Optimal Rate of Kernel Regression in Large Dimensions
0
↗️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This study examines kernel regression, a machine learning technique, for large-dimensional data where the sample size is polynomially related to the data dimension.
- The researchers develop a general tool to characterize the upper and lower bounds of kernel regression performance in high-dimensional settings.
- They apply this tool to show that the optimal rate of kernel regression's excess risk is n^(-1/2) when the sample size n scales as d^(γ), where d is the data dimension and γ is 2, 4, 6, 8, etc.
- The researchers also explore how the optimal rate varies for other values of γ, revealing new phenomena like "multiple descent" and "periodic plateau" behavior.
- As an application, the paper analyzes the optimal rates for the neural tangent kernel (NTK), which is relevant for wide neural networks.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers investigate kernel regression, a widely used machine learning technique, in settings where the number of data samples (n) is related to the dimensionality of the data (d) in a specific way. Specifically, they look at cases where n scales as a polynomial function of d, i.e., n ~ d^γ for some exponent γ.
The key contribution is the development of a general analytical tool that allows the researchers to determine both the best possible performance (the minimax lower bound) and the performance of existing methods (the upper bound) for kernel regression in high-dimensional settings. They use this tool to show that when n ~ d^γ and γ is 2, 4, 6, 8, or similar even numbers, the optimal rate of the "excess risk" (a measure of how well the method performs) is n^(-1/2), meaning it improves at a rate proportional to the square root of the number of samples.
But the researchers also find that the optimal rate varies in more complex ways for other values of γ. In particular, they observe "multiple descent" behavior, where the optimal rate first decreases, then increases, and then decreases again as γ increases. They also see "periodic plateau" behavior, where the optimal rate stays constant over certain ranges of γ.
As an application, the paper also analyzes the optimal rates for the neural tangent kernel (NTK), which is related to the performance of wide neural networks. This provides insights into the best achievable performance for these types of models in high-dimensional settings.
Technical Explanation
The researchers begin by developing a general framework to characterize the upper and lower bounds of kernel regression performance in high-dimensional settings. They do this by relating the performance to two key complexity measures: the Mendelson complexity (ε_n^2), which bounds the upper limit, and the metric entropy (ᾱ_n^2), which bounds the lower limit.
When the target function falls within the reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS) associated with an inner product model defined on the d-dimensional unit sphere (S^d), the researchers leverage this framework to show that the minimax rate of the excess risk is n^(-1/2) when n ~ d^γ and γ = 2, 4, 6, 8, etc.
They then extend their analysis to determine the optimal rate of the excess risk for all γ > 0. This reveals several new phenomena, including "multiple descent" behavior, where the optimal rate first decreases, then increases, and then decreases again as γ increases, as well as "periodic plateau" behavior, where the optimal rate remains constant over certain ranges of γ.
As an application, the paper also analyzes the optimal rates for the neural tangent kernel (NTK), which is relevant for wide neural networks. This provides a explicit characterization of the optimal rate curve for NTK-based models in high-dimensional settings.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive theoretical analysis of kernel regression performance in high-dimensional settings, with a focus on the scaling of the sample size n with the data dimension d. The development of the general framework to characterize upper and lower bounds is a valuable contribution, as it allows for a deeper understanding of the fundamental limits of kernel regression in these challenging regimes.
One potential limitation is that the analysis is primarily theoretical, and the practical implications may depend on factors not fully captured by the theoretical model, such as the specific structure of real-world data and the impact of approximations or numerical errors. Additionally, the paper does not provide empirical validation of the theoretical results, which would be helpful for assessing the relevance and applicability of the findings.
Moreover, the analysis is limited to the specific setting of RKHS target functions on the unit sphere. It would be interesting to explore how the results generalize to other function classes or data manifolds, as well as to investigate the potential implications for the design of kernel functions and the selection of hyperparameters in practical applications.
Despite these caveats, the paper presents a significant advancement in the theoretical understanding of kernel regression for large-dimensional data, with potential implications for the design and analysis of a broad range of machine learning models, including wide neural networks.
Conclusion
This study provides a comprehensive theoretical analysis of kernel regression for large-dimensional data, where the sample size n is polynomially related to the data dimension d. The researchers develop a general framework to characterize the upper and lower bounds of kernel regression performance, and they use this tool to derive the optimal rates of the excess risk under different scaling regimes between n and d.
The findings reveal several new phenomena, including "multiple descent" and "periodic plateau" behaviors in the optimal rate curve, which expand our understanding of the fundamental limits of kernel regression in high-dimensional settings. The analysis also provides insights into the performance of the neural tangent kernel, with implications for wide neural networks.
