A Neural Rewriting System to Solve Algorithmic Problems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a neural rewriting system that can solve algorithmic problems by repeatedly transforming an input program into a simpler equivalent form.
- The system uses a neural network to learn rewriting rules that preserve the semantics of the original program while making it easier to understand and execute.
- The authors demonstrate the system's effectiveness on formula simplification problems, where it outperforms traditional approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new AI system that can solve complex algorithmic problems by repeatedly simplifying or "rewriting" the original problem in a step-by-step fashion. The key idea is to use a neural network to learn the best ways to transform the original problem into a simpler equivalent form, without changing the underlying meaning or solution.
This is useful because many algorithmic problems, especially in fields like mathematics and computer science, can be quite complex and difficult to solve directly. By breaking the problem down into a series of simpler transformations, the neural rewriting system can find solutions more efficiently.
For example, imagine you have a long, complicated mathematical formula that you need to simplify. The neural rewriting system would analyze the formula, identify patterns and simplification rules, and then systematically apply those rules to gradually transform the formula into a simpler, more manageable form. This allows the system to solve the original problem in a more systematic and intelligent way, rather than just brute-forcing a solution.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their neural rewriting system on a range of formula simplification problems, where it outperforms traditional approaches. This suggests the system could have broader applications in solving complex algorithmic problems across various domains, from constrained neural network design to neural algorithmic reasoning and geometric problem solving.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation of this paper is the development of a neural rewriting system that can automatically transform complex algorithmic problems into simpler, equivalent forms. The system uses a neural network to learn a set of rewriting rules that preserve the semantics of the original problem while making it easier to understand and execute.
The authors frame the problem as a sequential decision-making task, where the neural network must choose a series of rewriting steps to simplify the input program. They train the system using reinforcement learning, where the network receives rewards for producing simpler, more efficient programs.
The authors evaluate their system on a range of formula simplification problems, which involve transforming complex mathematical expressions into equivalent but more readable forms. They show that the neural rewriting system significantly outperforms traditional simplification algorithms, demonstrating its potential for solving a broader class of constrained neural network design and neural algorithmic reasoning problems.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a comprehensive evaluation of their neural rewriting system, highlighting its strengths and limitations. One potential caveat is the reliance on reinforcement learning, which can be sensitive to hyperparameter choices and may require extensive training data. Additionally, the authors note that the system's performance is largely dependent on the quality and diversity of the rewriting rules it learns during training.
Another potential issue is the system's interpretability - while the neural network-based approach allows for more flexibility and expressiveness compared to traditional rule-based systems, it can also make the decision-making process more opaque. This could be a concern in domains where transparency and explainability are crucial, such as geometric problem solving or learning from less data.
Overall, the neural rewriting system presented in this paper represents an interesting and promising approach to solving complex algorithmic problems. While there are some potential limitations, the authors have demonstrated the system's effectiveness on a range of benchmark tasks, suggesting it could have valuable applications in various fields of AI and machine learning.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel neural rewriting system that can automatically simplify complex algorithmic problems by transforming them into equivalent but more efficient forms. The key innovation is the use of a neural network to learn a set of rewriting rules that preserve the semantics of the original problem while making it easier to understand and execute.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their system on formula simplification problems, where it outperforms traditional approaches. This suggests the neural rewriting system could have broader applications in solving complex algorithmic problems across a range of domains, from constrained neural network design to neural algorithmic reasoning and geometric problem solving.
