A new model for natural groupings in high-dimensional data
1909.06511
0
0
📈
Abstract
Clustering aims to divide a set of points into groups. The current paradigm assumes that the grouping is well-defined (unique) given the probability model from which the data is drawn. Yet, recent experiments have uncovered several high-dimensional datasets that form different binary groupings after projecting the data to randomly chosen one-dimensional subspaces. This paper describes a probability model for the data that could explain this phenomenon. It is a simple model to serve as a proof of concept for understanding the geometry of high-dimensional data. We start by building a rescaled multivariate Bernouilli model (stretched hypercube) so to create several overlapping grouping structures in the data. The size of each scaling parameter is related to the likelihood of uncovering the corresponding grouping by random 1D projection. Clusters in the original space are then created by adding noise to this cluster-free model. In high dimension, these clusters would hardly be observable given a sample set from the distribution because of the curse of dimensionality, but the binary groupings are clear. Our construction makes it clear that one needs to make a distinction between groupings and clusters in the original space. It also highlights the need to interpret any clustering found in projected data as merely one among potentially many other groupings in a dataset.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores a probability model for high-dimensional data that can exhibit multiple, overlapping groupings when projected to one-dimensional subspaces.
- The authors propose a rescaled multivariate Bernoulli model (a "stretched hypercube") that can create various grouping structures within the data.
- They then add noise to this cluster-free model to generate clusters in the original high-dimensional space, which are difficult to observe due to the curse of dimensionality.
- The key insight is the distinction between "groupings" that may be visible in projections and "clusters" in the original high-dimensional space.
Plain English Explanation
Clustering is a common technique used to group similar data points together. Traditionally, it's assumed that there is a well-defined, unique way to group the data based on the underlying probability model.
However, this paper describes a probability model for high-dimensional data that can exhibit multiple, overlapping groupings when you look at the data in one-dimensional projections. This relates to the phenomenon described in the paper "Classifying Overlapping Gaussian Mixtures in High Dimensions from Random Sketches".
The authors start by building a simple model - a "stretched hypercube" - that can create these overlapping grouping structures in the data. The size of the scaling parameters in this model determines how likely it is to uncover a particular grouping by randomly projecting the data to a one-dimensional subspace.
Then, the authors add noise to this cluster-free model to generate clusters in the original high-dimensional space. These clusters are very difficult to observe directly because of the "curse of dimensionality" - the phenomenon where data becomes increasingly sparse and difficult to analyze as the number of dimensions increases.
The key insight here is that we need to distinguish between these "groupings" that may be visible in low-dimensional projections and the "clusters" that exist in the original high-dimensional space. This highlights the importance of interpreting any clustering results in projected data as just one of potentially many possible groupings in the dataset.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a probability model for high-dimensional data that can exhibit multiple, overlapping grouping structures when projected to one-dimensional subspaces. This relates to the observation that certain high-dimensional datasets can form different binary groupings after such projections.
The authors start by constructing a rescaled multivariate Bernoulli model, which they call a "stretched hypercube." This model can create several overlapping grouping structures in the data, where the size of the scaling parameters determines the likelihood of uncovering a particular grouping via random 1D projection.
To generate clusters in the original high-dimensional space, the authors then add noise to this cluster-free model. Due to the "curse of dimensionality," these clusters would be hardly observable in a sample from the distribution, but the binary groupings in the projected data would still be clear.
This construction highlights the distinction between "groupings" that may be visible in low-dimensional projections and "clusters" that exist in the original high-dimensional space. It suggests that any clustering found in projected data should be interpreted as just one of potentially many possible groupings within the dataset.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a simple, yet insightful, probability model that can explain the phenomenon of overlapping groupings in high-dimensional data. By distinguishing between "groupings" and "clusters," the authors challenge the traditional assumption that clustering should uncover a well-defined, unique grouping structure.
One potential limitation of this research is the simplicity of the proposed model. While it serves as a proof of concept, the authors acknowledge that real-world high-dimensional data may exhibit more complex structures. Further research could explore more sophisticated models, like those used in the "Interpretable Clustering with a Distinguishability Criterion" paper, to better capture the nuances of high-dimensional data.
Additionally, the paper does not provide extensive empirical validation of the model, relying primarily on the theoretical construction. Comparing the model's predictions to experimental results, as done in the "Differential Similarity in Higher Dimensional Spaces: Theory and Applications" paper, could strengthen the claims and provide more practical insights.
Nevertheless, this research offers a thought-provoking perspective on the challenges of clustering high-dimensional data and the need to interpret clustering results with caution. It encourages readers to think critically about the assumptions underlying common clustering techniques and to consider alternative approaches that better capture the inherent complexities of high-dimensional datasets.
Conclusion
This paper presents a probability model for high-dimensional data that can exhibit multiple, overlapping grouping structures when projected to one-dimensional subspaces. The authors propose a rescaled multivariate Bernoulli model, or "stretched hypercube," that can create these grouping structures, and then add noise to generate clusters in the original high-dimensional space.
