NeRF View Synthesis: Subjective Quality Assessment and Objective Metrics Evaluation
2405.20078
0
0
āØ
Abstract
Neural radiance fields (NeRF) are a groundbreaking computer vision technology that enables the generation of high-quality, immersive visual content from multiple viewpoints. This capability holds significant advantages for applications such as virtual/augmented reality, 3D modelling and content creation for the film and entertainment industry. However, the evaluation of NeRF methods poses several challenges, including a lack of comprehensive datasets, reliable assessment methodologies, and objective quality metrics. This paper addresses the problem of NeRF quality assessment thoroughly, by conducting a rigorous subjective quality assessment test that considers several scene classes and recently proposed NeRF view synthesis methods. Additionally, the performance of a wide range of state-of-the-art conventional and learning-based full-reference 2D image and video quality assessment metrics is evaluated against the subjective scores of the subjective study. The experimental results are analyzed in depth, providing a comparative evaluation of several NeRF methods and objective quality metrics, across different classes of visual scenes, including real and synthetic content for front-face and 360-degree camera trajectories.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper addresses the challenge of evaluating the quality of neural radiance fields (NeRF), a groundbreaking computer vision technology for generating high-quality, immersive visual content from multiple viewpoints.
- NeRF holds significant advantages for applications like virtual/augmented reality, 3D modeling, and content creation for film and entertainment, but evaluating NeRF methods poses several challenges.
- The paper conducts a rigorous subjective quality assessment test and evaluates the performance of various state-of-the-art 2D image and video quality assessment metrics against the subjective scores.
Plain English Explanation
Neural radiance fields (NeRF) are a new computer vision technology that can generate high-quality, 3D visual content from multiple camera angles. This is really useful for applications like virtual reality, 3D modeling, and creating visual effects for movies and games. However, it's challenging to evaluate how well these NeRF methods work, because there aren't many good datasets or ways to measure the quality of the results.
This paper aims to address this problem by conducting a detailed study where people subjectively rate the quality of different NeRF methods across various types of visual scenes, including real and synthetic content. The researchers also test how well a range of existing 2D image and video quality assessment tools can predict these subjective quality scores for NeRF.
The goal is to provide a better understanding of the strengths and limitations of NeRF methods and the tools used to evaluate them, which can help improve methods and strategies for improving novel view synthesis quality and casting and improving view-dependent appearance consistency in NeRF.
Technical Explanation
The paper conducts a comprehensive subjective quality assessment study to evaluate several recently proposed NeRF view synthesis methods. The study considers different scene classes, including real and synthetic content, as well as front-facing and 360-degree camera trajectories.
The subjective study involves human participants rating the visual quality of NeRF-generated images on a scale. The researchers then assess how well a wide range of state-of-the-art 2D image and video quality assessment metrics can predict these subjective quality scores.
The experimental results provide a comparative evaluation of several NeRF methods and objective quality metrics across the different scene classes. This helps identify the strengths, weaknesses, and appropriate use cases for both the NeRF techniques and the quality assessment tools.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive and rigorous approach to evaluating NeRF quality, which is crucial for improving novel view synthesis quality and ensuring consistent view-dependent appearance in NeRF-based systems.
However, the paper does not delve into the potential limitations of the subjective evaluation methodology or the generalizability of the findings across a wider range of NeRF applications in robotics. Additionally, the paper does not explore the impact of factors like scene complexity, object occlusion, or lighting conditions on the performance of NeRF methods and quality assessment metrics.
Further research could investigate the robustness of NeRF quality evaluation under more diverse and challenging conditions, as well as explore the development of more specialized quality assessment metrics tailored to the unique characteristics of NeRF-generated content.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive study on the quality assessment of neural radiance fields (NeRF), a powerful computer vision technology for generating high-quality, immersive visual content from multiple viewpoints. The rigorous subjective quality evaluation and the assessment of various state-of-the-art quality metrics provide valuable insights into the strengths, weaknesses, and appropriate use cases of NeRF methods.
