PEAR: Primitive enabled Adaptive Relabeling for boosting Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning
0
🏅
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) can solve complex long-term tasks by using temporal abstraction and increased exploration, but hierarchical agents are difficult to train due to inherent non-stationarity.
- The paper presents Primitive Enabled Adaptive Relabeling (PEAR), a two-phase approach that first performs adaptive relabeling on expert demonstrations to generate efficient subgoal supervision, and then jointly optimizes HRL agents using reinforcement learning (RL) and imitation learning (IL).
- The paper provides theoretical analysis to bound the sub-optimality of PEAR and derive a generalized framework for joint optimization using RL and IL.
- PEAR can be easily integrated with typical off-policy RL algorithms, making it a practical HRL approach.
- Extensive experiments on challenging environments show that PEAR outperforms various hierarchical and non-hierarchical baselines on complex tasks requiring long-term decision-making.
Plain English Explanation
Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) is a powerful technique that can help AI agents solve complex, long-term tasks. By breaking down a task into smaller subtasks and learning to solve them over time, HRL agents can explore more effectively and make better decisions in the long run. However, training these hierarchical agents is quite challenging because the different subtasks they learn can become misaligned or non-stationary, making it hard for the agent to learn a coherent overall strategy.
The researchers who wrote this paper developed a new approach called Primitive Enabled Adaptive Relabeling (PEAR) to address this challenge. PEAR works in two phases. First, it takes a few expert demonstrations of how to solve the task and uses them to generate useful subgoals or "primitives" that the agent can learn to achieve. This helps provide the agent with a good starting point and guidance on how to break down the overall task.
Then, in the second phase, PEAR jointly optimizes the agent's behavior using both reinforcement learning, where the agent learns through trial and error, and imitation learning, where the agent tries to mimic the expert demonstrations. The researchers show mathematically that this joint approach can learn an efficient overall strategy without the subgoals becoming misaligned.
Importantly, PEAR only requires a small number of expert demonstrations and makes minimal assumptions about the task structure, meaning it can be easily integrated with standard reinforcement learning algorithms. This makes it a practical and effective way to train HRL agents to solve complex, long-term tasks.
The researchers tested PEAR extensively on challenging simulated environments and also on real-world robotic tasks. In all cases, PEAR outperformed other hierarchical and non-hierarchical baselines, demonstrating its ability to help agents make better long-term decisions and solve difficult problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents Primitive Enabled Adaptive Relabeling (PEAR), a hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) approach that addresses the challenge of training hierarchical agents due to inherent non-stationarity. PEAR works in two phases:
-
Adaptive Relabeling: PEAR first performs adaptive relabeling on a few expert demonstrations to generate efficient subgoal supervision. This involves identifying useful "primitives" or subtasks that the agent can learn to achieve.
-
Joint Optimization: PEAR then jointly optimizes the HRL agent by employing both reinforcement learning (RL) and imitation learning (IL). The RL component allows the agent to learn through trial and error, while the IL component guides the agent to mimic the expert demonstrations.
The paper provides theoretical analysis to (i) bound the sub-optimality of PEAR's approach, and (ii) derive a generalized plug-and-play framework for joint optimization using RL and IL. This analysis shows that PEAR can effectively learn an efficient overall strategy without the subgoals becoming misaligned.
Since PEAR only requires a small number of expert demonstrations and makes minimal assumptions about the task structure, it can be easily integrated with typical off-policy RL algorithms, making it a practical HRL approach. The researchers extensively evaluated PEAR on challenging simulated environments and real-world robotic tasks, demonstrating that it outperforms various hierarchical and non-hierarchical baselines on complex, long-term decision-making problems.
The paper also includes ablation studies to thoroughly analyze the importance of PEAR's design choices, such as the adaptive relabeling and joint optimization components.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to addressing the challenges of training hierarchical reinforcement learning agents. By incorporating both reinforcement learning and imitation learning, PEAR is able to effectively learn efficient strategies without the inherent non-stationarity issues that often plague hierarchical agents.
One potential limitation of the approach is that it still relies on a small number of expert demonstrations to generate the initial subgoal supervision. While the paper shows that PEAR can work with minimal expert data, there may be some tasks or environments where even a small number of demonstrations is not available or practical to obtain.
Additionally, the paper's theoretical analysis provides a strong foundation for the PEAR approach, but it would be interesting to see further empirical exploration of the factors that influence the performance and scalability of the method, such as the size and complexity of the task, the quality and quantity of expert demonstrations, and the specific RL and IL algorithms used.
Overall, the PEAR approach represents a promising step forward in making hierarchical reinforcement learning more practical and effective, especially for complex, long-term decision-making tasks. The paper's rigorous analysis and empirical results suggest that PEAR could be a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners working in this area.
Conclusion
The Primitive Enabled Adaptive Relabeling (PEAR) approach presented in this paper offers a compelling solution to the challenge of training hierarchical reinforcement learning agents. By combining adaptive relabeling of expert demonstrations with a joint optimization framework using both reinforcement learning and imitation learning, PEAR is able to effectively learn efficient strategies for complex, long-term tasks.
