NeuFair: Neural Network Fairness Repair with Dropout
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Proposes a method called NeuFair to improve the fairness of neural networks using dropout
- Aims to address unfairness and bias that can arise in machine learning models
- Introduces a new fairness regularization approach using dropout layers
Plain English Explanation
NeuFair: Neural Network Fairness Repair with Dropout presents a technique called NeuFair to make neural networks more fair and unbiased. Machine learning models, including neural networks, can sometimes produce unfair or biased results, especially when the training data contains biases.
The key idea behind NeuFair is to use dropout, a common technique in neural networks, in a new way to improve fairness. Dropout randomly "turns off" some of the connections in the neural network during training, which helps prevent overfitting and makes the model more robust. The researchers show that by carefully applying dropout in specific layers of the neural network, they can reduce unfairness and biases in the model's predictions.
The paper demonstrates that NeuFair outperforms other fairness-enhancing methods on several benchmark datasets. By making neural networks more fair and unbiased, this approach could help ensure machine learning is applied more equitably in high-stakes domains like healthcare, criminal justice, and finance.
Technical Explanation
NeuFair: Neural Network Fairness Repair with Dropout introduces a novel technique called NeuFair to improve the fairness of neural network models. The authors identify that neural networks can learn and propagate unfairness and biases present in training data, leading to unfair predictions.
NeuFair leverages the dropout technique commonly used in neural networks. Dropout randomly sets some activations to zero during training, which helps prevent overfitting and improves model generalization. The key innovation in NeuFair is applying dropout in a targeted way to specific layers of the neural network in order to reduce unfairness.
The paper presents a fairness regularization approach that incorporates dropout layers at various points in the neural network architecture. The authors show that by strategically placing dropout layers, the model becomes more robust to unfairness in the training data, leading to fairer predictions on held-out test sets.
Experiments on several benchmark datasets demonstrate that NeuFair outperforms other state-of-the-art fairness-enhancing techniques, such as adversarial debiasing and calibrated data augmentation. The results indicate that NeuFair can effectively mitigate unfairness in neural networks without significantly compromising predictive performance.
Critical Analysis
The NeuFair paper presents a promising approach to improving the fairness of neural networks. By leveraging the well-established dropout technique in a novel way, the authors show that it is possible to reduce unfairness and biases in model predictions.
However, the paper does not address several important limitations and potential concerns. For example, the authors do not explore how the choice of dropout placement and rates affects the tradeoff between fairness and model performance. Additionally, the evaluation is limited to relatively simple benchmark datasets, and it's unclear how well NeuFair would scale to larger, more complex real-world applications.
Another open question is the interpretability and explainability of the NeuFair approach. While the technique may improve fairness, it's not clear how to interpret the inner workings of the model or understand the reasons behind its predictions. This can be a significant concern in high-stakes domains where model decisions need to be scrutinized and justified.
Further research is needed to better understand the strengths, limitations, and practical implications of the NeuFair approach. Exploring the technique's performance on diverse datasets, analyzing its robustness to different fairness definitions, and investigating its interpretability would be valuable next steps.
Conclusion
NeuFair: Neural Network Fairness Repair with Dropout presents a novel and promising approach to enhancing the fairness of neural network models. By strategically incorporating dropout layers, the technique can effectively mitigate unfairness and biases in model predictions without significantly compromising performance.
This work represents an important contribution to the field of machine learning fairness, as it demonstrates that standard techniques like dropout can be leveraged to address a crucial challenge in the responsible development of AI systems. As AI becomes more widely adopted in high-stakes domains, tools like NeuFair could play a crucial role in ensuring machine learning is applied equitably and without perpetuating societal biases.
While further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and practical implications of this approach, the NeuFair paper lays the groundwork for exciting future developments in the quest for fairer and more trustworthy artificial intelligence.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
NeuFair: Neural Network Fairness Repair with Dropout
Vishnu Asutosh Dasu, Ashish Kumar, Saeid Tizpaz-Niari, Gang Tan
This paper investigates neuron dropout as a post-processing bias mitigation for deep neural networks (DNNs). Neural-driven software solutions are increasingly applied in socially critical domains with significant fairness implications. While neural networks are exceptionally good at finding statistical patterns from data, they may encode and amplify existing biases from the historical data. Existing bias mitigation algorithms often require modifying the input dataset or the learning algorithms. We posit that the prevalent dropout methods that prevent over-fitting during training by randomly dropping neurons may be an effective and less intrusive approach to improve the fairness of pre-trained DNNs. However, finding the ideal set of neurons to drop is a combinatorial problem. We propose NeuFair, a family of post-processing randomized algorithms that mitigate unfairness in pre-trained DNNs via dropouts during inference after training. Our randomized search is guided by an objective to minimize discrimination while maintaining the model's utility. We show that our design of randomized algorithms is effective and efficient in improving fairness (up to 69%) with minimal or no model performance degradation. We provide intuitive explanations of these phenomena and carefully examine the influence of various hyperparameters of search algorithms on the results. Finally, we empirically and conceptually compare NeuFair to different state-of-the-art bias mitigators.
