One-shot skill assessment in high-stakes domains with limited data via meta learning
2301.00812
0
0
📊
Abstract
Deep Learning (DL) has achieved robust competency assessment in various high-stakes fields. However, the applicability of DL models is often hampered by their substantial data requirements and confinement to specific training domains. This prevents them from transitioning to new tasks where data is scarce. Therefore, domain adaptation emerges as a critical element for the practical implementation of DL in real-world scenarios. Herein, we introduce A-VBANet, a novel meta-learning model capable of delivering domain-agnostic skill assessment via one-shot learning. Our methodology has been tested by assessing surgical skills on five laparoscopic and robotic simulators and real-life laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Our model successfully adapted with accuracies up to 99.5% in one-shot and 99.9% in few-shot settings for simulated tasks and 89.7% for laparoscopic cholecystectomy. This study marks the first instance of a domain-agnostic methodology for skill assessment in critical fields setting a precedent for the broad application of DL across diverse real-life domains with limited data.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Deep learning (DL) has achieved strong performance in various high-stakes fields, but its applicability is often limited by large data requirements and confinement to specific training domains.
- Domain adaptation is crucial for the practical implementation of DL in real-world scenarios where data is scarce.
- The paper introduces A-VBANet, a novel meta-learning model that can perform domain-agnostic skill assessment using one-shot learning.
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning is a powerful type of artificial intelligence that has become very good at certain tasks, like assessing people's skills in high-stakes fields. However, deep learning models often need a lot of data to work well, and they're usually only good at the specific tasks they were trained on. This limits their usefulness in the real world, where data can be scarce and we need AI systems that can adapt to new situations.
To address this, the researchers developed a new deep learning model called A-VBANet. This model is designed to be able to assess people's skills without needing a lot of data, and it can do this in a wide range of domains, not just the ones it was trained on. The researchers tested A-VBANet on assessing surgical skills in both simulated and real-life settings, and it was able to achieve very high accuracy, even when only shown a small amount of data.
This is an important breakthrough because it means deep learning can now be used to evaluate skills in critical fields, like medicine, where data may be limited. It sets the stage for deep learning to be more widely applied in diverse real-world scenarios.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed A-VBANet, a meta-learning model that can perform domain-agnostic skill assessment using one-shot learning. Meta-learning is a technique that allows a model to quickly adapt to new tasks or domains with limited data.
To test A-VBANet, the researchers assessed surgical skills on five different laparoscopic and robotic simulators, as well as real-life laparoscopic cholecystectomy (gallbladder removal) procedures. The model was able to achieve accuracies up to 99.5% in one-shot settings and 99.9% in few-shot settings for the simulated tasks, and 89.7% for the real-life laparoscopic cholecystectomy procedure.
This is the first instance of a domain-agnostic methodology for skill assessment in critical fields, setting a precedent for the broad application of deep learning across diverse real-life domains with limited data.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to domain-agnostic skill assessment using meta-learning, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- The experiments were conducted on a relatively limited set of simulated and real-life surgical tasks. It would be valuable to test the model's performance on a wider range of skills and domains to fully assess its generalization capabilities.
- The real-life laparoscopic cholecystectomy task had a lower accuracy compared to the simulated tasks. Further research is needed to understand the factors that affect the model's performance in real-world settings and how to improve its robustness.
- The paper does not provide detailed information about the model's architecture and training process, which makes it difficult to fully evaluate the technical approach.
Overall, the research is an important step towards enabling the broad application of deep learning for skill assessment in critical domains, but more work is needed to fully realize the potential of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel meta-learning model, A-VBANet, that can perform domain-agnostic skill assessment using one-shot learning. The model was successfully tested on a range of simulated and real-life surgical tasks, demonstrating its ability to adapt to new domains with limited data.
This research marks a significant advancement in the field of deep learning, as it sets the stage for the widespread application of this technology in critical domains, such as healthcare, where data may be scarce. By enabling deep learning models to adapt to new tasks and environments, this work has the potential to unlock new possibilities for the use of AI in real-world settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Domain Generalization through Meta-Learning: A Survey
Arsham Gholamzadeh Khoee, Yinan Yu, Robert Feldt
0
0
Deep neural networks (DNNs) have revolutionized artificial intelligence but often lack performance when faced with out-of-distribution (OOD) data, a common scenario due to the inevitable domain shifts in real-world applications. This limitation stems from the common assumption that training and testing data share the same distribution-an assumption frequently violated in practice. Despite their effectiveness with large amounts of data and computational power, DNNs struggle with distributional shifts and limited labeled data, leading to overfitting and poor generalization across various tasks and domains. Meta-learning presents a promising approach by employing algorithms that acquire transferable knowledge across various tasks for fast adaptation, eliminating the need to learn each task from scratch. This survey paper delves into the realm of meta-learning with a focus on its contribution to domain generalization. We first clarify the concept of meta-learning for domain generalization and introduce a novel taxonomy based on the feature extraction strategy and the classifier learning methodology, offering a granular view of methodologies. Through an exhaustive review of existing methods and underlying theories, we map out the fundamentals of the field. Our survey provides practical insights and an informed discussion on promising research directions, paving the way for future innovation in meta-learning for domain generalization.
