,783.8 tons of CO2 emissions over four years. However, the renewable-source model that sold heat at 3.5 EUR/kg had the best economic and environmental performance.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of different business models for Power-to-Hydrogen systems and the role of excess heat management. The use of agent-based modeling and multi-criteria decision-making methods is a robust approach to evaluating the trade-offs between economic and environmental factors.

One potential limitation is the reliance on simulated data rather than real-world operational data. While the modeling approach is sound, actual performance may differ depending on factors like local electricity and heat market conditions. Additionally, the analysis focuses on a specific geographic context, so the findings may not be directly generalizable to other regions.

Further research could explore the sensitivity of the results to changes in key input parameters, such as electricity prices, hydrogen demand, and heat market dynamics. Investigating the potential for synergies with other energy-intensive industries that could utilize the excess heat could also yield additional insights.

Overall, the study provides a valuable framework for optimizing the business models and environmental impact of Power-to-Hydrogen systems, which will be crucial for the renewable energy transition.

Conclusion

This study highlights the importance of considering the excess heat generated by Power-to-Hydrogen systems and how selling that heat can significantly improve the economic and environmental viability of this technology.

The findings suggest that a flexible business model that adjusts hydrogen production based on electricity prices and includes heat sales to local district heating grids is the optimal approach. This can reduce hydrogen production costs by over 5% and maintain a selling price of around 3.3 EUR/kg, while also dramatically cutting CO2 emissions compared to using grid electricity.

As renewable energy sources continue to grow, Power-to-Hydrogen will play a crucial role in the energy transition. This research provides a valuable framework for optimizing the economic and environmental performance of these systems through innovative business models that leverage excess heat.