While the theoretical nature of the study limits its immediate practical applications, the insights gained can inform the design and analysis of a variety of machine learning models, particularly in domains where large-dimensional data is prevalent. Further empirical validation and exploration of more general data settings could help bridge the gap between theory and practice, paving the way for more robust and efficient kernel-based methods in the future.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
↗️
0
Optimal Rate of Kernel Regression in Large Dimensions
Weihao Lu, Haobo Zhang, Yicheng Li, Manyun Xu, Qian Lin
We perform a study on kernel regression for large-dimensional data (where the sample size $n$ is polynomially depending on the dimension $d$ of the samples, i.e., $nasymp d^{gamma}$ for some $gamma >0$ ). We first build a general tool to characterize the upper bound and the minimax lower bound of kernel regression for large dimensional data through the Mendelson complexity $varepsilon_{n}^{2}$ and the metric entropy $bar{varepsilon}_{n}^{2}$ respectively. When the target function falls into the RKHS associated with a (general) inner product model defined on $mathbb{S}^{d}$, we utilize the new tool to show that the minimax rate of the excess risk of kernel regression is $n^{-1/2}$ when $nasymp d^{gamma}$ for $gamma =2, 4, 6, 8, cdots$. We then further determine the optimal rate of the excess risk of kernel regression for all the $gamma>0$ and find that the curve of optimal rate varying along $gamma$ exhibits several new phenomena including the multiple descent behavior and the periodic plateau behavior. As an application, For the neural tangent kernel (NTK), we also provide a similar explicit description of the curve of optimal rate. As a direct corollary, we know these claims hold for wide neural networks as well.
Read more7/1/2024
↗️
0
Universality of kernel random matrices and kernel regression in the quadratic regime
Parthe Pandit, Zhichao Wang, Yizhe Zhu
Kernel ridge regression (KRR) is a popular class of machine learning models that has become an important tool for understanding deep learning. Much of the focus has been on studying the proportional asymptotic regime, $n asymp d$, where $n$ is the number of training samples and $d$ is the dimension of the dataset. In this regime, under certain conditions on the data distribution, the kernel random matrix involved in KRR exhibits behavior akin to that of a linear kernel. In this work, we extend the study of kernel regression to the quadratic asymptotic regime, where $n asymp d^2$. In this regime, we demonstrate that a broad class of inner-product kernels exhibit behavior similar to a quadratic kernel. Specifically, we establish an operator norm approximation bound for the difference between the original kernel random matrix and a quadratic kernel random matrix with additional correction terms compared to the Taylor expansion of the kernel functions. The approximation works for general data distributions under a Gaussian-moment-matching assumption with a covariance structure. This new approximation is utilized to obtain a limiting spectral distribution of the original kernel matrix and characterize the precise asymptotic training and generalization errors for KRR in the quadratic regime when $n/d^2$ converges to a non-zero constant. The generalization errors are obtained for both deterministic and random teacher models. Our proof techniques combine moment methods, Wick's formula, orthogonal polynomials, and resolvent analysis of random matrices with correlated entries.
Read more8/6/2024
👀
0
The phase diagram of kernel interpolation in large dimensions
Haobo Zhang, Weihao Lu, Qian Lin
The generalization ability of kernel interpolation in large dimensions (i.e., $n asymp d^{gamma}$ for some $gamma>0$) might be one of the most interesting problems in the recent renaissance of kernel regression, since it may help us understand the 'benign overfitting phenomenon' reported in the neural networks literature. Focusing on the inner product kernel on the sphere, we fully characterized the exact order of both the variance and bias of large-dimensional kernel interpolation under various source conditions $sgeq 0$. Consequently, we obtained the $(s,gamma)$-phase diagram of large-dimensional kernel interpolation, i.e., we determined the regions in $(s,gamma)$-plane where the kernel interpolation is minimax optimal, sub-optimal and inconsistent.
Read more4/22/2024
0
Kernel Density Estimators in Large Dimensions
Giulio Biroli, Marc M'ezard
This paper studies Kernel density estimation for a high-dimensional distribution $rho(x)$. Traditional approaches have focused on the limit of large number of data points $n$ and fixed dimension $d$. We analyze instead the regime where both the number $n$ of data points $y_i$ and their dimensionality $d$ grow with a fixed ratio $alpha=(log n)/d$. Our study reveals three distinct statistical regimes for the kernel-based estimate of the density $hat rho_h^{mathcal {D}}(x)=frac{1}{n h^d}sum_{i=1}^n Kleft(frac{x-y_i}{h}right)$, depending on the bandwidth $h$: a classical regime for large bandwidth where the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) holds, which is akin to the one found in traditional approaches. Below a certain value of the bandwidth, $h_{CLT}(alpha)$, we find that the CLT breaks down. The statistics of $hat rho_h^{mathcal {D}}(x)$ for a fixed $x$ drawn from $rho(x)$ is given by a heavy-tailed distribution (an alpha-stable distribution). In particular below a value $h_G(alpha)$, we find that $hat rho_h^{mathcal {D}}(x)$ is governed by extreme value statistics: only a few points in the database matter and give the dominant contribution to the density estimator. We provide a detailed analysis for high-dimensional multivariate Gaussian data. We show that the optimal bandwidth threshold based on Kullback-Leibler divergence lies in the new statistical regime identified in this paper. Our findings reveal limitations of classical approaches, show the relevance of these new statistical regimes, and offer new insights for Kernel density estimation in high-dimensional settings.
Read more8/19/2024