The paper's theoretical analysis provides a strong foundation for the method, while the extensive experiments demonstrate PEAR's ability to outperform various hierarchical and non-hierarchical baselines on challenging simulated and real-world robotic tasks. As a practical, plug-and-play HRL approach, PEAR has the potential to significantly advance the state of the art in reinforcement learning for complex, long-horizon problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
0
PEAR: Primitive enabled Adaptive Relabeling for boosting Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning
Utsav Singh, Vinay P. Namboodiri
Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) has the potential to solve complex long horizon tasks using temporal abstraction and increased exploration. However, hierarchical agents are difficult to train due to inherent non-stationarity. We present primitive enabled adaptive relabeling (PEAR), a two-phase approach where we first perform adaptive relabeling on a few expert demonstrations to generate efficient subgoal supervision, and then jointly optimize HRL agents by employing reinforcement learning (RL) and imitation learning (IL). We perform theoretical analysis to $(i)$ bound the sub-optimality of our approach, and $(ii)$ derive a generalized plug-and-play framework for joint optimization using RL and IL. Since PEAR utilizes only a handful of expert demonstrations and considers minimal limiting assumptions on the task structure, it can be easily integrated with typical off-policy RL algorithms to produce a practical HRL approach. We perform extensive experiments on challenging environments and show that PEAR is able to outperform various hierarchical and non-hierarchical baselines on complex tasks that require long term decision making. We also perform ablations to thoroughly analyse the importance of our various design choices. Finally, we perform real world robotic experiments on complex tasks and demonstrate that PEAR consistently outperforms the baselines.
Read more4/23/2024
0
PIPER: Primitive-Informed Preference-based Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning via Hindsight Relabeling
Utsav Singh, Wesley A. Suttle, Brian M. Sadler, Vinay P. Namboodiri, Amrit Singh Bedi
In this work, we introduce PIPER: Primitive-Informed Preference-based Hierarchical reinforcement learning via Hindsight Relabeling, a novel approach that leverages preference-based learning to learn a reward model, and subsequently uses this reward model to relabel higher-level replay buffers. Since this reward is unaffected by lower primitive behavior, our relabeling-based approach is able to mitigate non-stationarity, which is common in existing hierarchical approaches, and demonstrates impressive performance across a range of challenging sparse-reward tasks. Since obtaining human feedback is typically impractical, we propose to replace the human-in-the-loop approach with our primitive-in-the-loop approach, which generates feedback using sparse rewards provided by the environment. Moreover, in order to prevent infeasible subgoal prediction and avoid degenerate solutions, we propose primitive-informed regularization that conditions higher-level policies to generate feasible subgoals for lower-level policies. We perform extensive experiments to show that PIPER mitigates non-stationarity in hierarchical reinforcement learning and achieves greater than 50$%$ success rates in challenging, sparse-reward robotic environments, where most other baselines fail to achieve any significant progress.
Read more6/18/2024
🔮
0
CRISP: Curriculum inducing Primitive Informed Subgoal Prediction
Utsav Singh, Vinay P. Namboodiri
Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) is a promising approach that uses temporal abstraction to solve complex long horizon problems. However, simultaneously learning a hierarchy of policies is unstable as it is challenging to train higher-level policy when the lower-level primitive is non-stationary. In this paper, we present CRISP, a novel HRL algorithm that effectively generates a curriculum of achievable subgoals for evolving lower-level primitives using reinforcement learning and imitation learning. CRISP uses the lower level primitive to periodically perform data relabeling on a handful of expert demonstrations, using a novel primitive informed parsing (PIP) approach, thereby mitigating non-stationarity. Since our approach only assumes access to a handful of expert demonstrations, it is suitable for most robotic control tasks. Experimental evaluations on complex robotic maze navigation and robotic manipulation tasks demonstrate that inducing hierarchical curriculum learning significantly improves sample efficiency, and results in efficient goal conditioned policies for solving temporally extended tasks. Additionally, we perform real world robotic experiments on complex manipulation tasks and demonstrate that CRISP demonstrates impressive generalization in real world scenarios.
Read more4/23/2024
0
Subgoal-based Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning for Multi-Agent Collaboration
Cheng Xu, Changtian Zhang, Yuchen Shi, Ran Wang, Shihong Duan, Yadong Wan, Xiaotong Zhang
Recent advancements in reinforcement learning have made significant impacts across various domains, yet they often struggle in complex multi-agent environments due to issues like algorithm instability, low sampling efficiency, and the challenges of exploration and dimensionality explosion. Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) offers a structured approach to decompose complex tasks into simpler sub-tasks, which is promising for multi-agent settings. This paper advances the field by introducing a hierarchical architecture that autonomously generates effective subgoals without explicit constraints, enhancing both flexibility and stability in training. We propose a dynamic goal generation strategy that adapts based on environmental changes. This method significantly improves the adaptability and sample efficiency of the learning process. Furthermore, we address the critical issue of credit assignment in multi-agent systems by synergizing our hierarchical architecture with a modified QMIX network, thus improving overall strategy coordination and efficiency. Comparative experiments with mainstream reinforcement learning algorithms demonstrate the superior convergence speed and performance of our approach in both single-agent and multi-agent environments, confirming its effectiveness and flexibility in complex scenarios. Our code is open-sourced at: url{https://github.com/SICC-Group/GMAH}.
Read more8/22/2024