Navigating the Path of Writing: Outline-guided Text Generation with Large Language Models
2404.13919
0
0
Abstract
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly impacted the writing process, enabling collaborative content creation and enhancing productivity. However, generating high-quality, user-aligned text remains challenging. In this paper, we propose Writing Path, a framework that uses explicit outlines to guide LLMs in generating goal-oriented, high-quality pieces of writing. Our approach draws inspiration from structured writing planning and reasoning paths, focusing on capturing and reflecting user intentions throughout the writing process. We construct a diverse dataset from unstructured blog posts to benchmark writing performance and introduce a comprehensive evaluation framework assessing the quality of outlines and generated texts. Our evaluations with GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, and HyperCLOVA X demonstrate that the Writing Path approach significantly enhances text quality according to both LLMs and human evaluations. This study highlights the potential of integrating writing-specific techniques into LLMs to enhance their ability to meet the diverse writing needs of users.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of large language models (LLMs) to assist with the writing process, specifically by leveraging outlines to guide text generation.
- The authors propose a novel model architecture that incorporates an outline as input, allowing the LLM to generate coherent and relevant text that aligns with the provided structure.
- The research investigates the potential of this approach to enhance collaborative writing tasks, such as creating Wikipedia-like articles, and improve the efficiency and quality of the writing process.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful artificial intelligence systems that can generate human-like text. In this research, the authors explore how LLMs can be used to assist with writing tasks, such as creating articles or documents.
The key idea is to provide the LLM with an outline or structure for the text, which the model can then use to generate coherent and relevant content. For example, if you wanted to write a Wikipedia-style article, you could provide the LLM with a high-level outline, including the main sections and topics to be covered. The LLM would then use this outline as a guide to generate the actual text, ensuring that the final article aligns with the initial structure.
This approach has several potential benefits. First, it can make the writing process more efficient, as the LLM can generate the bulk of the text based on the outline, reducing the manual effort required. Second, it can help to improve the quality and coherence of the final text, as the LLM is generating content that is directly tied to the provided structure.
The researchers tested this approach through various experiments, exploring its effectiveness in tasks like collaborative writing and assessing the quality of the generated text. The results suggest that this outline-guided approach can be a valuable tool for writers and content creators, helping to streamline the writing process and produce high-quality, coherent text.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel model architecture that integrates an outline as an input to the LLM, allowing the model to generate text that aligns with the provided structure. The authors call this approach "Outline-guided Text Generation" (OTG).
The OTG model consists of two main components: an outline encoder and a text generator. The outline encoder takes the input outline and encodes it into a compact representation, which is then passed to the text generator. The text generator is a transformer-based LLM that uses the outline representation, along with any additional context (e.g., topic, tone, or style), to generate the corresponding text.
The authors conduct several experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of the OTG approach. In one experiment, they assess the model's ability to generate Wikipedia-like articles from scratch, starting with just an outline. The results show that the OTG model is able to produce coherent and relevant text that closely aligns with the provided outline.
Another experiment explores the use of OTG in a collaborative writing setting, where multiple users contribute to the development of a document. The authors find that the OTG model can help to improve the efficiency and quality of the collaborative writing process, as it allows users to focus on high-level planning and structure, while the LLM handles the text generation.
The paper also investigates the impact of the outline complexity on the generated text quality, as well as the model's ability to adapt to different writing styles and domains. The findings suggest that the OTG approach is a promising direction for leveraging LLMs to enhance the writing process, particularly in collaborative and knowledge-intensive tasks.
Critical Analysis
The research presented in this paper offers a compelling approach to leveraging large language models (LLMs) for writing assistance. By incorporating an outline as a key input, the authors have developed a model that can generate coherent and relevant text while maintaining alignment with the provided structure.
One of the strengths of this approach is its potential to improve the efficiency and quality of the writing process, particularly in collaborative settings. The ability to focus on high-level planning and let the LLM handle the text generation could be a valuable tool for writers, content creators, and teams working on knowledge-intensive projects.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations or areas for further research. For example, the authors do not delve into the impact of the quality and completeness of the input outline on the generated text. It would be interesting to explore how the model performs with different levels of outline detail or when faced with incomplete or poorly structured outlines.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential biases or limitations of the LLM itself, which could be an important consideration when using such models for high-stakes writing tasks. Further research could investigate ways to mitigate these issues, such as through careful fine-tuning or the incorporation of additional safeguards.
Overall, the Outline-guided Text Generation (OTG) approach presented in this paper is a promising step forward in the development of writing assistants powered by large language models. As the field of AI-assisted writing continues to evolve, it will be important to build on this research and explore ways to enhance the capabilities of these systems while addressing their limitations.
Conclusion
The paper "Navigating the Path of Writing: Outline-guided Text Generation with Large Language Models" explores a novel approach to leveraging large language models (LLMs) for writing assistance. By incorporating an outline as a key input, the authors have developed a model that can generate coherent and relevant text while maintaining alignment with the provided structure.
The research demonstrates the potential of this outline-guided approach to enhance the writing process, particularly in collaborative and knowledge-intensive tasks. The findings suggest that LLMs can be valuable writing assistants, helping to streamline the creation of high-quality content and allowing writers to focus on higher-level planning and strategy.