The key insight is the distinction between "groupings" that may be visible in low-dimensional projections and "clusters" that exist in the original high-dimensional space. This challenges the traditional assumption that clustering should uncover a well-defined, unique grouping structure and highlights the need to interpret clustering results in projected data as just one of potentially many possible groupings within the dataset.
While the model is relatively simple, it serves as a proof of concept and encourages further research into more sophisticated approaches for understanding the geometry of high-dimensional data. By fostering critical thinking about the assumptions and limitations of common clustering techniques, this work contributes to a more nuanced understanding of the challenges and opportunities in the field of high-dimensional data analysis.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Learning Discrete Concepts in Latent Hierarchical Models
Lingjing Kong, Guangyi Chen, Biwei Huang, Eric P. Xing, Yuejie Chi, Kun Zhang
0
0
Learning concepts from natural high-dimensional data (e.g., images) holds potential in building human-aligned and interpretable machine learning models. Despite its encouraging prospect, formalization and theoretical insights into this crucial task are still lacking. In this work, we formalize concepts as discrete latent causal variables that are related via a hierarchical causal model that encodes different abstraction levels of concepts embedded in high-dimensional data (e.g., a dog breed and its eye shapes in natural images). We formulate conditions to facilitate the identification of the proposed causal model, which reveals when learning such concepts from unsupervised data is possible. Our conditions permit complex causal hierarchical structures beyond latent trees and multi-level directed acyclic graphs in prior work and can handle high-dimensional, continuous observed variables, which is well-suited for unstructured data modalities such as images. We substantiate our theoretical claims with synthetic data experiments. Further, we discuss our theory's implications for understanding the underlying mechanisms of latent diffusion models and provide corresponding empirical evidence for our theoretical insights.
6/4/2024
Interpretable Clustering with the Distinguishability Criterion
Ali Turfah, Xiaoquan Wen
0
0
Cluster analysis is a popular unsupervised learning tool used in many disciplines to identify heterogeneous sub-populations within a sample. However, validating cluster analysis results and determining the number of clusters in a data set remains an outstanding problem. In this work, we present a global criterion called the Distinguishability criterion to quantify the separability of identified clusters and validate inferred cluster configurations. Our computational implementation of the Distinguishability criterion corresponds to the Bayes risk of a randomized classifier under the 0-1 loss. We propose a combined loss function-based computational framework that integrates the Distinguishability criterion with many commonly used clustering procedures, such as hierarchical clustering, k-means, and finite mixture models. We present these new algorithms as well as the results from comprehensive data analysis based on simulation studies and real data applications.
4/26/2024
🔗
Spectral clustering in the Gaussian mixture block model
Shuangping Li, Tselil Schramm
0
0
Gaussian mixture block models are distributions over graphs that strive to model modern networks: to generate a graph from such a model, we associate each vertex $i$ with a latent feature vector $u_i in mathbb{R}^d$ sampled from a mixture of Gaussians, and we add edge $(i,j)$ if and only if the feature vectors are sufficiently similar, in that $langle u_i,u_j rangle ge tau$ for a pre-specified threshold $tau$. The different components of the Gaussian mixture represent the fact that there may be different types of nodes with different distributions over features -- for example, in a social network each component represents the different attributes of a distinct community. Natural algorithmic tasks associated with these networks are embedding (recovering the latent feature vectors) and clustering (grouping nodes by their mixture component). In this paper we initiate the study of clustering and embedding graphs sampled from high-dimensional Gaussian mixture block models, where the dimension of the latent feature vectors $dto infty$ as the size of the network $n to infty$. This high-dimensional setting is most appropriate in the context of modern networks, in which we think of the latent feature space as being high-dimensional. We analyze the performance of canonical spectral clustering and embedding algorithms for such graphs in the case of 2-component spherical Gaussian mixtures, and begin to sketch out the information-computation landscape for clustering and embedding in these models.
4/12/2024
Classifying Overlapping Gaussian Mixtures in High Dimensions: From Optimal Classifiers to Neural Nets
Khen Cohen, Noam Levi, Yaron Oz
0
0
We derive closed-form expressions for the Bayes optimal decision boundaries in binary classification of high dimensional overlapping Gaussian mixture model (GMM) data, and show how they depend on the eigenstructure of the class covariances, for particularly interesting structured data. We empirically demonstrate, through experiments on synthetic GMMs inspired by real-world data, that deep neural networks trained for classification, learn predictors which approximate the derived optimal classifiers. We further extend our study to networks trained on authentic data, observing that decision thresholds correlate with the covariance eigenvectors rather than the eigenvalues, mirroring our GMM analysis. This provides theoretical insights regarding neural networks' ability to perform probabilistic inference and distill statistical patterns from intricate distributions.
5/29/2024