Paired Autoencoders for Inverse Problems

Read original: arXiv:2405.13220 - Published 5/24/2024 by Matthias Chung, Emma Hart, Julianne Chung, Bas Peters, Eldad Haber

📉

Overview

This paper addresses the challenge of solving nonlinear inverse problems, where the goal is to estimate unknown parameters from observed data.
Nonlinear inverse problems are notoriously difficult to solve in practice, as they require minimizing a combination of a data-fit term and a regularization term.
The main computational bottleneck of typical algorithms is the direct estimation of the data misfit, leading to the exploration of likelihood-free approaches.
However, these likelihood-free approaches have faced difficulties in generalization and limitations in accuracy, hindering their broader utility and applicability.

Plain English Explanation

In this paper, the researchers are tackling a challenging problem in science and engineering called "nonlinear inverse problems." Imagine you have a machine or system that takes in some input and produces an output. The inverse problem is trying to figure out what the input was, given the output. This is often very difficult to do, especially when the relationship between the input and output is complex and nonlinear.

The researchers propose using a special type of artificial intelligence called a "paired autoencoder" as a solution. An autoencoder is a neural network that can learn to compress and decompress data, effectively learning a simplified representation of the original data. By pairing two of these autoencoders together, the researchers show that they can efficiently estimate the unknown input parameters from the observed output data, without needing to explicitly model the complex relationship between them.

This approach helps overcome some of the limitations of other likelihood-free estimation methods, which have struggled with generalization and accuracy. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their paired autoencoder framework on two challenging inverse problems: full waveform inversion and inverse electromagnetic imaging.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on solving nonlinear inverse problems, where the forward problem is a discretization of a partial differential equation. These types of problems are notoriously difficult to solve in practice, as they require minimizing a combination of a data-fit term and a regularization term.

The authors propose using a paired autoencoder framework as a likelihood-free estimator for these inverse problems. The key idea is to train two autoencoder neural networks in a paired configuration, where one network maps the observed data to the unknown parameters, and the other network maps the unknown parameters back to the observed data.

This architecture allows the researchers to construct a solution efficiently and to overcome some known open problems when using likelihood-free estimators, such as difficulties in generalization and limitations in accuracy. Importantly, the framework can also assess the quality of the solution and improve on it if needed.

The authors demonstrate the viability of their approach using examples from full waveform inversion and inverse electromagnetic imaging, two challenging inverse problems in science and engineering.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to addressing the difficulties associated with solving nonlinear inverse problems, particularly the computational bottleneck of directly estimating the data misfit. The paired autoencoder framework appears to offer a more efficient and robust solution compared to traditional likelihood-free methods.

However, the paper does not discuss the potential limitations or caveats of the proposed approach. For example, it would be valuable to understand the computational complexity of training the paired autoencoders, the sensitivity of the method to hyperparameter tuning, and the generalization capabilities of the trained models to unseen data.

Additionally, the authors could have provided more insight into the choice of the specific neural network architectures and training procedures used, as these design decisions can significantly impact the performance of the method.

Furthermore, the paper does not compare the paired autoencoder framework to other state-of-the-art approaches, such as generative modeling for sparse approximate inverse preconditioning or other neural network-based techniques for inverse problems. Such a comparative analysis would help readers better understand the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed method.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to solving nonlinear inverse problems using a paired autoencoder framework. The key idea is to leverage the compression and decompression capabilities of autoencoders to efficiently estimate unknown parameters from observed data, without the need for explicit modeling of the complex forward problem.

The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on two challenging inverse problems, full waveform inversion and inverse electromagnetic imaging. This work represents an important step forward in addressing the computational challenges associated with nonlinear inverse problems, which have far-reaching applications in various scientific and engineering domains.

While the paper shows promising results, further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and generalization capabilities of the paired autoencoder framework. Comparative studies with other state-of-the-art methods and a more in-depth analysis of the design choices and their impact on performance would help strengthen the contribution of this work.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📉

Paired Autoencoders for Inverse Problems

Matthias Chung, Emma Hart, Julianne Chung, Bas Peters, Eldad Haber

We consider the solution of nonlinear inverse problems where the forward problem is a discretization of a partial differential equation. Such problems are notoriously difficult to solve in practice and require minimizing a combination of a data-fit term and a regularization term. The main computational bottleneck of typical algorithms is the direct estimation of the data misfit. Therefore, likelihood-free approaches have become appealing alternatives. Nonetheless, difficulties in generalization and limitations in accuracy have hindered their broader utility and applicability. In this work, we use a paired autoencoder framework as a likelihood-free estimator for inverse problems. We show that the use of such an architecture allows us to construct a solution efficiently and to overcome some known open problems when using likelihood-free estimators. In particular, our framework can assess the quality of the solution and improve on it if needed. We demonstrate the viability of our approach using examples from full waveform inversion and inverse electromagnetic imaging.

