Optimizing the Optimal Weighted Average: Efficient Distributed Sparse Classification
2406.01753
0
0
🏷️
Abstract
While distributed training is often viewed as a solution to optimizing linear models on increasingly large datasets, inter-machine communication costs of popular distributed approaches can dominate as data dimensionality increases. Recent work on non-interactive algorithms shows that approximate solutions for linear models can be obtained efficiently with only a single round of communication among machines. However, this approximation often degenerates as the number of machines increases. In this paper, building on the recent optimal weighted average method, we introduce a new technique, ACOWA, that allows an extra round of communication to achieve noticeably better approximation quality with minor runtime increases. Results show that for sparse distributed logistic regression, ACOWA obtains solutions that are more faithful to the empirical risk minimizer and attain substantially higher accuracy than other distributed algorithms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Distributed training is often used to optimize linear models on large datasets, but inter-machine communication costs can dominate as data dimensionality increases.
- Recent work on non-interactive algorithms shows that approximate solutions for linear models can be obtained efficiently with only a single round of communication.
- However, this approximation can degrade as the number of machines increases.
- This paper introduces a new technique called ACOWA that allows an extra round of communication to achieve better approximation quality with minor runtime increases.
Plain English Explanation
Building machine learning models on large datasets can be a challenge, especially as the complexity of the data grows. One approach that researchers have explored is distributed training, where the dataset is split across multiple machines and the model is trained in parallel.
While distributed training can be effective, the cost of communication between machines can become a problem, particularly as the dimensionality of the data increases. Recent work has shown that it's possible to get approximate solutions for linear models using just a single round of communication between machines. This is an efficient approach, but the quality of the approximation can suffer as more machines are added to the system.
The paper introduces a new technique called ACOWA that allows for an extra round of communication to get better approximation quality, with only a minor increase in runtime. The key idea is to leverage the optimal weighted average method and build on it to achieve higher accuracy, especially for sparse distributed logistic regression problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new algorithm called ACOWA (Approximate Consensus-based Optimal Weighted Average) that builds on the recent optimal weighted average method. ACOWA allows for an extra round of communication among machines to achieve noticeably better approximation quality compared to other distributed algorithms, with only a minor increase in runtime.
The authors evaluate ACOWA on sparse distributed logistic regression tasks and show that it obtains solutions that are more faithful to the empirical risk minimizer and achieve substantially higher accuracy than other distributed approaches, such as FedAvg and WASH.
The key insight behind ACOWA is that by allowing an extra round of communication, the algorithm can better capture the underlying structure of the data and produce more accurate approximations of the optimal solution, even as the number of machines increases. This is particularly important for high-dimensional datasets, where the communication costs of popular distributed approaches can become a bottleneck.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for improving the quality of approximate solutions in distributed linear model training. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- The experiments are focused on sparse distributed logistic regression, so it's unclear how well ACOWA would perform on other types of linear models or more complex machine learning tasks.
- The paper does not explore the impact of heterogeneous data distributions across machines, which can be a common challenge in distributed systems.
- The authors do not investigate the communication efficiency of ACOWA compared to other distributed algorithms, which could be an important factor in real-world deployments.
- Further research could explore ways to integrate ACOWA with graph-based sampling techniques to improve its scalability and efficiency.
Overall, the ACOWA algorithm presents a novel approach to improving the accuracy of distributed linear model training, and the results are promising. However, additional research is needed to fully understand its strengths, weaknesses, and potential applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new technique called ACOWA that builds on the optimal weighted average method to achieve better approximation quality in distributed linear model training, with only a minor increase in runtime. The results show that ACOWA can obtain solutions that are more faithful to the empirical risk minimizer and achieve substantially higher accuracy than other distributed algorithms, particularly for sparse distributed logistic regression problems.