The findings of this research can inform the development of improved methods and strategies for novel view synthesis quality and techniques for ensuring consistent view-dependent appearance in NeRF. Additionally, the insights gained can guide the application of NeRF in robotics and other domains where high-quality, immersive visual content is crucial.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
š§
Novel View Synthesis with Neural Radiance Fields for Industrial Robot Applications
Markus Hillemann, Robert Langendorfer, Max Heiken, Max Mehltretter, Andreas Schenk, Martin Weinmann, Stefan Hinz, Christian Heipke, Markus Ulrich
0
0
Neural Radiance Fields (NeRFs) have become a rapidly growing research field with the potential to revolutionize typical photogrammetric workflows, such as those used for 3D scene reconstruction. As input, NeRFs require multi-view images with corresponding camera poses as well as the interior orientation. In the typical NeRF workflow, the camera poses and the interior orientation are estimated in advance with Structure from Motion (SfM). But the quality of the resulting novel views, which depends on different parameters such as the number and distribution of available images, as well as the accuracy of the related camera poses and interior orientation, is difficult to predict. In addition, SfM is a time-consuming pre-processing step, and its quality strongly depends on the image content. Furthermore, the undefined scaling factor of SfM hinders subsequent steps in which metric information is required. In this paper, we evaluate the potential of NeRFs for industrial robot applications. We propose an alternative to SfM pre-processing: we capture the input images with a calibrated camera that is attached to the end effector of an industrial robot and determine accurate camera poses with metric scale based on the robot kinematics. We then investigate the quality of the novel views by comparing them to ground truth, and by computing an internal quality measure based on ensemble methods. For evaluation purposes, we acquire multiple datasets that pose challenges for reconstruction typical of industrial applications, like reflective objects, poor texture, and fine structures. We show that the robot-based pose determination reaches similar accuracy as SfM in non-demanding cases, while having clear advantages in more challenging scenarios. Finally, we present first results of applying the ensemble method to estimate the quality of the synthetic novel view in the absence of a ground truth.
5/8/2024
Methods and strategies for improving the novel view synthesis quality of neural radiation field
Shun Fang, Ming Cui, Xing Feng, Yanna Lv
0
0
Neural Radiation Field (NeRF) technology can learn a 3D implicit model of a scene from 2D images and synthesize realistic novel view images. This technology has received widespread attention from the industry and has good application prospects. In response to the problem that the rendering quality of NeRF images needs to be improved, many researchers have proposed various methods to improve the rendering quality in the past three years. The latest relevant papers are classified and reviewed, the technical principles behind quality improvement are analyzed, and the future evolution direction of quality improvement methods is discussed. This study can help researchers quickly understand the current state and evolutionary context of technology in this field, which is helpful in inspiring the development of more efficient algorithms and promoting the application of NeRF technology in related fields.
4/19/2024
Towards Real-Time Neural Volumetric Rendering on Mobile Devices: A Measurement Study
Zhe Wang, Yifei Zhu
0
0
Neural Radiance Fields (NeRF) is an emerging technique to synthesize 3D objects from 2D images with a wide range of potential applications. However, rendering existing NeRF models is extremely computation intensive, making it challenging to support real-time interaction on mobile devices. In this paper, we take the first initiative to examine the state-of-the-art real-time NeRF rendering technique from a system perspective. We first define the entire working pipeline of the NeRF serving system. We then identify possible control knobs that are critical to the system from the communication, computation, and visual performance perspective. Furthermore, an extensive measurement study is conducted to reveal the effects of these control knobs on system performance. Our measurement results reveal that different control knobs contribute differently towards improving the system performance, with the mesh granularity being the most effective knob and the quantization being the least effective knob. In addition, diverse hardware device settings and network conditions have to be considered to fully unleash the benefit of operating under the appropriate knobs
6/26/2024
š
NeRF-Casting: Improved View-Dependent Appearance with Consistent Reflections
Dor Verbin, Pratul P. Srinivasan, Peter Hedman, Ben Mildenhall, Benjamin Attal, Richard Szeliski, Jonathan T. Barron
0
0
Neural Radiance Fields (NeRFs) typically struggle to reconstruct and render highly specular objects, whose appearance varies quickly with changes in viewpoint. Recent works have improved NeRF's ability to render detailed specular appearance of distant environment illumination, but are unable to synthesize consistent reflections of closer content. Moreover, these techniques rely on large computationally-expensive neural networks to model outgoing radiance, which severely limits optimization and rendering speed. We address these issues with an approach based on ray tracing: instead of querying an expensive neural network for the outgoing view-dependent radiance at points along each camera ray, our model casts reflection rays from these points and traces them through the NeRF representation to render feature vectors which are decoded into color using a small inexpensive network. We demonstrate that our model outperforms prior methods for view synthesis of scenes containing shiny objects, and that it is the only existing NeRF method that can synthesize photorealistic specular appearance and reflections in real-world scenes, while requiring comparable optimization time to current state-of-the-art view synthesis models.
5/24/2024