4/4/2024
📈
Multiple Teachers-Meticulous Student: A Domain Adaptive Meta-Knowledge Distillation Model for Medical Image Classification
Shahabedin Nabavi, Kian Anvari Hamedani, Mohsen Ebrahimi Moghaddam, Ahmad Ali Abin, Alejandro F. Frangi
0
0
Background: Image classification can be considered one of the key pillars of medical image analysis. Deep learning (DL) faces challenges that prevent its practical applications despite the remarkable improvement in medical image classification. The data distribution differences can lead to a drop in the efficiency of DL, known as the domain shift problem. Besides, requiring bulk annotated data for model training, the large size of models, and the privacy-preserving of patients are other challenges of using DL in medical image classification. This study presents a strategy that can address the mentioned issues simultaneously. Method: The proposed domain adaptive model based on knowledge distillation can classify images by receiving limited annotated data of different distributions. The designed multiple teachers-meticulous student model trains a student network that tries to solve the challenges by receiving the parameters of several teacher networks. The proposed model was evaluated using six available datasets of different distributions by defining the respiratory motion artefact detection task. Results: The results of extensive experiments using several datasets show the superiority of the proposed model in addressing the domain shift problem and lack of access to bulk annotated data. Besides, the privacy preservation of patients by receiving only the teacher network parameters instead of the original data and consolidating the knowledge of several DL models into a model with almost similar performance are other advantages of the proposed model. Conclusions: The proposed model can pave the way for practical clinical applications of deep classification methods by achieving the mentioned objectives simultaneously.
4/10/2024
🤔
Meta-learning in healthcare: A survey
Alireza Rafiei, Ronald Moore, Sina Jahromi, Farshid Hajati, Rishikesan Kamaleswaran
0
0
As a subset of machine learning, meta-learning, or learning to learn, aims at improving the model's capabilities by employing prior knowledge and experience. A meta-learning paradigm can appropriately tackle the conventional challenges of traditional learning approaches, such as insufficient number of samples, domain shifts, and generalization. These unique characteristics position meta-learning as a suitable choice for developing influential solutions in various healthcare contexts, where the available data is often insufficient, and the data collection methodologies are different. This survey discusses meta-learning broad applications in the healthcare domain to provide insight into how and where it can address critical healthcare challenges. We first describe the theoretical foundations and pivotal methods of meta-learning. We then divide the employed meta-learning approaches in the healthcare domain into two main categories of multi/single-task learning and many/few-shot learning and survey the studies. Finally, we highlight the current challenges in meta-learning research, discuss the potential solutions, and provide future perspectives on meta-learning in healthcare.
6/11/2024
A Systematic Review of Few-Shot Learning in Medical Imaging
Eva Pachetti, Sara Colantonio
0
0
The lack of annotated medical images limits the performance of deep learning models, which usually need large-scale labelled datasets. Few-shot learning techniques can reduce data scarcity issues and enhance medical image analysis, especially with meta-learning. This systematic review gives a comprehensive overview of few-shot learning in medical imaging. We searched the literature systematically and selected 80 relevant articles published from 2018 to 2023. We clustered the articles based on medical outcomes, such as tumour segmentation, disease classification, and image registration; anatomical structure investigated (i.e. heart, lung, etc.); and the meta-learning method used. For each cluster, we examined the papers' distributions and the results provided by the state-of-the-art. In addition, we identified a generic pipeline shared among all the studies. The review shows that few-shot learning can overcome data scarcity in most outcomes and that meta-learning is a popular choice to perform few-shot learning because it can adapt to new tasks with few labelled samples. In addition, following meta-learning, supervised learning and semi-supervised learning stand out as the predominant techniques employed to tackle few-shot learning challenges in medical imaging and also best performing. Lastly, we observed that the primary application areas predominantly encompass cardiac, pulmonary, and abdominal domains. This systematic review aims to inspire further research to improve medical image analysis and patient care.
6/26/2024