Optimizing Nurse Scheduling: A Supply Chain Approach for Healthcare Institutions

Read original: arXiv:2407.11195 - Published 7/17/2024 by Jubin Thomas

🎯

Overview

Managers often face complex scenarios that require more than just intuition or experience to solve
The rise of big data has further complicated organizational challenges, necessitating a quantitative approach
This study aims to provide a framework for addressing personnel scheduling, a critical issue in organizational management
The focus is on optimizing shift assignments for staff, a task complicated by factors like contractual obligations and employee shortages
The study examines the nurse rostering problem, a personnel scheduling challenge prevalent in healthcare settings

Plain English Explanation

Managers often encounter difficult situations when running an organization. They can't always rely on their gut feelings or past experience to make the best decisions. This is especially true in the era of big data, where the sheer amount of information and constraints can be overwhelming.

The goal of this research is to provide a framework for tackling one of the key challenges in organizational management: personnel scheduling. Specifically, the study focuses on optimizing the assignment of work shifts for staff. This is a complex task that has to consider things like employee contracts, required rest periods, and staffing shortages - particularly in healthcare settings like hospitals.

The nurse rostering problem is a prime example of this challenge. Hospitals employ hundreds of nurses, and they need to ensure adequate coverage at all times while also giving nurses their required breaks, especially after night shifts. The COVID-19 pandemic has only made this problem more acute, as healthcare facilities have struggled with staffing shortages. This research aims to help organizations, like hospitals, better manage their workforces and operate more effectively, even in crisis situations.

Technical Explanation

The study's main objective is to develop a foundational framework for addressing personnel scheduling, with a specific focus on the nurse rostering problem in healthcare settings. This challenge is characterized by a multitude of variables, as a single healthcare facility may employ hundreds of nurses, alongside stringent constraints such as the need for adequate staffing levels and rest periods post-night shifts.

The researchers recognize that relying solely on managerial intuition or experience is often insufficient in such complex scenarios, necessitating a quantitative approach. The rise of big data has further exacerbated these challenges, as the scale and complexity of constraints pose significant difficulties for organizational planners.

To tackle this issue, the study proposes a systematic framework for optimizing shift assignments for staff. This involves considering factors such as contractual obligations, mandated rest periods, and the prevalent problem of employee shortages across various industries, including healthcare.

The researchers pay particular attention to the nurse rostering problem, which is characterized by a multitude of variables and stringent constraints, such as the need for adequate staffing levels and rest periods post-night shifts. Furthermore, the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated staffing challenges in healthcare institutions, underscoring the importance of accurately assessing staffing needs and optimizing shift allocations for effective operation amidst crisis situations.

Critical Analysis

The study acknowledges the complexity of the personnel scheduling problem, particularly in the context of healthcare settings. By focusing on the nurse rostering problem, the researchers recognize the unique challenges faced by hospitals and other healthcare institutions, such as the need for adequate staffing levels and strict regulations around employee rest periods.

While the study proposes a foundational framework for addressing these issues, it does not provide a comprehensive solution. The researchers note that the problem is characterized by a multitude of variables and stringent constraints, which may require further exploration and refinement of the proposed approach.

Additionally, the study does not delve into the potential limitations or caveats of the framework, such as its applicability to different organizational contexts or its susceptibility to unforeseen disruptions, like the COVID-19 pandemic. A more in-depth discussion of these aspects could help readers assess the real-world feasibility and scalability of the proposed solution.

Conclusion

This study aims to provide a foundational framework for addressing personnel scheduling, with a particular focus on the nurse rostering problem in healthcare settings. The researchers recognize the growing complexity of organizational challenges, driven by the rise of big data and the prevalence of staffing shortages across various industries.

By proposing a quantitative approach to shift assignment optimization, the study seeks to help managers overcome the limitations of intuition and experience-based decision-making. The focus on the nurse rostering problem highlights the unique challenges faced by healthcare institutions, such as the need for adequate staffing levels and strict regulations around employee rest periods.

While the study offers a promising starting point, further research and refinement may be necessary to ensure the framework's widespread applicability and effectiveness in addressing personnel scheduling challenges across diverse organizational contexts.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🎯

Optimizing Nurse Scheduling: A Supply Chain Approach for Healthcare Institutions

Jubin Thomas

When managing an organization, planners often encounter numerous challenging scenarios. In such instances, relying solely on intuition or managerial experience may not suffice, necessitating a quantitative approach. This demand is further accentuated in the era of big data, where the sheer scale and complexity of constraints pose significant challenges. Therefore, the aim of this study is to provide a foundational framework for addressing personnel scheduling, a critical issue in organizational management. Specifically, we focus on optimizing shift assignments for staff, a task fraught with complexities due to factors such as contractual obligations and mandated rest periods. Moreover, the current landscape is characterized by frequent employee shortages across various industries, with many organizations lacking efficient and dependable management tools to address them. Therefore, our attention is particularly drawn to the nurse rostering problem, a personnel scheduling challenge prevalent in healthcare settings. These issues are characterized by a multitude of variables, given that a single healthcare facility may employ hundreds of nurses, alongside stringent constraints such as the need for adequate staffing levels and rest periods postnight shifts. Furthermore, the ongoing COVID19 pandemic has exacerbated staffing challenges in healthcare institutions, underlining the importance of accurately assessing staffing needs and optimizing shift allocations for effective operation amidst crisis situations.

