Neural Surrogate HMC: Accelerated Hamiltonian Monte Carlo with a Neural Network Surrogate Likelihood
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Accelerating Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (HMC) sampling using a neural network surrogate likelihood
- Applying this technique to a cosmic ray transport problem
- Demonstrating improved computational efficiency compared to standard HMC
Plain English Explanation
This paper introduces a method called Neural Surrogate HMC that can speed up Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (HMC) sampling by using a neural network to approximate the likelihood function. HMC is a powerful Markov Chain Monte Carlo method for sampling from complex probability distributions, but it can be computationally expensive, especially when the likelihood function is expensive to evaluate.
The key idea is to train a neural network to serve as a surrogate for the true likelihood function. This surrogate can be evaluated much more efficiently than the original likelihood, allowing HMC to explore the target distribution more rapidly. The authors demonstrate this approach on a problem from cosmic ray physics, where they need to infer parameters governing the transport of cosmic rays through the heliosphere. By using the neural surrogate, they are able to obtain samples from the posterior distribution much faster than standard HMC.
Technical Explanation
The authors formulate the cosmic ray transport problem as a Bayesian inference task, where the goal is to sample from the posterior distribution of the model parameters given observational data. They use HMC to perform this sampling, as HMC is known to be an efficient MCMC method for high-dimensional problems.
However, evaluating the true likelihood function in this problem is computationally expensive, as it requires running a complex numerical simulation. To address this, the authors train a neural network to approximate the true likelihood function. This neural network surrogate can be evaluated much faster than the original likelihood, allowing HMC to explore the parameter space more efficiently.
The authors carefully design the neural network architecture and training procedure to ensure the surrogate provides a good approximation to the true likelihood. They also develop techniques to account for the uncertainty in the surrogate's predictions, which is crucial for maintaining the validity of the HMC sampling.
The results demonstrate that the Neural Surrogate HMC approach can obtain samples from the posterior distribution an order of magnitude faster than standard HMC, without significantly sacrificing accuracy. This highlights the potential of using neural network surrogates to accelerate computationally expensive Bayesian inference problems.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations and caveats to their approach. First, the performance of the neural surrogate is dependent on the quality of the training data, which in this case comes from the expensive numerical simulations. If the training data does not adequately cover the relevant regions of the parameter space, the surrogate may provide poor approximations.
Additionally, the authors note that their method of accounting for surrogate uncertainty may be overly conservative, potentially leading to slower convergence of the HMC sampler. Further research is needed to find the right balance between surrogate accuracy and sampling efficiency.
Another limitation is that the neural network surrogate needs to be retrained if the underlying physics model changes. This could limit the applicability of the method to problems where the model is frequently updated.
Despite these caveats, the Neural Surrogate HMC approach represents an important step forward in accelerating Bayesian inference for computationally intensive problems. The authors' work highlights the potential of neural network surrogates to serve as a powerful tool for bridging the gap between complex physical models and efficient statistical inference.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel method called Neural Surrogate HMC that uses a neural network to approximate the likelihood function in Hamiltonian Monte Carlo sampling. By leveraging the efficiency of the neural surrogate, the authors demonstrate significant speedups in sampling from the posterior distribution of a cosmic ray transport problem, without sacrificing accuracy.
The authors' work highlights the potential of neural network surrogates to accelerate computationally expensive Bayesian inference problems across a range of scientific and engineering domains. While the method has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in bridging the gap between complex physical models and efficient statistical inference.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Neural Surrogate HMC: Accelerated Hamiltonian Monte Carlo with a Neural Network Surrogate Likelihood
Linnea M Wolniewicz, Peter Sadowski, Claudio Corti
Bayesian Inference with Markov Chain Monte Carlo requires efficient computation of the likelihood function. In some scientific applications, the likelihood must be computed by numerically solving a partial differential equation, which can be prohibitively expensive. We demonstrate that some such problems can be made tractable by amortizing the computation with a surrogate likelihood function implemented by a neural network. We show that this has two additional benefits: reducing noise in the likelihood evaluations and providing fast gradient calculations. In experiments, the approach is applied to a model of heliospheric transport of galactic cosmic rays, where it enables efficient sampling from the posterior of latent parameters in the Parker equation.
