PANDA: Prompt Transfer Meets Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Model Adaptation

Overview

• Prompt Transfer (PoT) is a new approach to improve prompt-tuning, which initializes the target prompt with an existing prompt trained on similar source tasks.
• However, the vanilla PoT approach often leads to suboptimal performance due to issues with prompt similarity and knowledge forgetting.
• The researchers propose a new metric to predict prompt transferability and a novel PoT approach called PANDA that uses knowledge distillation to mitigate knowledge forgetting.

Plain English Explanation

Prompt-tuning is a technique used to fine-tune language models for specific tasks. The key idea behind Prompt Transfer (PoT) is to start with a prompt that has been trained on a similar task, rather than initializing the prompt randomly. This can potentially help the model learn the new task more efficiently.

However, the researchers found that the vanilla PoT approach often doesn't work as well as expected. There are a few reasons for this. First, the success of PoT depends a lot on how similar the source and target tasks are - if they are not very similar, the transferred prompt may not be very useful. Second, when fine-tuning the prompt on the new task, the model can sometimes "forget" some of the useful knowledge it learned from the source task.

To address these issues, the researchers developed a new way to predict how transferable a prompt will be, based on analyzing the prompts and tasks. They also introduced a new PoT approach called PANDA, which uses a technique called knowledge distillation to help the model retain the useful knowledge from the source task, while still learning the new task effectively.

Technical Explanation

The researchers first propose a new metric to predict the transferability of a prompt from a source task to a target task. This metric analyzes the prompts and tasks to estimate how well the source prompt will work for the target task.

They then introduce PANDA, a novel PoT approach that uses knowledge distillation to address the knowledge forgetting issue. PANDA initializes the target prompt with the source prompt, but then fine-tunes it in a way that encourages the model to retain the useful knowledge learned from the source task.

The researchers conducted extensive experiments on 189 combinations of 21 source and 9 target tasks, across 5 different language model scales. They found that:

1. Their proposed transferability metric is effective at predicting how well PoT will work.
2. Their PANDA approach consistently outperforms the vanilla PoT approach, improving the average score by 2.3% (up to 24.1%).
3. With PANDA, prompt-tuning can achieve competitive or even better performance than full model fine-tuning, across different model scales.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough and rigorous evaluation of the proposed PoT approaches. The researchers address important practical issues with the vanilla PoT method and demonstrate clear improvements with their PANDA approach.

One potential limitation is that the experiments were conducted on a relatively limited set of tasks and models. It would be helpful to see how the methods generalize to a wider range of applications and model architectures.

Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the specific mechanisms by which PANDA is able to retain knowledge from the source task. Further analysis of the internal workings of the method could help build a deeper understanding of how and why it is effective.

Overall, this research represents a significant advance in prompt-tuning techniques and could have important implications for improving the efficiency and performance of language models in a wide range of applications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a new metric for predicting prompt transferability and a novel PoT approach called PANDA that uses knowledge distillation to address the issue of knowledge forgetting. Through extensive experiments, the researchers demonstrate that PANDA consistently outperforms the vanilla PoT approach and can even match or exceed the performance of full model fine-tuning in certain scenarios.

These findings have important implications for making language models more efficient and accessible, by allowing them to be fine-tuned on new tasks more effectively using prompt-based techniques. The proposed methods could potentially lead to significant improvements in the applicability and real-world impact of large language models.