7/17/2024

Machine Learning and Constraint Programming for Efficient Healthcare Scheduling

Aymen Ben Said, Malek Mouhoub

Solving combinatorial optimization problems involve satisfying a set of hard constraints while optimizing some objectives. In this context, exact or approximate methods can be used. While exact methods guarantee the optimal solution, they often come with an exponential running time as opposed to approximate methods that trade the solutions quality for a better running time. In this context, we tackle the Nurse Scheduling Problem (NSP). The NSP consist in assigning nurses to daily shifts within a planning horizon such that workload constraints are satisfied while hospitals costs and nurses preferences are optimized. To solve the NSP, we propose implicit and explicit approaches. In the implicit solving approach, we rely on Machine Learning methods using historical data to learn and generate new solutions through the constraints and objectives that may be embedded in the learned patterns. To quantify the quality of using our implicit approach in capturing the embedded constraints and objectives, we rely on the Frobenius Norm, a quality measure used to compute the average error between the generated solutions and historical data. To compensate for the uncertainty related to the implicit approach given that the constraints and objectives may not be concretely visible in the produced solutions, we propose an alternative explicit approach where we first model the NSP using the Constraint Satisfaction Problem (CSP) framework. Then we develop Stochastic Local Search methods and a new Branch and Bound algorithm enhanced with constraint propagation techniques and variables/values ordering heuristics. Since our implicit approach may not guarantee the feasibility or optimality of the generated solution, we propose a data-driven approach to passively learn the NSP as a constraint network. The learned constraint network, formulated as a CSP, will then be solved using the methods we listed earlier.

9/14/2024

Optimal Hospital Capacity Management During Demand Surges

Felix Parker, Fardin Ganjkhanloo, Diego A. Mart'inez, Kimia Ghobadi

Effective hospital capacity management is pivotal for enhancing patient care quality, operational efficiency, and healthcare system resilience, notably during demand spikes like those seen in the COVID-19 pandemic. However, devising optimal capacity strategies is complicated by fluctuating demand, conflicting objectives, and multifaceted practical constraints. This study presents a data-driven framework to optimize capacity management decisions within hospital systems during surge events. Two key decisions are optimized over a tactical planning horizon: allocating dedicated capacity to surge patients and transferring incoming patients between emergency departments (EDs) of hospitals to better distribute demand. The optimization models are formulated as robust mixed-integer linear programs, enabling efficient computation of optimal decisions that are robust against demand uncertainty. The models incorporate practical constraints and costs, including setup times and costs for adding surge capacity, restrictions on ED patient transfers, and relative costs of different decisions that reflect impacts on care quality and operational efficiency. The methodology is evaluated retrospectively in a hospital system during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic to demonstrate the potential impact of the recommended decisions. The results show that optimally allocating beds and transferring just 32 patients over a 63 day period around the peak, about one transfer every two days, could have reduced the need for surge capacity in the hospital system by nearly 90%. Overall, this work introduces a practical tool to transform capacity management decision-making, enabling proactive planning and the use of data-driven recommendations to improve outcomes.

4/1/2024

Robust personnel rostering: how accurate should absenteeism predictions be?

Martina Doneda, Pieter Smet, Giuliana Carello, Ettore Lanzarone, Greet Vanden Berghe

Disruptions to personnel rosters caused by absenteeism often necessitate last-minute adjustments to the employees' working hours. A common strategy to mitigate the impact of such changes is to assign employees to reserve shifts: special on-call duties during which an employee can be called in to cover for an absent employee. To maximize roster robustness, we assume a predict-then-optimize approach that uses absence predictions from a machine learning model to schedule an adequate number of reserve shifts. In this paper we propose a methodology to evaluate the robustness of rosters generated by the predict-then-optimize approach, assuming the machine learning model will make predictions at a predetermined prediction performance level. Instead of training and testing machine learning models, our methodology simulates the predictions based on a characterization of model performance. We show how this methodology can be applied to identify the minimum performance level needed for the model to outperform simple non-data-driven robust rostering policies. In a computational study on a nurse rostering problem, we demonstrate how the predict-then-optimize approach outperforms non-data-driven policies under reasonable performance requirements, particularly when employees possess interchangeable skills.

6/27/2024