PlanNetX: Learning an Efficient Neural Network Planner from MPC for Longitudinal Control

Overview

• Model Predictive Control (MPC) is a powerful optimization-based approach for controlling dynamic systems
• However, the computational complexity of online optimization can be problematic on embedded devices, especially when control frequency needs to be guaranteed
• Previous work proposed using imitation learning (IL) to approximate the MPC policy with a neural network to reduce the computational burden
• This paper introduces a novel approach that learns the whole planned trajectory of the MPC using a combination of a novel neural network architecture and a simple loss function

Plain English Explanation

Model Predictive Control (MPC) is a way of controlling dynamic systems, like self-driving cars, that works by repeatedly predicting the future behavior of the system and then choosing the best course of action. This is a powerful approach, but the complex optimization required can be challenging to run in real-time, especially on small embedded devices like those found in many robots and self-driving cars.

Previous work has tried to address this by using imitation learning to train a neural network to mimic the MPC policy, essentially outsourcing the optimization to the neural network. In this paper, the authors take a different approach - instead of just learning the policy, they try to learn the entire trajectory that the MPC controller would generate.

To do this, they developed a new neural network architecture called PlanNetX and a custom loss function that leverages the structure of the MPC optimization problem. The idea is that by learning the full trajectory, the neural network can better capture the underlying dynamics and constraints of the system, leading to better control performance.

The authors validate their approach in the context of autonomous driving, using a simulator to test their longitudinal planner on both synthetic and real-world-based scenarios. They show that their approach can learn the MPC trajectory with high accuracy and also outperform other methods like behavior cloning in terms of closed-loop control performance.

Technical Explanation

The key technical contributions of this paper are:

1. A novel neural network architecture called PlanNetX that is designed to learn the full planned trajectory of the MPC controller, rather than just the control policy.
2. A custom loss function that leverages the parameterized optimal control structure of the MPC problem to improve the learning of the trajectory.

The authors evaluate their approach in the context of autonomous driving, using the CommonRoad simulator to test a longitudinal planner on both synthetic and real-world-based scenarios.

Their results show that the PlanNetX architecture can learn the MPC trajectory with high accuracy, outperforming other baselines like behavior cloning in terms of closed-loop control performance. This suggests that learning the full trajectory can provide benefits over just learning the control policy, especially in safety-critical applications like autonomous driving.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research in their paper:

• The approach has only been evaluated on a longitudinal planner for autonomous driving and may not generalize to other control tasks or more complex systems.
• The simulator-based evaluation, while comprehensive, may not fully capture the challenges of real-world deployment, such as sensor noise and model uncertainty.
• The authors do not provide a thorough analysis of the computational complexity and inference time of the PlanNetX architecture, which is an important consideration for embedded systems.

Additionally, one could question whether the performance improvements over behavior cloning are significant enough to justify the added complexity of the PlanNetX architecture and custom loss function. Further research may be needed to fully understand the tradeoffs and determine the most suitable applications for this approach.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach for learning the planned trajectory of a Model Predictive Control (MPC) controller using a combination of a custom neural network architecture and a specialized loss function. The key idea is that by learning the full trajectory, rather than just the control policy, the neural network can better capture the underlying dynamics and constraints of the system, leading to improved control performance.

The authors validate their approach in the context of autonomous driving, where they show that their method can learn the MPC trajectory with high accuracy and outperform other baselines, such as behavior cloning, in terms of closed-loop control performance. This suggests that their approach could be a promising direction for improving the real-world deployment of MPC-based control systems, especially in safety-critical applications where computational constraints and control frequency guarantees are important.