Out-of-Domain Generalization in Dynamical Systems Reconstruction
2402.18377
0
0
🏋️
Abstract
In science we are interested in finding the governing equations, the dynamical rules, underlying empirical phenomena. While traditionally scientific models are derived through cycles of human insight and experimentation, recently deep learning (DL) techniques have been advanced to reconstruct dynamical systems (DS) directly from time series data. State-of-the-art dynamical systems reconstruction (DSR) methods show promise in capturing invariant and long-term properties of observed DS, but their ability to generalize to unobserved domains remains an open challenge. Yet, this is a crucial property we would expect from any viable scientific theory. In this work, we provide a formal framework that addresses generalization in DSR. We explain why and how out-of-domain (OOD) generalization (OODG) in DSR profoundly differs from OODG considered elsewhere in machine learning. We introduce mathematical notions based on topological concepts and ergodic theory to formalize the idea of learnability of a DSR model. We formally prove that black-box DL techniques, without adequate structural priors, generally will not be able to learn a generalizing DSR model. We also show this empirically, considering major classes of DSR algorithms proposed so far, and illustrate where and why they fail to generalize across the whole phase space. Our study provides the first comprehensive mathematical treatment of OODG in DSR, and gives a deeper conceptual understanding of where the fundamental problems in OODG lie and how they could possibly be addressed in practice.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the challenge of generalizing dynamical systems reconstruction (DSR) models to unobserved domains.
- Traditional scientific models are derived through human insight and experimentation, but deep learning techniques have recently been used to reconstruct dynamical systems directly from time series data.
- While state-of-the-art DSR methods can capture important properties of observed systems, their ability to generalize to new, unobserved domains remains an open challenge.
- The authors provide a formal framework to address the issue of out-of-domain (OOD) generalization in DSR, which they argue is fundamentally different from OOD generalization in other machine learning tasks.
Plain English Explanation
Scientists are interested in discovering the underlying mathematical equations and rules that govern the behavior of observed phenomena in the real world. Traditionally, these scientific models have been developed through a cycle of human insight and experimentation.
However, a new approach using deep learning techniques has emerged, where computers can directly reconstruct these dynamical systems from time series data. The resulting models have shown promising results in capturing important long-term properties of the observed systems.
But a key challenge remains: can these dynamical systems reconstruction (DSR) models generalize to new, unobserved domains? This is a crucial requirement for any scientific theory to be viable and useful. The authors argue that out-of-domain generalization in DSR is fundamentally different from other machine learning tasks, and they provide a formal framework to address this challenge.
Technical Explanation
The authors introduce mathematical concepts based on topology and ergodic theory to formalize the idea of "learnability" of a DSR model. They formally prove that black-box deep learning techniques, without adequate structural priors, generally will not be able to learn a DSR model that can generalize to unobserved domains.
The authors also empirically demonstrate this by evaluating major classes of DSR algorithms proposed so far, and illustrate where and why they fail to generalize across the entire phase space of the dynamical system. This study provides the first comprehensive mathematical treatment of out-of-domain generalization in DSR and offers a deeper understanding of the fundamental problems in this area.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical and empirical analysis of the challenges in achieving out-of-domain generalization in dynamical systems reconstruction. The authors make a compelling case that this problem is fundamentally different from OOD generalization in other machine learning tasks, and that traditional deep learning techniques are unlikely to solve it without incorporating appropriate structural priors.
However, the paper does not provide a clear solution or pathway to address these challenges. The authors mention that incorporating relevant prior knowledge, such as learning governing equations from unobserved states, may be a promising direction, but more research is needed to develop practical algorithms that can reliably generalize DSR models to new, unobserved domains.
Conclusion
This paper highlights a critical challenge in the field of dynamical systems reconstruction, where state-of-the-art deep learning techniques have shown promising results but struggle to generalize to new, unobserved domains. The authors provide a formal mathematical framework to understand the nature of this problem and demonstrate why traditional deep learning approaches may not be sufficient.
