Multivariate Trend Filtering for Lattice Data
0
📊
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• The paper introduces a multivariate version of trend filtering called Kronecker Trend Filtering (KTF), which is an extension of univariate trend filtering.
• KTF is defined by minimizing a penalized least squares problem, where the penalty term sums the absolute (higher-order) differences of the parameter to be estimated along each coordinate direction.
• The paper provides a comprehensive theoretical analysis of KTF, revealing its advantages over linear smoothers in estimating heterogeneously smooth functions and a phase transition in high dimensions.
• The paper also leverages recent results on discrete splines to enable fast estimation of KTF at off-lattice locations.
Plain English Explanation
Trend filtering is a technique used to smooth and analyze data with underlying trends. The authors of this paper have developed a more advanced version of trend filtering called Kronecker Trend Filtering (KTF) that can handle data with multiple dimensions, such as images or time series.
In KTF, the data is arranged in a grid or lattice structure, and the smoothing process involves minimizing a penalty function that considers the differences between neighboring data points along each dimension of the grid. This allows KTF to adaptively capture complex patterns in the data, such as areas with varying degrees of smoothness.
The paper provides a thorough mathematical analysis of KTF, demonstrating its advantages over simpler linear smoothing methods, especially when the underlying function being estimated has heterogeneous smoothness (varying degrees of smoothness in different regions). The authors also show that as the number of dimensions increases, linear smoothers can completely fail to produce accurate estimates, while KTF remains consistent.
Additionally, the paper introduces a technique to quickly estimate the KTF model at any location, even if that location is not part of the original grid. This is achieved by leveraging recent advances in the theory of discrete splines, a type of piecewise polynomial function that underlies the KTF approach.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a multivariate version of trend filtering called Kronecker Trend Filtering (KTF), which is designed to handle data arranged in a lattice structure with multiple dimensions. KTF is defined by minimizing a penalized least squares problem, where the penalty term sums the absolute (higher-order) differences of the parameter to be estimated along each coordinate direction.
This penalty structure can be expressed in terms of Kronecker products of univariate trend filtering penalty operators, hence the name "Kronecker Trend Filtering." Alternatively, KTF can be viewed as an $\ell_1$-penalized basis regression problem, where the basis functions are tensor products of falling factorial functions, a piecewise polynomial (discrete spline) basis that underlies univariate trend filtering.
The paper provides a comprehensive theoretical analysis of KTF, covering its behavior for different orders of smoothing (k) and dimensions (d). The results reveal several interesting phenomena, including the dominance of KTF over linear smoothers in estimating heterogeneously smooth functions, and a phase transition at $d=2(k+1)$, a boundary past which (on the high dimension-to-smoothness side) linear smoothers fail to be consistent entirely.
The authors also leverage recent results on discrete splines from Tibshirani (2020), particularly discrete spline interpolation results, to enable the extension of the KTF estimate to any off-lattice location in constant-time (independent of the size of the lattice n).
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thorough theoretical analysis of Kronecker Trend Filtering (KTF) and its advantages over linear smoothers, especially for high-dimensional data with heterogeneous smoothness. However, the paper does not provide any empirical evaluation or real-world applications of KTF.
While the theoretical results are compelling, it would be valuable to see how KTF performs in practice, particularly in comparison to other advanced smoothing techniques like generalized Langevin equations or Kalman filters. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational efficiency of KTF or its scalability to very large datasets.
Furthermore, the paper focuses on the case where the design points form a regular lattice structure. It would be interesting to explore how KTF can be extended to handle more general, irregular grid structures, which are common in real-world applications.
Conclusion
The paper introduces Kronecker Trend Filtering (KTF), a multivariate extension of univariate trend filtering, and provides a comprehensive theoretical analysis of its properties. KTF is shown to have significant advantages over linear smoothers, particularly in estimating heterogeneously smooth functions and in high-dimensional settings.
