A Multimodal Feature Distillation with CNN-Transformer Network for Brain Tumor Segmentation with Incomplete Modalities
2404.14019
0
0
â¨
Abstract
Existing brain tumor segmentation methods usually utilize multiple Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) modalities in brain tumor images for segmentation, which can achieve better segmentation performance. However, in clinical applications, some modalities are missing due to resource constraints, leading to severe degradation in the performance of methods applying complete modality segmentation. In this paper, we propose a Multimodal feature distillation with Convolutional Neural Network (CNN)-Transformer hybrid network (MCTSeg) for accurate brain tumor segmentation with missing modalities. We first design a Multimodal Feature Distillation (MFD) module to distill feature-level multimodal knowledge into different unimodality to extract complete modality information. We further develop a Unimodal Feature Enhancement (UFE) module to model the relationship between global and local information semantically. Finally, we build a Cross-Modal Fusion (CMF) module to explicitly align the global correlations among different modalities even when some modalities are missing. Complementary features within and across different modalities are refined via the CNN-Transformer hybrid architectures in both the UFE and CMF modules, where local and global dependencies are both captured. Our ablation study demonstrates the importance of the proposed modules with CNN-Transformer networks and the convolutional blocks in Transformer for improving the performance of brain tumor segmentation with missing modalities. Extensive experiments on the BraTS2018 and BraTS2020 datasets show that the proposed MCTSeg framework outperforms the state-of-the-art methods in missing modalities cases. Our code is available at: https://github.com/mkang315/MCTSeg.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Existing brain tumor segmentation methods rely on multiple Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) modalities, which can achieve better performance.
- However, in clinical settings, some modalities may be missing due to resource constraints, leading to a severe degradation in segmentation performance.
- The paper proposes a Multimodal feature distillation with Convolutional Neural Network (CNN)-Transformer hybrid network (MCTSeg) for accurate brain tumor segmentation with missing modalities.
Plain English Explanation
Brain tumors are a serious health issue, and accurately diagnosing and treating them is crucial. One way doctors can get a better understanding of a brain tumor is through Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scans, which can provide different views of the tumor.
However, in some medical settings, not all the different MRI scans may be available due to limited resources or equipment. This can make it harder for doctors to accurately identify and segment the tumor.
The researchers in this paper have developed a new approach called MCTSeg that can still perform accurate brain tumor segmentation even when some of the MRI scans are missing. The key idea is to use a combination of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and transformer models to learn the relationships between the different MRI modalities, even when some are missing.
By distilling the knowledge from the complete MRI modalities and enhancing the features from the available modalities, the MCTSeg model can still provide accurate tumor segmentation. This is an important advancement, as it can help doctors make better decisions about diagnosis and treatment, even in resource-constrained settings.
Technical Explanation
The proposed MCTSeg framework consists of three main modules:
-
Multimodal Feature Distillation (MFD) Module: This module distills feature-level multimodal knowledge into different unimodality inputs to extract complete modality information, even when some modalities are missing.
-
Unimodal Feature Enhancement (UFE) Module: This module models the relationship between global and local information semantically, further enhancing the features from the available modalities.
-
Cross-Modal Fusion (CMF) Module: This module explicitly aligns the global correlations among different modalities, even when some modalities are missing, by fusing the complementary features within and across different modalities.
The researchers use a CNN-Transformer hybrid architecture in both the UFE and CMF modules, where local and global dependencies are captured to improve the performance of brain tumor segmentation with missing modalities.
The paper's ablation study demonstrates the importance of the proposed modules and the CNN-Transformer networks, as well as the contribution of the convolutional blocks in the Transformer for improving the performance of brain tumor segmentation with missing modalities.
The researchers evaluated the proposed MCTSeg framework on the BraTS2018 and BraTS2020 datasets and showed that it outperforms state-of-the-art methods in missing modalities cases.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for brain tumor segmentation in the presence of missing modalities, which is a common challenge in clinical settings. The researchers have tackled this problem effectively by introducing several novel modules and leveraging the strengths of both CNNs and Transformer models.
One potential limitation of the study is that it was evaluated only on the BraTS2018 and BraTS2020 datasets, which may not fully represent the diversity of real-world clinical data. Further validation on a broader range of datasets, including data from different hospitals or imaging systems, would help to strengthen the generalizability of the MCTSeg framework.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the computational complexity or inference time of the proposed model, which are important practical considerations for clinical deployment. Comparing the efficiency of MCTSeg to other state-of-the-art methods would be valuable for understanding its suitability for real-time applications.
Overall, the MCTSeg framework represents an exciting advancement in the field of brain tumor segmentation, and the researchers' use of CNN-Transformer hybrid architectures and feature distillation techniques is a promising direction for addressing the challenge of missing modalities in medical imaging applications.