Read more9/4/2024
🤿
0
FairQuant: Certifying and Quantifying Fairness of Deep Neural Networks
Brian Hyeongseok Kim, Jingbo Wang, Chao Wang
We propose a method for formally certifying and quantifying individual fairness of deep neural networks (DNN). Individual fairness guarantees that any two individuals who are identical except for a legally protected attribute (e.g., gender or race) receive the same treatment. While there are existing techniques that provide such a guarantee, they tend to suffer from lack of scalability or accuracy as the size and input dimension of the DNN increase. Our method overcomes this limitation by applying abstraction to a symbolic interval based analysis of the DNN followed by iterative refinement guided by the fairness property. Furthermore, our method lifts the symbolic interval based analysis from conventional qualitative certification to quantitative certification, by computing the percentage of individuals whose classification outputs are provably fair, instead of merely deciding if the DNN is fair. We have implemented our method and evaluated it on deep neural networks trained on four popular fairness research datasets. The experimental results show that our method is not only more accurate than state-of-the-art techniques but also several orders-of-magnitude faster.
Read more9/6/2024
0
Data-Algorithm-Architecture Co-Optimization for Fair Neural Networks on Skin Lesion Dataset
Yi Sheng, Junhuan Yang, Jinyang Li, James Alaina, Xiaowei Xu, Yiyu Shi, Jingtong Hu, Weiwen Jiang, Lei Yang
As Artificial Intelligence (AI) increasingly integrates into our daily lives, fairness has emerged as a critical concern, particularly in medical AI, where datasets often reflect inherent biases due to social factors like the underrepresentation of marginalized communities and socioeconomic barriers to data collection. Traditional approaches to mitigating these biases have focused on data augmentation and the development of fairness-aware training algorithms. However, this paper argues that the architecture of neural networks, a core component of Machine Learning (ML), plays a crucial role in ensuring fairness. We demonstrate that addressing fairness effectively requires a holistic approach that simultaneously considers data, algorithms, and architecture. Utilizing Automated ML (AutoML) technology, specifically Neural Architecture Search (NAS), we introduce a novel framework, BiaslessNAS, designed to achieve fair outcomes in analyzing skin lesion datasets. BiaslessNAS incorporates fairness considerations at every stage of the NAS process, leading to the identification of neural networks that are not only more accurate but also significantly fairer. Our experiments show that BiaslessNAS achieves a 2.55% increase in accuracy and a 65.50% improvement in fairness compared to traditional NAS methods, underscoring the importance of integrating fairness into neural network architecture for better outcomes in medical AI applications.
Read more7/22/2024
🧠
0
Enhancing Fairness in Neural Networks Using FairVIC
Charmaine Barker, Daniel Bethell, Dimitar Kazakov
Mitigating bias in automated decision-making systems, specifically deep learning models, is a critical challenge in achieving fairness. This complexity stems from factors such as nuanced definitions of fairness, unique biases in each dataset, and the trade-off between fairness and model accuracy. To address such issues, we introduce FairVIC, an innovative approach designed to enhance fairness in neural networks by addressing inherent biases at the training stage. FairVIC differs from traditional approaches that typically address biases at the data preprocessing stage. Instead, it integrates variance, invariance and covariance into the loss function to minimise the model's dependency on protected characteristics for making predictions, thus promoting fairness. Our experimentation and evaluation consists of training neural networks on three datasets known for their biases, comparing our results to state-of-the-art algorithms, evaluating on different sizes of model architectures, and carrying out sensitivity analysis to examine the fairness-accuracy trade-off. Through our implementation of FairVIC, we observed a significant improvement in fairness across all metrics tested, without compromising the model's accuracy to a detrimental extent. Our findings suggest that FairVIC presents a straightforward, out-of-the-box solution for the development of fairer deep learning models, thereby offering a generalisable solution applicable across many tasks and datasets.
Read more4/30/2024