The insights and analysis presented in this work can help guide future research in discovering and expanding new domains within dynamical systems reconstruction, with the ultimate goal of developing scientific theories that can accurately predict and explain real-world phenomena.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Non-stationary Domain Generalization: Theory and Algorithm
Thai-Hoang Pham, Xueru Zhang, Ping Zhang
0
0
Although recent advances in machine learning have shown its success to learn from independent and identically distributed (IID) data, it is vulnerable to out-of-distribution (OOD) data in an open world. Domain generalization (DG) deals with such an issue and it aims to learn a model from multiple source domains that can be generalized to unseen target domains. Existing studies on DG have largely focused on stationary settings with homogeneous source domains. However, in many applications, domains may evolve along a specific direction (e.g., time, space). Without accounting for such non-stationary patterns, models trained with existing methods may fail to generalize on OOD data. In this paper, we study domain generalization in non-stationary environment. We first examine the impact of environmental non-stationarity on model performance and establish the theoretical upper bounds for the model error at target domains. Then, we propose a novel algorithm based on adaptive invariant representation learning, which leverages the non-stationary pattern to train a model that attains good performance on target domains. Experiments on both synthetic and real data validate the proposed algorithm.
5/14/2024
🛸
Learning Governing Equations of Unobserved States in Dynamical Systems
Gevik Grigorian, Sandip V. George, Simon Arridge
0
0
Data-driven modelling and scientific machine learning have been responsible for significant advances in determining suitable models to describe data. Within dynamical systems, neural ordinary differential equations (ODEs), where the system equations are set to be governed by a neural network, have become a popular tool for this challenge in recent years. However, less emphasis has been placed on systems that are only partially-observed. In this work, we employ a hybrid neural ODE structure, where the system equations are governed by a combination of a neural network and domain-specific knowledge, together with symbolic regression (SR), to learn governing equations of partially-observed dynamical systems. We test this approach on two case studies: A 3-dimensional model of the Lotka-Volterra system and a 5-dimensional model of the Lorenz system. We demonstrate that the method is capable of successfully learning the true underlying governing equations of unobserved states within these systems, with robustness to measurement noise.
5/8/2024
Learning Deep Dynamical Systems using Stable Neural ODEs
Andreas Sochopoulos, Michael Gienger, Sethu Vijayakumar
0
0
Learning complex trajectories from demonstrations in robotic tasks has been effectively addressed through the utilization of Dynamical Systems (DS). State-of-the-art DS learning methods ensure stability of the generated trajectories; however, they have three shortcomings: a) the DS is assumed to have a single attractor, which limits the diversity of tasks it can achieve, b) state derivative information is assumed to be available in the learning process and c) the state of the DS is assumed to be measurable at inference time. We propose a class of provably stable latent DS with possibly multiple attractors, that inherit the training methods of Neural Ordinary Differential Equations, thus, dropping the dependency on state derivative information. A diffeomorphic mapping for the output and a loss that captures time-invariant trajectory similarity are proposed. We validate the efficacy of our approach through experiments conducted on a public dataset of handwritten shapes and within a simulated object manipulation task.
4/17/2024
🤿
Verifying the Generalization of Deep Learning to Out-of-Distribution Domains
Guy Amir, Osher Maayan, Tom Zelazny, Guy Katz, Michael Schapira
0
0
Deep neural networks (DNNs) play a crucial role in the field of machine learning, demonstrating state-of-the-art performance across various application domains. However, despite their success, DNN-based models may occasionally exhibit challenges with generalization, i.e., may fail to handle inputs that were not encountered during training. This limitation is a significant challenge when it comes to deploying deep learning for safety-critical tasks, as well as in real-world settings characterized by substantial variability. We introduce a novel approach for harnessing DNN verification technology to identify DNN-driven decision rules that exhibit robust generalization to previously unencountered input domains. Our method assesses generalization within an input domain by measuring the level of agreement between independently trained deep neural networks for inputs in this domain. We also efficiently realize our approach by using off-the-shelf DNN verification engines, and extensively evaluate it on both supervised and unsupervised DNN benchmarks, including a deep reinforcement learning (DRL) system for Internet congestion control -- demonstrating the applicability of our approach for real-world settings. Moreover, our research introduces a fresh objective for formal verification, offering the prospect of mitigating the challenges linked to deploying DNN-driven systems in real-world scenarios.
6/10/2024