The paper's contributions include a unified treatment of KTF, revealing interesting theoretical insights, and the leveraging of recent results on discrete splines to enable fast estimation at off-lattice locations. While the paper lacks empirical evaluation, the theoretical results suggest that KTF could be a powerful tool for smoothing and analyzing complex, high-dimensional data, with potential applications in fields like image processing, time series analysis, and uncertainty quantification.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
0
Multivariate Trend Filtering for Lattice Data
Veeranjaneyulu Sadhanala, Yu-Xiang Wang, Addison J. Hu, Ryan J. Tibshirani
We study a multivariate version of trend filtering, called Kronecker trend filtering or KTF, for the case in which the design points form a lattice in $d$ dimensions. KTF is a natural extension of univariate trend filtering (Steidl et al., 2006; Kim et al., 2009; Tibshirani, 2014), and is defined by minimizing a penalized least squares problem whose penalty term sums the absolute (higher-order) differences of the parameter to be estimated along each of the coordinate directions. The corresponding penalty operator can be written in terms of Kronecker products of univariate trend filtering penalty operators, hence the name Kronecker trend filtering. Equivalently, one can view KTF in terms of an $ell_1$-penalized basis regression problem where the basis functions are tensor products of falling factorial functions, a piecewise polynomial (discrete spline) basis that underlies univariate trend filtering. This paper is a unification and extension of the results in Sadhanala et al. (2016, 2017). We develop a complete set of theoretical results that describe the behavior of $k^{mathrm{th}}$ order Kronecker trend filtering in $d$ dimensions, for every $k geq 0$ and $d geq 1$. This reveals a number of interesting phenomena, including the dominance of KTF over linear smoothers in estimating heterogeneously smooth functions, and a phase transition at $d=2(k+1)$, a boundary past which (on the high dimension-to-smoothness side) linear smoothers fail to be consistent entirely. We also leverage recent results on discrete splines from Tibshirani (2020), in particular, discrete spline interpolation results that enable us to extend the KTF estimate to any off-lattice location in constant-time (independent of the size of the lattice $n$).
Read more4/9/2024
🏷️
0
Inhomogeneous graph trend filtering via a l2,0 cardinality penalty
Xiaoqing Huang, Andersen Ang, Kun Huang, Jie Zhang, Yijie Wang
We study estimation of piecewise smooth signals over a graph. We propose a $ell_{2,0}$-norm penalized Graph Trend Filtering (GTF) model to estimate piecewise smooth graph signals that exhibit inhomogeneous levels of smoothness across the nodes. We prove that the proposed GTF model is simultaneously a k-means clustering on the signal over the nodes and a minimum graph cut on the edges of the graph, where the clustering and the cut share the same assignment matrix. We propose two methods to solve the proposed GTF model: a spectral decomposition method and a method based on simulated annealing. In the experiment on synthetic and real-world datasets, we show that the proposed GTF model has a better performances compared with existing approaches on the tasks of denoising, support recovery and semi-supervised classification. We also show that the proposed GTF model can be solved more efficiently than existing models for the dataset with a large edge set.
Read more6/5/2024
↗️
0
Regression for matrix-valued data via Kronecker products factorization
Yin-Jen Chen, Minh Tang
We study the matrix-variate regression problem $Y_i = sum_{k} beta_{1k} X_i beta_{2k}^{top} + E_i$ for $i=1,2dots,n$ in the high dimensional regime wherein the response $Y_i$ are matrices whose dimensions $p_{1}times p_{2}$ outgrow both the sample size $n$ and the dimensions $q_{1}times q_{2}$ of the predictor variables $X_i$ i.e., $q_{1},q_{2} ll n ll p_{1},p_{2}$. We propose an estimation algorithm, termed KRO-PRO-FAC, for estimating the parameters ${beta_{1k}} subset Re^{p_1 times q_1}$ and ${beta_{2k}} subset Re^{p_2 times q_2}$ that utilizes the Kronecker product factorization and rearrangement operations from Van Loan and Pitsianis (1993). The KRO-PRO-FAC algorithm is computationally efficient as it does not require estimating the covariance between the entries of the ${Y_i}$. We establish perturbation bounds between $hat{beta}_{1k} -beta_{1k}$ and $hat{beta}_{2k} - beta_{2k}$ in spectral norm for the setting where either the rows of $E_i$ or the columns of $E_i$ are independent sub-Gaussian random vectors. Numerical studies on simulated and real data indicate that our procedure is competitive, in terms of both estimation error and predictive accuracy, compared to other existing methods.
Read more5/1/2024
↗️
0
Scalable Spatiotemporally Varying Coefficient Modelling with Bayesian Kernelized Tensor Regression
Mengying Lei, Aurelie Labbe, Lijun Sun
As a regression technique in spatial statistics, the spatiotemporally varying coefficient model (STVC) is an important tool for discovering nonstationary and interpretable response-covariate associations over both space and time. However, it is difficult to apply STVC for large-scale spatiotemporal analyses due to its high computational cost. To address this challenge, we summarize the spatiotemporally varying coefficients using a third-order tensor structure and propose to reformulate the spatiotemporally varying coefficient model as a special low-rank tensor regression problem. The low-rank decomposition can effectively model the global patterns of large data sets with a substantially reduced number of parameters. To further incorporate the local spatiotemporal dependencies, we use Gaussian process (GP) priors on the spatial and temporal factor matrices. We refer to the overall framework as Bayesian Kernelized Tensor Regression (BKTR), and kernelized tensor factorization can be considered a new and scalable approach to modeling multivariate spatiotemporal processes with a low-rank covariance structure. For model inference, we develop an efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm, which uses Gibbs sampling to update factor matrices and slice sampling to update kernel hyperparameters. We conduct extensive experiments on both synthetic and real-world data sets, and our results confirm the superior performance and efficiency of BKTR for model estimation and parameter inference.
Read more4/16/2024