Read more7/31/2024
🧠
0
A Study of Bayesian Neural Network Surrogates for Bayesian Optimization
Yucen Lily Li, Tim G. J. Rudner, Andrew Gordon Wilson
Bayesian optimization is a highly efficient approach to optimizing objective functions which are expensive to query. These objectives are typically represented by Gaussian process (GP) surrogate models which are easy to optimize and support exact inference. While standard GP surrogates have been well-established in Bayesian optimization, Bayesian neural networks (BNNs) have recently become practical function approximators, with many benefits over standard GPs such as the ability to naturally handle non-stationarity and learn representations for high-dimensional data. In this paper, we study BNNs as alternatives to standard GP surrogates for optimization. We consider a variety of approximate inference procedures for finite-width BNNs, including high-quality Hamiltonian Monte Carlo, low-cost stochastic MCMC, and heuristics such as deep ensembles. We also consider infinite-width BNNs, linearized Laplace approximations, and partially stochastic models such as deep kernel learning. We evaluate this collection of surrogate models on diverse problems with varying dimensionality, number of objectives, non-stationarity, and discrete and continuous inputs. We find: (i) the ranking of methods is highly problem dependent, suggesting the need for tailored inductive biases; (ii) HMC is the most successful approximate inference procedure for fully stochastic BNNs; (iii) full stochasticity may be unnecessary as deep kernel learning is relatively competitive; (iv) deep ensembles perform relatively poorly; (v) infinite-width BNNs are particularly promising, especially in high dimensions.
Read more5/9/2024
0
Multi-fidelity Hamiltonian Monte Carlo
Dhruv V. Patel, Jonghyun Lee, Matthew W. Farthing, Peter K. Kitanidis, Eric F. Darve
Numerous applications in biology, statistics, science, and engineering require generating samples from high-dimensional probability distributions. In recent years, the Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (HMC) method has emerged as a state-of-the-art Markov chain Monte Carlo technique, exploiting the shape of such high-dimensional target distributions to efficiently generate samples. Despite its impressive empirical success and increasing popularity, its wide-scale adoption remains limited due to the high computational cost of gradient calculation. Moreover, applying this method is impossible when the gradient of the posterior cannot be computed (for example, with black-box simulators). To overcome these challenges, we propose a novel two-stage Hamiltonian Monte Carlo algorithm with a surrogate model. In this multi-fidelity algorithm, the acceptance probability is computed in the first stage via a standard HMC proposal using an inexpensive differentiable surrogate model, and if the proposal is accepted, the posterior is evaluated in the second stage using the high-fidelity (HF) numerical solver. Splitting the standard HMC algorithm into these two stages allows for approximating the gradient of the posterior efficiently, while producing accurate posterior samples by using HF numerical solvers in the second stage. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this algorithm for a range of problems, including linear and nonlinear Bayesian inverse problems with in-silico data and experimental data. The proposed algorithm is shown to seamlessly integrate with various low-fidelity and HF models, priors, and datasets. Remarkably, our proposed method outperforms the traditional HMC algorithm in both computational and statistical efficiency by several orders of magnitude, all while retaining or improving the accuracy in computed posterior statistics.
Read more5/9/2024
🎯
0
Bayesian Uncertainty Estimation by Hamiltonian Monte Carlo: Applications to Cardiac MRI Segmentation
Yidong Zhao, Joao Tourais, Iain Pierce, Christian Nitsche, Thomas A. Treibel, Sebastian Weingartner, Artur M. Schweidtmann, Qian Tao
Deep learning (DL)-based methods have achieved state-of-the-art performance for many medical image segmentation tasks. Nevertheless, recent studies show that deep neural networks (DNNs) can be miscalibrated and overconfident, leading to silent failures that are risky for clinical applications. Bayesian DL provides an intuitive approach to DL failure detection, based on posterior probability estimation. However, the posterior is intractable for large medical image segmentation DNNs. To tackle this challenge, we propose a Bayesian learning framework using Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (HMC), tempered by cold posterior (CP) to accommodate medical data augmentation, named HMC-CP. For HMC computation, we further propose a cyclical annealing strategy, capturing both local and global geometries of the posterior distribution, enabling highly efficient Bayesian DNN training with the same computational budget as training a single DNN. The resulting Bayesian DNN outputs an ensemble segmentation along with the segmentation uncertainty. We evaluate the proposed HMC-CP extensively on cardiac magnetic resonance image (MRI) segmentation, using in-domain steady-state free precession (SSFP) cine images as well as out-of-domain datasets of quantitative T1 and T2 mapping. Our results show that the proposed method improves both segmentation accuracy and uncertainty estimation for in- and out-of-domain data, compared with well-established baseline methods such as Monte Carlo Dropout and Deep Ensembles. Additionally, we establish a conceptual link between HMC and the commonly known stochastic gradient descent (SGD) and provide general insight into the uncertainty of DL. This uncertainty is implicitly encoded in the training dynamics but often overlooked. With reliable uncertainty estimation, our method provides a promising direction toward trustworthy DL in clinical applications.
Read more6/28/2024