A New Analysis of Differential Privacy's Generalization Guarantees

Overview

• This paper presents a new proof for the "transfer theorem" underlying adaptive data analysis, which shows that mechanisms for answering adaptively chosen statistical queries that are differentially private and sample-accurate are also accurate out-of-sample.
• The new proof is more elementary and provides structural insights that the authors expect will be useful in other contexts.
• The key ideas are: 1) differential privacy ensures the expected value of any query on the posterior distribution is close to its true value on the data distribution, and 2) sample accuracy ensures any query answer is close to its posterior expectation with high probability.
• The new proof avoids the "monitor argument" used in prior work and provides substantially better concrete bounds than the previous state of the art.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses a fundamental result in the field of adaptive data analysis, which is the study of how to analyze data in a way that is robust to the process of analyzing the data itself. Specifically, the "transfer theorem" shows that if you have a way of answering statistical queries about a dataset that is both differentially private and accurate on the sample data, then that mechanism will also be accurate on new, unseen data.

The authors present a new, simpler proof of this transfer theorem that provides additional insights. The key ideas are:

1. Differential privacy: If a mechanism is differentially private, it means that the answers it provides don't depend too much on any individual data point. This ensures that the expected value of any query on the "posterior distribution" (the distribution of datasets that are consistent with the query answers) is close to the true value on the original data distribution.

2. Sample accuracy: If a mechanism is accurate on the sample data, that means any query answer it produces is close to the expected value on the posterior distribution. This follows from a thought experiment where we imagine the dataset is resampled from the posterior after the mechanism has committed to its answers.

By combining these two ideas, the authors show that differentially private and sample-accurate mechanisms will also be accurate on new, unseen data. Importantly, their new proof technique allows them to derive concrete bounds that are substantially better than prior work, bringing these techniques closer to practical use.

Technical Explanation

The core of the paper is a new proof of the "transfer theorem" for adaptive data analysis. This theorem shows that any mechanism for answering adaptively chosen statistical queries that is both differentially private and sample-accurate is also accurate out-of-sample.

The authors' new proof has two key components:

1. Differential privacy ensures posterior accuracy: They show that differential privacy implies the expectation of any query on the posterior distribution (the distribution of datasets consistent with the transcript of the interaction) is close to its true value on the data distribution. This follows from the properties of differentially private mechanisms.

2. Sample accuracy ensures posterior concentration: They then show that sample accuracy on its own ensures any query answer produced by the mechanism is close to its posterior expectation with high probability. This uses a thought experiment where the dataset is resampled from the posterior after the mechanism has committed to its answers.

By combining these two bounds, the transfer theorem follows. Importantly, this new proof technique avoids the "monitor argument" used in prior work, and results in substantially better concrete bounds, even though the asymptotic rates are the same.

The authors demonstrate that their new bounds outperform the naive sample-splitting baseline at much smaller dataset sizes compared to the previous state of the art. This brings techniques from this literature closer to practical use in areas like causal inference with differentially private clustered outcomes or generalization in the face of adaptivity from a Bayesian perspective.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge some limitations of their work. Firstly, while their new bounds are substantially better than prior results, the improvements are in the constants rather than the asymptotic rates, which are known to be tight. It's an open question whether further improvements are possible.

Additionally, the authors' proof technique relies on a specific technical condition called "approximate sufficiency," which may not hold in all settings. Extensions to more general query types or mechanisms could be an area for future research.

That said, the authors' new proof is a valuable contribution, as it provides structural insights that may be useful beyond this particular problem. The clear explanations and comparisons to prior work also make the paper accessible to a broader audience.

Overall, this work represents a meaningful advance in our understanding of the fundamental limits of adaptive data analysis, with potentially important implications for fields like causal inference and Bayesian generalization that rely on these techniques.

Conclusion

This paper presents a new, more elementary proof of the transfer theorem for adaptive data analysis, which shows that differentially private and sample-accurate mechanisms are also accurate out-of-sample. The key ideas are that differential privacy ensures posterior accuracy, while sample accuracy ensures posterior concentration.

The authors' new proof technique avoids the limitations of prior work and yields substantially better concrete bounds, bringing these techniques closer to practical use in areas like causal inference and Bayesian generalization. While the asymptotic rates cannot be improved, the structural insights from this work may be valuable in other contexts as well.

Overall, this paper represents an important step forward in our theoretical understanding of the fundamental limits of adaptive data analysis, with potential implications for a wide range of applications that rely on these techniques.