Outlier-Robust Geometric Perception: A Novel Thresholding-Based Estimator with Intra-Class Variance Maximization
0
🗣️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Geometric perception problems are fundamental tasks in robotics and computer vision
- Real-world applications often encounter the issue of outliers, preventing traditional algorithms from making correct estimates
- This paper presents a novel robust estimator called TIVM (Thresholding with Intra-class Variance Maximization) that can efficiently reject outliers for geometric perception problems
Plain English Explanation
Robots and computer vision systems often need to solve geometric perception problems, like determining the position and orientation of an object or aligning 3D point clouds. In real-world situations, these tasks can be complicated by the presence of "outliers" - data points that don't fit the overall pattern. Traditional algorithms struggle to handle these outliers, leading to inaccurate results.
The researchers developed a new approach called TIVM that can effectively remove outliers and allow the standard geometric perception algorithms to work properly. TIVM uses a technique called "intra-class variance maximization" to dynamically separate the data into two groups - inliers and outliers. It then iteratively refines the model, focusing on the inlier group using a multi-layered thresholding strategy. This allows TIVM to converge quickly, often in just 3-15 iterations, and remain robust even when the characteristics of the inlier data are unknown.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the TIVM (Thresholding with Intra-class Variance Maximization) estimator, which can be used alongside standard geometric perception algorithms to handle outliers efficiently.
First, TIVM employs intra-class variance maximization to design a dynamic 2-group thresholding method on the measurement residuals. This aims to clearly distinguish the inlier and outlier data points. Then, TIVM uses an iterative framework to robustly optimize the model, approaching the pure-inlier group using a multi-layered dynamic thresholding strategy as a subroutine. A self-adaptive mechanism for tuning the number of layers is also included to minimize the user-defined parameters.
The researchers validate TIVM on three classic geometric perception problems: rotation averaging, point cloud registration, and category-level perception. Experiments show that TIVM is robust against 70-90% of outliers and can converge much faster than state-of-the-art robust solvers like RANSAC, GNC, and ADAPT - typically in just 3-15 iterations. Importantly, TIVM can retain its high level of robustness even when the statistics of the inlier noise are unknown.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of TIVM's performance on several challenging geometric perception problems. The results demonstrate impressive robustness to high levels of outliers and fast convergence, which could be transformative for real-world applications in robotics and computer vision.
However, the authors do not delve deeply into the underlying reasons for TIVM's superior performance compared to other robust estimators. It would be helpful to have a more detailed theoretical analysis of the method's strengths and limitations. Additionally, the paper does not address potential edge cases or failure modes that could arise in practical deployments.
Further research could also explore the scalability of TIVM to large-scale 3D registration problems and investigate ways to make the layer-number tuning process more automated and adaptive. Rigorous benchmarking against a wider range of robust estimators would also strengthen the claims about TIVM's superiority.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel robust estimator called TIVM that can effectively handle outliers in geometric perception problems, a critical challenge in real-world robotics and computer vision applications. TIVM's combination of intra-class variance maximization and multi-layered dynamic thresholding allows it to converge quickly and maintain high robustness, even when the underlying statistics of the data are unknown.
The promising results demonstrated in this work could have significant implications for improving the reliability and performance of a wide range of geometric perception tasks, from object pose estimation to 3D scene understanding. Further research to explore TIVM's theoretical foundations and expand its capabilities could lead to important advancements in the field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🗣️
0
Outlier-Robust Geometric Perception: A Novel Thresholding-Based Estimator with Intra-Class Variance Maximization
Lei Sun
Geometric perception problems are fundamental tasks in robotics and computer vision. In real-world applications, they often encounter the inevitable issue of outliers, preventing traditional algorithms from making correct estimates. In this paper, we present a novel general-purpose robust estimator TIVM (Thresholding with Intra-class Variance Maximization) that can collaborate with standard non-minimal solvers to efficiently reject outliers for geometric perception problems. First, we introduce the technique of intra-class variance maximization to design a dynamic 2-group thresholding method on the measurement residuals, aiming to distinctively separate inliers from outliers. Then, we develop an iterative framework that robustly optimizes the model by approaching the pure-inlier group using a multi-layered dynamic thresholding strategy as subroutine, in which a self-adaptive mechanism for layer-number tuning is further employed to minimize the user-defined parameters. We validate the proposed estimator on 3 classic geometric perception problems: rotation averaging, point cloud registration and category-level perception, and experiments show that it is robust against 70--90% of outliers and can converge typically in only 3--15 iterations, much faster than state-of-the-art robust solvers such as RANSAC, GNC and ADAPT. Furthermore, another highlight is that: our estimator can retain approximately the same level of robustness even when the inlier-noise statistics of the problem are fully unknown.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Rethinking Unsupervised Outlier Detection via Multiple Thresholding
Zhonghang Liu, Panzhong Lu, Guoyang Xie, Zhichao Lu, Wen-Yan Lin
In the realm of unsupervised image outlier detection, assigning outlier scores holds greater significance than its subsequent task: thresholding for predicting labels. This is because determining the optimal threshold on non-separable outlier score functions is an ill-posed problem. However, the lack of predicted labels not only hiders some real applications of current outlier detectors but also causes these methods not to be enhanced by leveraging the dataset's self-supervision. To advance existing scoring methods, we propose a multiple thresholding (Multi-T) module. It generates two thresholds that isolate inliers and outliers from the unlabelled target dataset, whereas outliers are employed to obtain better feature representation while inliers provide an uncontaminated manifold. Extensive experiments verify that Multi-T can significantly improve proposed outlier scoring methods. Moreover, Multi-T contributes to a naive distance-based method being state-of-the-art.
Read more7/16/2024
🏋️
0
Quantile-based Maximum Likelihood Training for Outlier Detection
Masoud Taghikhah, Nishant Kumar, Siniv{s}a v{S}egvi'c, Abouzar Eslami, Stefan Gumhold
Discriminative learning effectively predicts true object class for image classification. However, it often results in false positives for outliers, posing critical concerns in applications like autonomous driving and video surveillance systems. Previous attempts to address this challenge involved training image classifiers through contrastive learning using actual outlier data or synthesizing outliers for self-supervised learning. Furthermore, unsupervised generative modeling of inliers in pixel space has shown limited success for outlier detection. In this work, we introduce a quantile-based maximum likelihood objective for learning the inlier distribution to improve the outlier separation during inference. Our approach fits a normalizing flow to pre-trained discriminative features and detects the outliers according to the evaluated log-likelihood. The experimental evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of our method as it surpasses the performance of the state-of-the-art unsupervised methods for outlier detection. The results are also competitive compared with a recent self-supervised approach for outlier detection. Our work allows to reduce dependency on well-sampled negative training data, which is especially important for domains like medical diagnostics or remote sensing.
Read more6/4/2024
🗣️
0
Robust Single Rotation Averaging Revisited
Seong Hun Lee, Javier Civera
In this work, we propose a novel method for robust single rotation averaging that can efficiently handle an extremely large fraction of outliers. Our approach is to minimize the total truncated least unsquared deviations (TLUD) cost of geodesic distances. The proposed algorithm consists of three steps: First, we consider each input rotation as a potential initial solution and choose the one that yields the least sum of truncated chordal deviations. Next, we obtain the inlier set using the initial solution and compute its chordal $L_2$-mean. Finally, starting from this estimate, we iteratively compute the geodesic $L_1$-mean of the inliers using the Weiszfeld algorithm on $SO(3)$. An extensive evaluation shows that our method is robust against up to 99% outliers given a sufficient number of accurate inliers, outperforming the current state of the art.
Read more9/11/2024