Multiscale Sliced Wasserstein Distances as Perceptual Color Difference Measures

Overview

• This paper introduces a new perceptual color difference measure based on multiscale Sliced Wasserstein distances.
• The authors propose using Sliced Wasserstein distances, which capture higher-order statistical information, to better model human color perception compared to existing metrics.
• The method is evaluated on standard color difference benchmarks and shown to outperform existing approaches.

Plain English Explanation

When we look at two colors, our eyes and brain perceive the difference between them in a certain way. Existing color difference metrics, like Euclidean distance in color spaces, don't always capture this perceptual difference well. Sliced Wasserstein distances are a more sophisticated way to compare two color distributions that can better model human color perception.

In this work, the authors use a multiscale analysis of Sliced Wasserstein distances to create a new perceptual color difference measure. This accounts for how we perceive color differences at different scales, from fine details to overall impressions.

The researchers show that this new metric outperforms existing color difference measures on standard benchmarks, like the ColorVIDEVDP dataset. This suggests it may be a better way to quantify differences between colors in a way that matches human perception.

Technical Explanation

The core idea of the paper is to use Sliced Wasserstein distances as a perceptual color difference measure. Sliced Wasserstein distances capture higher-order statistical information about color distributions, compared to simpler metrics like Euclidean distance in color spaces.

The authors propose a multiscale analysis, where Sliced Wasserstein distances are computed at multiple resolutions. This allows the metric to capture perceptual color differences at different scales, from fine details to overall impressions.

Experimentally, the proposed multiscale Sliced Wasserstein distance is evaluated on standard color difference benchmarks, including the ColorVIDEVDP dataset. The results show that it outperforms existing color difference measures, suggesting it is a more perceptually-aligned way to quantify color differences.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a strong technical foundation for the proposed multiscale Sliced Wasserstein distance metric. However, as with any research, there are some caveats and limitations to consider:

• The benchmarks used, while standard, may not fully capture the nuances of human color perception in real-world scenarios. Further validation on a wider range of datasets would strengthen the claims.

• The multiscale analysis introduces additional hyperparameters, which could make the metric more difficult to tune and apply in practice. Approaches like learning invariant inter-pixel correlations may offer more automatic ways to handle multiscale considerations.

• While the Sliced Wasserstein distance is a principled way to compare color distributions, it may still not capture all the complexities of human visual perception, such as the impact of spatial context or temporal dynamics. Further research is needed to fully understand the limitations of this approach.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel perceptual color difference measure based on multiscale Sliced Wasserstein distances. By capturing higher-order statistical information about color distributions and accounting for perceptual differences at multiple scales, the proposed metric outperforms existing color difference measures on standard benchmarks.

While the technical foundations are strong, there are still opportunities to further validate and refine the approach to better align with the complexities of human color perception. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in developing more perceptually-accurate color difference measures, with potential applications in fields like image processing, computer graphics, and industrial design.