Conclusion
The paper presents the MCTSeg framework, a novel approach for accurate brain tumor segmentation in the presence of missing MRI modalities. By leveraging multimodal feature distillation, unimodal feature enhancement, and cross-modal fusion within a CNN-Transformer hybrid architecture, the researchers have developed a system that can maintain high segmentation performance even when some MRI modalities are unavailable. This is a significant advancement that can potentially improve clinical decision-making and patient outcomes in resource-constrained healthcare settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Multi-modal Evidential Fusion Network for Trusted PET/CT Tumor Segmentation
Yuxuan Qi, Li Lin, Jiajun Wang, Jingya Zhang, Bin Zhang
0
0
Accurate segmentation of tumors in PET/CT images is important in computer-aided diagnosis and treatment of cancer. The key issue of such a segmentation problem lies in the effective integration of complementary information from PET and CT images. However, the quality of PET and CT images varies widely in clinical settings, which leads to uncertainty in the modality information extracted by networks. To take the uncertainty into account in multi-modal information fusion, this paper proposes a novel Multi-modal Evidential Fusion Network (MEFN) comprising a Cross-Modal Feature Learning (CFL) module and a Multi-modal Trusted Fusion (MTF) module. The CFL module reduces the domain gap upon modality conversion and highlights common tumor features, thereby alleviating the needs of the segmentation module to handle modality specificity. The MTF module utilizes mutual attention mechanisms and an uncertainty calibrator to fuse modality features based on modality uncertainty and then fuse the segmentation results under the guidance of Dempster-Shafer Theory. Besides, a new uncertainty perceptual loss is introduced to force the model focusing on uncertain features and hence improve its ability to extract trusted modality information. Extensive comparative experiments are conducted on two publicly available PET/CT datasets to evaluate the performance of our proposed method whose results demonstrate that our MEFN significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods with improvements of 2.15% and 3.23% in DSC scores on the AutoPET dataset and the Hecktor dataset, respectively. More importantly, our model can provide radiologists with credible uncertainty of the segmentation results for their decision in accepting or rejecting the automatic segmentation results, which is particularly important for clinical applications. Our code will be available at https://github.com/QPaws/MEFN.
6/27/2024
Unveiling Incomplete Modality Brain Tumor Segmentation: Leveraging Masked Predicted Auto-Encoder and Divergence Learning
Zhongao Sun, Jiameng Li, Yuhan Wang, Jiarong Cheng, Qing Zhou, Chun Li
0
0
Brain tumor segmentation remains a significant challenge, particularly in the context of multi-modal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) where missing modality images are common in clinical settings, leading to reduced segmentation accuracy. To address this issue, we propose a novel strategy, which is called masked predicted pre-training, enabling robust feature learning from incomplete modality data. Additionally, in the fine-tuning phase, we utilize a knowledge distillation technique to align features between complete and missing modality data, simultaneously enhancing model robustness. Notably, we leverage the Holder pseudo-divergence instead of the KLD for distillation loss, offering improve mathematical interpretability and properties. Extensive experiments on the BRATS2018 and BRATS2020 datasets demonstrate significant performance enhancements compared to existing state-of-the-art methods.
6/14/2024
Enhancing Incomplete Multi-modal Brain Tumor Segmentation with Intra-modal Asymmetry and Inter-modal Dependency
Weide Liu, Jingwen Hou, Xiaoyang Zhong, Huijing Zhan, Jun Cheng, Yuming Fang, Guanghui Yue
0
0
Deep learning-based brain tumor segmentation (BTS) models for multi-modal MRI images have seen significant advancements in recent years. However, a common problem in practice is the unavailability of some modalities due to varying scanning protocols and patient conditions, making segmentation from incomplete MRI modalities a challenging issue. Previous methods have attempted to address this by fusing accessible multi-modal features, leveraging attention mechanisms, and synthesizing missing modalities using generative models. However, these methods ignore the intrinsic problems of medical image segmentation, such as the limited availability of training samples, particularly for cases with tumors. Furthermore, these methods require training and deploying a specific model for each subset of missing modalities. To address these issues, we propose a novel approach that enhances the BTS model from two perspectives. Firstly, we introduce a pre-training stage that generates a diverse pre-training dataset covering a wide range of different combinations of tumor shapes and brain anatomy. Secondly, we propose a post-training stage that enables the model to reconstruct missing modalities in the prediction results when only partial modalities are available. To achieve the pre-training stage, we conceptually decouple the MRI image into two parts: `anatomy' and `tumor'. We pre-train the BTS model using synthesized data generated from the anatomy and tumor parts across different training samples. ... Extensive experiments demonstrate that our proposed method significantly improves the performance over the baseline and achieves new state-of-the-art results on three brain tumor segmentation datasets: BRATS2020, BRATS2018, and BRATS2015.
6/17/2024
On Enhancing Brain Tumor Segmentation Across Diverse Populations with Convolutional Neural Networks
Fadillah Maani, Anees Ur Rehman Hashmi, Numan Saeed, Mohammad Yaqub
0
0
Brain tumor segmentation is a fundamental step in assessing a patient's cancer progression. However, manual segmentation demands significant expert time to identify tumors in 3D multimodal brain MRI scans accurately. This reliance on manual segmentation makes the process prone to intra- and inter-observer variability. This work proposes a brain tumor segmentation method as part of the BraTS-GoAT challenge. The task is to segment tumors in brain MRI scans automatically from various populations, such as adults, pediatrics, and underserved sub-Saharan Africa. We employ a recent CNN architecture for medical image segmentation, namely MedNeXt, as our baseline, and we implement extensive model ensembling and postprocessing for inference. Our experiments show that our method performs well on the unseen validation set with an average DSC of 85.54% and HD95 of 27.88. The code is available on https://github.com/BioMedIA-MBZUAI/BraTS2024_BioMedIAMBZ.
5/7/2024