Multi-objective Evolution of Heuristic Using Large Language Model

Overview

• Heuristics are commonly used to solve diverse search and optimization problems
• Designing effective heuristics usually requires manual effort and domain knowledge
• Recent works have incorporated large language models (LLMs) to automate heuristic search
• Existing research focuses on optimal performance, neglecting other practical criteria like efficiency and scalability
• This paper proposes modeling heuristic search as a multi-objective optimization problem to consider multiple design criteria

Plain English Explanation

Heuristics are rules of thumb or shortcuts that can be used to solve complex problems. They are often used in areas like optimization and algorithm design. Traditionally, designing effective heuristics requires a lot of manual work and expert knowledge of the problem domain.

Recent research has started to use powerful language models to automate the process of finding good heuristics. However, these approaches have focused mainly on getting the best possible performance on the target problem, without considering other important factors like how efficient or scalable the heuristics are.

This paper proposes a new way of looking at the problem. Instead of just trying to maximize performance, it models heuristic search as a multi-objective optimization problem. This means the system tries to find heuristics that balance multiple design criteria, such as performance, efficiency, and scalability.

Due to the complexity of the search space, conventional multi-objective optimization methods struggle to effectively handle this kind of multi-objective heuristic search. So the researchers developed a new framework called "Multi-objective Evolution of Heuristic" (MEoH) that uses language models in a novel way to generate a diverse set of high-performing heuristics that satisfy multiple objectives.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contributions of this paper are:

1. Multi-objective Heuristic Search: The authors propose modeling heuristic search as a multi-objective optimization problem, considering not just optimal performance but also other practical criteria like efficiency and scalability.

2. MEoH Framework: They develop a new framework called "Multi-objective Evolution of Heuristic" (MEoH) that integrates large language models in a zero-shot manner to generate a diverse set of high-performing heuristics that satisfy multiple objectives.

3. Dominance-Dissimilarity Mechanism: MEoH uses a novel "dominance-dissimilarity" mechanism for effective population management and selection, which incorporates both code dissimilarity in the search space and dominance in the objective space.

The authors evaluate MEoH on two well-known combinatorial optimization problems: the online Bin Packing Problem (BPP) and the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP). The results show that MEoH can automatically generate a variety of elite heuristics in a single run, offering more trade-off options than existing methods. It achieves competitive or superior performance while improving efficiency by up to 10 times.

The multi-objective search also leads to the discovery of diverse heuristics, providing new insights into heuristic design.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to improving the efficiency and scalability of heuristic search, which is an important practical concern often overlooked in research focused solely on optimal performance.

One potential limitation is that the proposed MEoH framework relies on the availability of large language models, which may not be accessible to all researchers or practitioners. The authors acknowledge this and suggest exploring ways to make the approach more widely applicable.

Additionally, while the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of MEoH on two specific combinatorial optimization problems, it would be valuable to see how the framework performs on a broader range of problem domains to assess its generalizability.

Further research could also explore ways to make the multi-objective optimization process more transparent and interpretable, helping users understand the trade-offs between different design criteria and the reasoning behind the generated heuristics.

Conclusion

This paper presents an innovative approach to automating the design of heuristics for search and optimization problems. By modeling heuristic search as a multi-objective optimization problem, the researchers have developed a framework that can generate a diverse set of high-performing heuristics that balance multiple practical design criteria, such as performance, efficiency, and scalability.

The results demonstrate the potential of large language models to revolutionize the field of heuristic design, offering a powerful tool for practitioners and researchers to tackle complex real-world problems more effectively. This work opens up exciting new avenues for further research and development in the area of automated algorithm design.