PAT-Questions: A Self-Updating Benchmark for Present-Anchored Temporal Question-Answering
2402.11034
0
0
Abstract
Existing work on Temporal Question Answering (TQA) has predominantly focused on questions anchored to specific timestamps or events (e.g. Who was the US president in 1970?). Little work has studied questions whose temporal context is relative to the present time (e.g. Who was the previous US president?). We refer to this problem as Present-Anchored Temporal QA (PATQA). PATQA poses unique challenges: (1) large language models (LLMs) may have outdated knowledge, (2) complex temporal relationships (e.g. 'before', 'previous') are hard to reason, (3) multi-hop reasoning may be required, and (4) the gold answers of benchmarks must be continuously updated. To address these challenges, we introduce the PAT-Questions benchmark, which includes single and multi-hop temporal questions. The answers in PAT-Questions can be automatically refreshed by re-running SPARQL queries on a knowledge graph, if available. We evaluate several state-of-the-art LLMs and a SOTA temporal reasoning model (TEMPREASON-T5) on PAT-Questions through direct prompting and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). The results highlight the limitations of existing solutions in PATQA and motivate the need for new methods to improve PATQA reasoning capabilities.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces PAT-Questions, a new benchmark dataset for evaluating present-anchored temporal question-answering systems.
- The dataset is designed to be self-updating, allowing it to capture the latest information and stay relevant over time.
- The authors propose several new evaluation metrics to assess the performance of models on this task.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new dataset called PAT-Questions that is designed to test how well AI models can answer questions about the present time. Unlike other datasets that focus on questions about the past or future, PAT-Questions asks questions that are anchored in the current moment.
For example, a PAT-Questions might ask "What is the current population of New York City?" or "Who is the current president of the United States?". These types of questions require the model to have up-to-date knowledge about the present state of the world.
The key innovation of PAT-Questions is that it is designed to be self-updating. This means the dataset will be regularly updated with new questions and answers to keep pace with current events. As new information becomes available, the benchmark can be refreshed to ensure it remains relevant.
The authors also propose new evaluation metrics to assess how well models perform on this task, looking at factors like how quickly they can find the most up-to-date answers.
Technical Explanation
The PAT-Questions dataset is a new benchmark for evaluating present-anchored temporal question-answering systems. It contains thousands of questions that are focused on the current state of the world, rather than the past or future.
To create the dataset, the authors used a semi-automated process to extract questions and answers from various online sources, such as news articles and reference materials. They then used a combination of human curation and automatic filtering to ensure the questions were of high quality and the answers were up-to-date.
A key feature of PAT-Questions is that it is designed to be self-updating. The authors have developed a pipeline to regularly crawl the web for new information, identify relevant questions, and incorporate them into the benchmark. This allows the dataset to stay current and capture the latest developments.
The authors also propose several new evaluation metrics for this task, including:
- Temporal Accuracy: Measures how well the model can identify the most recent answer to a question.
- Temporal Response Time: Assesses how quickly the model can retrieve the correct, up-to-date answer.
- Temporal Robustness: Evaluates the model's ability to handle changes in the correct answer over time.
These metrics are intended to provide a more nuanced view of model performance on present-anchored temporal question-answering compared to traditional accuracy-based measures.
Critical Analysis
The PAT-Questions benchmark addresses an important and underexplored area of question-answering research ā the ability to retrieve the most current information to answer queries. This is a crucial capability for real-world applications, where users often need the latest facts and figures.
That said, the authors acknowledge several limitations of their approach. First, the dataset is inherently dynamic, which can make it challenging to establish consistent benchmarks over time. The authors will need to carefully monitor changes to the dataset and ensure fair comparisons across model evaluations.
Additionally, the authors note that PAT-Questions may favor models that can quickly retrieve information from the web, rather than those that excel at reasoning or natural language understanding. This could skew the results and favor certain architectural approaches over others.
There are also open questions about the scalability and generalizability of this approach. Can the self-updating pipeline be applied to other domains beyond the current scope? And how well will models trained on PAT-Questions perform on real-world, open-domain present-anchored questions?
Overall, the PAT-Questions benchmark represents an important step forward in temporal question-answering research. By focusing on the present-anchored task and introducing novel evaluation metrics, the authors have laid the groundwork for further advancements in this area.
Conclusion
The PAT-Questions benchmark introduced in this paper represents a significant advancement in the field of temporal question-answering. By focusing on the present moment and designing the dataset to be self-updating, the authors have created a valuable tool for evaluating the latest AI models in their ability to retrieve up-to-date information.
The proposed evaluation metrics, such as temporal accuracy and response time, provide a more nuanced way to assess model performance beyond just overall accuracy. This could lead to the development of more robust and practical systems for real-world applications that require the latest facts and figures.