5/24/2024

Inverse Problems with Diffusion Models: A MAP Estimation Perspective

Sai Bharath Chandra Gutha, Ricardo Vinuesa, Hossein Azizpour

Inverse problems have many applications in science and engineering. In Computer vision, several image restoration tasks such as inpainting, deblurring, and super-resolution can be formally modeled as inverse problems. Recently, methods have been developed for solving inverse problems that only leverage a pre-trained unconditional diffusion model and do not require additional task-specific training. In such methods, however, the inherent intractability of determining the conditional score function during the reverse diffusion process poses a real challenge, leaving the methods to settle with an approximation instead, which affects their performance in practice. Here, we propose a MAP estimation framework to model the reverse conditional generation process of a continuous time diffusion model as an optimization process of the underlying MAP objective, whose gradient term is tractable. In theory, the proposed framework can be applied to solve general inverse problems using gradient-based optimization methods. However, given the highly non-convex nature of the loss objective, finding a perfect gradient-based optimization algorithm can be quite challenging, nevertheless, our framework offers several potential research directions. We use our proposed formulation to develop empirically effective algorithms for image restoration. We validate our proposed algorithms with extensive experiments over multiple datasets across several restoration tasks.

9/19/2024

Half-VAE: An Encoder-Free VAE to Bypass Explicit Inverse Mapping

Yuan-Hao Wei, Yan-Jie Sun, Chen Zhang

Inference and inverse problems are closely related concepts, both fundamentally involving the deduction of unknown causes or parameters from observed data. Bayesian inference, a powerful class of methods, is often employed to solve a variety of problems, including those related to causal inference. Variational inference, a subset of Bayesian inference, is primarily used to efficiently approximate complex posterior distributions. Variational Autoencoders (VAEs), which combine variational inference with deep learning, have become widely applied across various domains. This study explores the potential of VAEs for solving inverse problems, such as Independent Component Analysis (ICA), without relying on an explicit inverse mapping process. Unlike other VAE-based ICA methods, this approach discards the encoder in the VAE architecture, directly setting the latent variables as trainable parameters. In other words, the latent variables are no longer outputs of the encoder but are instead optimized directly through the objective function to converge to appropriate values. We find that, with a suitable prior setup, the latent variables, represented by trainable parameters, can exhibit mutually independent properties as the parameters converge, all without the need for an encoding process. This approach, referred to as the Half-VAE, bypasses the inverse mapping process by eliminating the encoder. This study demonstrates the feasibility of using the Half-VAE to solve ICA without the need for an explicit inverse mapping process.

9/17/2024

Solving Inverse Problems with Model Mismatch using Untrained Neural Networks within Model-based Architectures

Peimeng Guan, Naveed Iqbal, Mark A. Davenport, Mudassir Masood

Model-based deep learning methods such as loop unrolling (LU) and deep equilibrium model}(DEQ) extensions offer outstanding performance in solving inverse problems (IP). These methods unroll the optimization iterations into a sequence of neural networks that in effect learn a regularization function from data. While these architectures are currently state-of-the-art in numerous applications, their success heavily relies on the accuracy of the forward model. This assumption can be limiting in many physical applications due to model simplifications or uncertainties in the apparatus. To address forward model mismatch, we introduce an untrained forward model residual block within the model-based architecture to match the data consistency in the measurement domain for each instance. We propose two variants in well-known model-based architectures (LU and DEQ) and prove convergence under mild conditions. Our approach offers a unified solution that is less parameter-sensitive, requires no additional data, and enables simultaneous fitting of the forward model and reconstruction in a single pass, benefiting both linear and nonlinear inverse problems. The experiments show significant quality improvement in removing artifacts and preserving details across three distinct applications, encompassing both linear and nonlinear inverse problems. Moreover, we highlight reconstruction effectiveness in intermediate steps and showcase robustness to random initialization of the residual block and a higher number of iterations during evaluation. Code is available at texttt{https://github.com/InvProbs/A-adaptive-model-based-methods}.

6/11/2024