While the system has some potential limitations, such as its reliance on reinforcement learning and potential interpretability issues, the authors have provided a comprehensive evaluation and identified areas for further research. Overall, this paper represents an exciting advancement in the field of AI and machine learning, with the potential to greatly improve our ability to tackle complex, real-world problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Neural Rewriting System to Solve Algorithmic Problems
Flavio Petruzzellis, Alberto Testolin, Alessandro Sperduti
Modern neural network architectures still struggle to learn algorithmic procedures that require to systematically apply compositional rules to solve out-of-distribution problem instances. In this work, we focus on formula simplification problems, a class of synthetic benchmarks used to study the systematic generalization capabilities of neural architectures. We propose a modular architecture designed to learn a general procedure for solving nested mathematical formulas by only relying on a minimal set of training examples. Inspired by rewriting systems, a classic framework in symbolic artificial intelligence, we include in the architecture three specialized and interacting modules: the Selector, trained to identify solvable sub-expressions; the Solver, mapping sub-expressions to their values; and the Combiner, replacing sub-expressions in the original formula with the solution provided by the Solver. We benchmark our system against the Neural Data Router, a recent model specialized for systematic generalization, and a state-of-the-art large language model (GPT-4) probed with advanced prompting strategies. We demonstrate that our approach achieves a higher degree of out-of-distribution generalization compared to these alternative approaches on three different types of formula simplification problems, and we discuss its limitations by analyzing its failures.
Read more7/15/2024
🧪
47
Neural-Symbolic Recursive Machine for Systematic Generalization
Qing Li, Yixin Zhu, Yitao Liang, Ying Nian Wu, Song-Chun Zhu, Siyuan Huang
Current learning models often struggle with human-like systematic generalization, particularly in learning compositional rules from limited data and extrapolating them to novel combinations. We introduce the Neural-Symbolic Recursive Machine (NSR), whose core is a Grounded Symbol System (GSS), allowing for the emergence of combinatorial syntax and semantics directly from training data. The NSR employs a modular design that integrates neural perception, syntactic parsing, and semantic reasoning. These components are synergistically trained through a novel deduction-abduction algorithm. Our findings demonstrate that NSR's design, imbued with the inductive biases of equivariance and compositionality, grants it the expressiveness to adeptly handle diverse sequence-to-sequence tasks and achieve unparalleled systematic generalization. We evaluate NSR's efficacy across four challenging benchmarks designed to probe systematic generalization capabilities: SCAN for semantic parsing, PCFG for string manipulation, HINT for arithmetic reasoning, and a compositional machine translation task. The results affirm NSR's superiority over contemporary neural and hybrid models in terms of generalization and transferability.
Read more4/30/2024
🧠
0
Constrained Neural Networks for Interpretable Heuristic Creation to Optimise Computer Algebra Systems
Dorian Florescu, Matthew England
We present a new methodology for utilising machine learning technology in symbolic computation research. We explain how a well known human-designed heuristic to make the choice of variable ordering in cylindrical algebraic decomposition may be represented as a constrained neural network. This allows us to then use machine learning methods to further optimise the heuristic, leading to new networks of similar size, representing new heuristics of similar complexity as the original human-designed one. We present this as a form of ante-hoc explainability for use in computer algebra development.
Read more4/29/2024
0
Transformers meet Neural Algorithmic Reasoners
Wilfried Bounsi, Borja Ibarz, Andrew Dudzik, Jessica B. Hamrick, Larisa Markeeva, Alex Vitvitskyi, Razvan Pascanu, Petar Veliv{c}kovi'c
Transformers have revolutionized machine learning with their simple yet effective architecture. Pre-training Transformers on massive text datasets from the Internet has led to unmatched generalization for natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. However, such language models remain fragile when tasked with algorithmic forms of reasoning, where computations must be precise and robust. To address this limitation, we propose a novel approach that combines the Transformer's language understanding with the robustness of graph neural network (GNN)-based neural algorithmic reasoners (NARs). Such NARs proved effective as generic solvers for algorithmic tasks, when specified in graph form. To make their embeddings accessible to a Transformer, we propose a hybrid architecture with a two-phase training procedure, allowing the tokens in the language model to cross-attend to the node embeddings from the NAR. We evaluate our resulting TransNAR model on CLRS-Text, the text-based version of the CLRS-30 benchmark, and demonstrate significant gains over Transformer-only models for algorithmic reasoning, both in and out of distribution.
Read more6/14/2024