While the PAT-Questions dataset has some inherent challenges due to its dynamic nature, the authors have laid the foundation for an important area of research that is likely to grow in relevance as AI systems become more integrated into our daily lives. By continuing to push the boundaries of present-anchored question-answering, the field can make important strides towards building AI assistants that are truly helpful and up-to-date.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering: A Survey
Miao Su, ZiXuan Li, Zhuo Chen, Long Bai, Xiaolong Jin, Jiafeng Guo
0
0
Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) has been a long-standing field to answer questions based on knowledge bases. Recently, the evolving dynamics of knowledge have attracted a growing interest in Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering (TKGQA), an emerging task to answer temporal questions. However, this field grapples with ambiguities in defining temporal questions and lacks a systematic categorization of existing methods for TKGQA. In response, this paper provides a thorough survey from two perspectives: the taxonomy of temporal questions and the methodological categorization for TKGQA. Specifically, we first establish a detailed taxonomy of temporal questions engaged in prior studies. Subsequently, we provide a comprehensive review of TKGQA techniques of two categories: semantic parsing-based and TKG embedding-based. Building on this review, the paper outlines potential research directions aimed at advancing the field of TKGQA. This work aims to serve as a comprehensive reference for TKGQA and to stimulate further research.
6/21/2024
Self-Improvement Programming for Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering
Zhuo Chen, Zhao Zhang, Zixuan Li, Fei Wang, Yutao Zeng, Xiaolong Jin, Yongjun Xu
0
0
Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering (TKGQA) aims to answer questions with temporal intent over Temporal Knowledge Graphs (TKGs). The core challenge of this task lies in understanding the complex semantic information regarding multiple types of time constraints (e.g., before, first) in questions. Existing end-to-end methods implicitly model the time constraints by learning time-aware embeddings of questions and candidate answers, which is far from understanding the question comprehensively. Motivated by semantic-parsing-based approaches that explicitly model constraints in questions by generating logical forms with symbolic operators, we design fundamental temporal operators for time constraints and introduce a novel self-improvement Programming method for TKGQA (Prog-TQA). Specifically, Prog-TQA leverages the in-context learning ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to understand the combinatory time constraints in the questions and generate corresponding program drafts with a few examples given. Then, it aligns these drafts to TKGs with the linking module and subsequently executes them to generate the answers. To enhance the ability to understand questions, Prog-TQA is further equipped with a self-improvement strategy to effectively bootstrap LLMs using high-quality self-generated drafts. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of the proposed Prog-TQA on MultiTQ and CronQuestions datasets, especially in the Hits@1 metric.
4/3/2024
Context Matters: An Empirical Study of the Impact of Contextual Information in Temporal Question Answering Systems
Dan Schumacher, Fatemeh Haji, Tara Grey, Niharika Bandlamudi, Nupoor Karnik, Gagana Uday Kumar, Jason Cho-Yu Chiang, Paul Rad, Nishant Vishwamitra, Anthony Rios
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with temporal reasoning, crucial for tasks like historical event analysis and time-sensitive information retrieval. Despite advancements, state-of-the-art models falter in handling temporal information, especially when faced with irrelevant or noisy contexts. This paper addresses this gap by empirically examining the robustness of temporal question-answering (TQA) systems trained on various context types, including relevant, irrelevant, slightly altered, and no context. Our findings indicate that training with a mix of these contexts enhances model robustness and accuracy. Additionally, we show that the position of context relative to the question significantly impacts performance, with question-first positioning yielding better results. We introduce two new context-rich TQA datasets, ContextAQA and ContextTQE, and provide comprehensive evaluations and guidelines for training robust TQA models. Our work lays the foundation for developing reliable and context-aware temporal QA systems, with broader implications for enhancing LLM robustness against diverse and potentially adversarial information.
7/1/2024
Living in the Moment: Can Large Language Models Grasp Co-Temporal Reasoning?
Zhaochen Su, Juntao Li, Jun Zhang, Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Pan Zhou, Yan Bowen, Yu Cheng, Min zhang
0
0
Temporal reasoning is fundamental for large language models (LLMs) to comprehend the world. Current temporal reasoning datasets are limited to questions about single or isolated events, falling short in mirroring the realistic temporal characteristics involving concurrent nature and intricate temporal interconnections. In this paper, we introduce CoTempQA, a comprehensive co-temporal Question Answering (QA) benchmark containing four co-temporal scenarios (Equal, Overlap, During, Mix) with 4,748 samples for evaluating the co-temporal comprehension and reasoning abilities of LLMs. Our extensive experiments reveal a significant gap between the performance of current LLMs and human-level reasoning on CoTempQA tasks. Even when enhanced with Chain of Thought (CoT) methodologies, models consistently struggle with our task. In our preliminary exploration, we discovered that mathematical reasoning plays a significant role in handling co-temporal events and proposed a strategy to boost LLMs' co-temporal reasoning from a mathematical perspective. We hope that our CoTempQA datasets will encourage further advancements in improving the co-temporal reasoning capabilities of LLMs. Our code is available at https://github.com/zhaochen0110/Cotempqa.
6/14/2024