While the paper focuses on a specific use case, the ACOWA approach could have broader implications for improving the efficiency and scalability of distributed machine learning systems, especially as the complexity and dimensionality of datasets continue to grow. Further research is needed to explore the wider applicability of this technique and address potential limitations, but the work represents an important step forward in addressing the challenges of distributed training for linear models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
Federated Learning Model Aggregation in Heterogenous Aerial and Space Networks
Fan Dong, Ali Abbasi, Steve Drew, Henry Leung, Xin Wang, Jiayu Zhou
0
0
Federated learning offers a promising approach under the constraints of networking and data privacy constraints in aerial and space networks (ASNs), utilizing large-scale private edge data from drones, balloons, and satellites. Existing research has extensively studied the optimization of the learning process, computing efficiency, and communication overhead. An important yet often overlooked aspect is that participants contribute predictive knowledge with varying diversity of knowledge, affecting the quality of the learned federated models. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to address this issue by introducing a Weighted Averaging and Client Selection (WeiAvgCS) framework that emphasizes updates from high-diversity clients and diminishes the influence of those from low-diversity clients. Direct sharing of the data distribution may be prohibitive due to the additional private information that is sent from the clients. As such, we introduce an estimation for the diversity using a projection-based method. Extensive experiments have been performed to show WeiAvgCS's effectiveness. WeiAvgCS could converge 46% faster on FashionMNIST and 38% faster on CIFAR10 than its benchmarks on average in our experiments.
4/11/2024
🌿
WASH: Train your Ensemble with Communication-Efficient Weight Shuffling, then Average
Louis Fournier (MLIA), Adel Nabli (MLIA, Mila), Masih Aminbeidokhti (ETS), Marco Pedersoli (ETS), Eugene Belilovsky (Mila), Edouard Oyallon
0
0
The performance of deep neural networks is enhanced by ensemble methods, which average the output of several models. However, this comes at an increased cost at inference. Weight averaging methods aim at balancing the generalization of ensembling and the inference speed of a single model by averaging the parameters of an ensemble of models. Yet, naive averaging results in poor performance as models converge to different loss basins, and aligning the models to improve the performance of the average is challenging. Alternatively, inspired by distributed training, methods like DART and PAPA have been proposed to train several models in parallel such that they will end up in the same basin, resulting in good averaging accuracy. However, these methods either compromise ensembling accuracy or demand significant communication between models during training. In this paper, we introduce WASH, a novel distributed method for training model ensembles for weight averaging that achieves state-of-the-art image classification accuracy. WASH maintains models within the same basin by randomly shuffling a small percentage of weights during training, resulting in diverse models and lower communication costs compared to standard parameter averaging methods.
5/29/2024
🐍
Adaptive Stochastic Weight Averaging
Caglar Demir, Arnab Sharma, Axel-Cyrille Ngonga Ngomo
0
0
Ensemble models often improve generalization performances in challenging tasks. Yet, traditional techniques based on prediction averaging incur three well-known disadvantages: the computational overhead of training multiple models, increased latency, and memory requirements at test time. To address these issues, the Stochastic Weight Averaging (SWA) technique maintains a running average of model parameters from a specific epoch onward. Despite its potential benefits, maintaining a running average of parameters can hinder generalization, as an underlying running model begins to overfit. Conversely, an inadequately chosen starting point can render SWA more susceptible to underfitting compared to an underlying running model. In this work, we propose Adaptive Stochastic Weight Averaging (ASWA) technique that updates a running average of model parameters, only when generalization performance is improved on the validation dataset. Hence, ASWA can be seen as a combination of SWA with the early stopping technique, where the former accepts all updates on a parameter ensemble model and the latter rejects any update on an underlying running model. We conducted extensive experiments ranging from image classification to multi-hop reasoning over knowledge graphs. Our experiments over 11 benchmark datasets with 7 baseline models suggest that ASWA leads to a statistically better generalization across models and datasets
6/28/2024
Regularizing and Aggregating Clients with Class Distribution for Personalized Federated Learning
Gyuejeong Lee, Daeyoung Choi
0
0
Personalized federated learning (PFL) enables customized models for clients with varying data distributions. However, existing PFL methods often incur high computational and communication costs, limiting their practical application. This paper proposes a novel PFL method, Class-wise Federated Averaging (cwFedAVG), that performs Federated Averaging (FedAVG) class-wise, creating multiple global models per class on the server. Each local model integrates these global models weighted by its estimated local class distribution, derived from the L2-norms of deep network weights, avoiding privacy violations. Afterward, each global model does the same with local models using the same method. We also newly designed Weight Distribution Regularizer (WDR) to further enhance the accuracy of estimating a local class distribution by minimizing the Euclidean distance between the class distribution and the weight norms' distribution. Experimental results demonstrate that cwFedAVG matches or outperforms several existing PFL methods. Notably, cwFedAVG is conceptually simple yet computationally efficient as it mitigates the need for extensive calculation to collaborate between clients by leveraging shared global models. Visualizations provide insights into how cwFedAVG enables local model specialization on respective class distributions while global models capture class-relevant information across clients.
6/13/2024