The Normal Distributions Indistinguishability Spectrum and its Application to Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning

Overview

• Differential Privacy (DP) is a popular method for machine learning on privacy-sensitive data
• In big data analytics, randomized sketching/aggregation algorithms are used to process high-dimensional data
• These randomized algorithms should provide some inherent privacy, but existing DP mechanisms don't fully leverage this randomness

Plain English Explanation

Differential Privacy (DP) is a way to protect people's privacy when doing machine learning on sensitive data. In big data analytics, researchers often use random algorithms to process high-dimensional data and make it easier to work with. Intuitively, these random algorithms should provide some privacy protection on their own. However, most existing DP techniques don't take full advantage of this inherent randomness, which can lead to unnecessary "noise" being added to the data.

The key question this research aims to answer is: Can we improve the usefulness of DP mechanisms for random machine learning algorithms by leveraging the randomness of the algorithms themselves?

The researchers' main contribution is proving what they call the "NDIS theorem." This is a mathematical result that allows them to efficiently calculate how "indistinguishable" two normal distributions are from a DP perspective. This has two important practical implications:

1. It provides a way to estimate the optimal privacy-utility tradeoff for DP mechanisms with normally-distributed outputs.
2. It allows analyzing DP mechanisms for a wider range of algorithms, not just those with normally-distributed outputs.

The researchers then apply the NDIS theorem to derive new DP mechanisms for specific types of machine learning algorithms, like Gaussian Random Projections and Ordinary Least Squares. Compared to existing techniques, these new DP mechanisms are able to achieve better privacy-utility tradeoffs by taking advantage of the randomness inherent in the underlying algorithms.

Technical Explanation

The key contribution of this work is the NDIS theorem, which provides a closed-form analytic computation for the (ε,δ)-indistinguishability-spectrum (IS) of two arbitrary normal distributions N1 and N2. This means the theorem gives an efficient way to calculate the optimal δ (for any given ε) such that N1 and N2 are (ε,δ)-close according to differential privacy.

The importance of the NDIS theorem is two-fold:

1. It yields efficient estimators for the IS, which is key for analyzing DP mechanisms with normally-distributed outputs.
2. It allows analyzing DP mechanisms for more general queries by leveraging their behavior on large inputs.

The researchers apply the NDIS theorem to derive new DP mechanisms for:

1. Gaussian Random Projections (RP): A common randomized sketching algorithm used in big data analytics.
2. Ordinary Least Squares (OLS): A widely used machine learning algorithm.

Compared to existing DP techniques, these new mechanisms achieve superior privacy-utility tradeoffs by taking advantage of the inherent randomness in the underlying algorithms.

The researchers also apply the NDIS theorem to analyze a data-driven DP notion called "relative DP," introduced by Lu et al. [S&P 2024]. Their method identifies the range of (ε,δ) values where no additional noise is needed to satisfy relative DP.

Critical Analysis

The main strength of this work is the NDIS theorem, which provides a powerful analytical tool for studying DP mechanisms with normally-distributed outputs. This allows the researchers to derive new DP algorithms that outperform existing techniques by better leveraging the inherent randomness in the underlying machine learning queries.

However, the applicability of this approach is limited to algorithms with normally-distributed outputs or those that can be analyzed in terms of their behavior on large inputs. It's not clear how well the NDIS theorem and the derived DP mechanisms would generalize to a broader class of machine learning algorithms.

Additionally, the researchers only evaluate their methods on synthetic data, so it would be important to see how they perform on real-world datasets and tasks. Further research is needed to understand the practical limitations and potential pitfalls of this approach.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel theoretical result, the NDIS theorem, that enables more efficient analysis and design of differentially private mechanisms for machine learning algorithms with inherent randomness. By leveraging this theorem, the researchers derive new DP mechanisms that achieve superior privacy-utility tradeoffs compared to existing techniques.

These findings have the potential to improve the practicality of deploying DP in real-world machine learning applications, particularly in domains like big data analytics where randomized sketching/aggregation algorithms are commonly used. However, further research is needed to assess the broader applicability and robustness of this approach.