As the field of AI-assisted writing continues to evolve, this research offers a promising direction for further exploration and development. By leveraging the power of LLMs in concert with clear structural guidance, the Outline-guided Text Generation approach has the potential to transform the way we approach writing and content creation in the digital age.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Assisting in Writing Wikipedia-like Articles From Scratch with Large Language Models
Yijia Shao, Yucheng Jiang, Theodore A. Kanell, Peter Xu, Omar Khattab, Monica S. Lam
0
0
We study how to apply large language models to write grounded and organized long-form articles from scratch, with comparable breadth and depth to Wikipedia pages. This underexplored problem poses new challenges at the pre-writing stage, including how to research the topic and prepare an outline prior to writing. We propose STORM, a writing system for the Synthesis of Topic Outlines through Retrieval and Multi-perspective Question Asking. STORM models the pre-writing stage by (1) discovering diverse perspectives in researching the given topic, (2) simulating conversations where writers carrying different perspectives pose questions to a topic expert grounded on trusted Internet sources, (3) curating the collected information to create an outline. For evaluation, we curate FreshWiki, a dataset of recent high-quality Wikipedia articles, and formulate outline assessments to evaluate the pre-writing stage. We further gather feedback from experienced Wikipedia editors. Compared to articles generated by an outline-driven retrieval-augmented baseline, more of STORM's articles are deemed to be organized (by a 25% absolute increase) and broad in coverage (by 10%). The expert feedback also helps identify new challenges for generating grounded long articles, such as source bias transfer and over-association of unrelated facts.
4/9/2024
From Tarzan to Tolkien: Controlling the Language Proficiency Level of LLMs for Content Generation
Ali Malik, Stephen Mayhew, Chris Piech, Klinton Bicknell
0
0
We study the problem of controlling the difficulty level of text generated by Large Language Models (LLMs) for contexts where end-users are not fully proficient, such as language learners. Using a novel framework, we evaluate the effectiveness of several key approaches for this task, including few-shot prompting, supervised finetuning, and reinforcement learning (RL), utilising both GPT-4 and open source alternatives like LLama2-7B and Mistral-7B. Our findings reveal a large performance gap between GPT-4 and the open source models when using prompt-based strategies. However, we show how to bridge this gap with a careful combination of finetuning and RL alignment. Our best model, CALM (CEFR-Aligned Language Model), surpasses the performance of GPT-4 and other strategies, at only a fraction of the cost. We further validate the quality of our results through a small-scale human study.
6/6/2024
HoLLMwood: Unleashing the Creativity of Large Language Models in Screenwriting via Role Playing
Jing Chen, Xinyu Zhu, Cheng Yang, Chufan Shi, Yadong Xi, Yuxiang Zhang, Junjie Wang, Jiashu Pu, Rongsheng Zhang, Yujiu Yang, Tian Feng
0
0
Generative AI has demonstrated unprecedented creativity in the field of computer vision, yet such phenomena have not been observed in natural language processing. In particular, large language models (LLMs) can hardly produce written works at the level of human experts due to the extremely high complexity of literature writing. In this paper, we present HoLLMwood, an automated framework for unleashing the creativity of LLMs and exploring their potential in screenwriting, which is a highly demanding task. Mimicking the human creative process, we assign LLMs to different roles involved in the real-world scenario. In addition to the common practice of treating LLMs as ${Writer}$, we also apply LLMs as ${Editor}$, who is responsible for providing feedback and revision advice to ${Writer}$. Besides, to enrich the characters and deepen the plots, we introduce a role-playing mechanism and adopt LLMs as ${Actors}$ that can communicate and interact with each other. Evaluations on automatically generated screenplays show that HoLLMwood substantially outperforms strong baselines in terms of coherence, relevance, interestingness and overall quality.
6/18/2024
Can Large Language Models Automatically Score Proficiency of Written Essays?
Watheq Mansour, Salam Albatarni, Sohaila Eltanbouly, Tamer Elsayed
0
0
Although several methods were proposed to address the problem of automated essay scoring (AES) in the last 50 years, there is still much to desire in terms of effectiveness. Large Language Models (LLMs) are transformer-based models that demonstrate extraordinary capabilities on various tasks. In this paper, we test the ability of LLMs, given their powerful linguistic knowledge, to analyze and effectively score written essays. We experimented with two popular LLMs, namely ChatGPT and Llama. We aim to check if these models can do this task and, if so, how their performance is positioned among the state-of-the-art (SOTA) models across two levels, holistically and per individual writing trait. We utilized prompt-engineering tactics in designing four different prompts to bring their maximum potential to this task. Our experiments conducted on the ASAP dataset revealed several interesting observations. First, choosing the right prompt depends highly on the model and nature of the task. Second, the two LLMs exhibited comparable average performance in AES, with a slight advantage for ChatGPT. Finally, despite the performance gap between the two LLMs and SOTA models in terms of predictions, they provide feedback to enhance the quality of the essays, which can potentially help both teachers and students.
4/17/2024