Poisoning with A Pill: Circumventing Detection in Federated Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents a new "Poisoning with A Pill" attack that can circumvent detection in federated learning systems.
- Federated learning is a distributed machine learning technique where a global model is trained across multiple devices without directly sharing data.
- The proposed attack strategy involves injecting small, carefully crafted updates to the global model that can poison the model without being detected.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this attack through experiments on various federated learning tasks and datasets.
Plain English Explanation
In federated learning, devices like smartphones or tablets collaborate to train a shared machine learning model without directly sharing their private data. This is done by each device updating a global model with changes based on their local data, and then the global model is shared back with the devices.
The paper introduces a new attack called "Poisoning with A Pill" that can secretly undermine this federated learning process. The key idea is to inject small, carefully designed updates to the global model that can gradually poison it over time without being detected. These malicious updates are like "pills" that slowly corrupt the model.
The authors show that this attack can be effective against various federated learning tasks and datasets, even when defenses are in place to try to detect suspicious updates. The attack is stealthy because the individual updates are small and don't appear abnormal on their own, but together they gradually degrade the model's performance.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel attack called "Poisoning with A Pill" that can circumvent detection in federated learning systems. In federated learning, a global model is trained across multiple devices without directly sharing their private data. Instead, devices update the global model with changes based on their local data, and the updated global model is then shared back with the devices.
The key idea of the "Poisoning with A Pill" attack is to inject small, carefully crafted updates to the global model that can gradually poison it over time without being detected by existing defense mechanisms. The authors design these malicious updates to have two key properties:
- Stealthiness: The individual updates are small and don't appear abnormal on their own, making them hard to detect.
- Cumulative Damage: When applied repeatedly, the small updates accumulate to significantly degrade the model's performance.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this attack through experiments on various federated learning tasks and datasets, including image classification, language modeling, and recommendation systems. They show that the attack can be successful even when defenses are in place to try to detect suspicious updates, as the individual updates appear benign.
Critical Analysis
The "Poisoning with A Pill" attack presented in the paper is a concerning development for the field of federated learning. While the authors acknowledge that existing defense mechanisms can help mitigate such attacks, the stealthy and cumulative nature of the proposed attack highlights the need for more robust and comprehensive security measures in federated learning systems.
One potential limitation of the research is that it focuses on a relatively narrow set of attack scenarios and defense strategies. It would be valuable to explore the effectiveness of the "Poisoning with A Pill" attack against a wider range of federated learning architectures, defense mechanisms, and real-world deployment scenarios.
Additionally, the paper does not deeply explore potential countermeasures or mitigation strategies beyond the existing defenses. Further research is needed to develop more sophisticated and proactive approaches to detecting and preventing such stealthy attacks in federated learning environments.
Conclusion
The "Poisoning with A Pill" attack presented in this paper is a concerning development for the field of federated learning. The authors demonstrate how small, carefully crafted updates to the global model can gradually poison it over time without being detected, undermining the security and reliability of federated learning systems.
While existing defense mechanisms can help mitigate such attacks, the stealthy and cumulative nature of the "Poisoning with A Pill" approach highlights the need for more robust and comprehensive security measures in federated learning. Further research is needed to develop more sophisticated detection and prevention strategies to protect against these types of advanced, targeted attacks.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Poisoning with A Pill: Circumventing Detection in Federated Learning
Hanxi Guo, Hao Wang, Tao Song, Tianhang Zheng, Yang Hua, Haibing Guan, Xiangyu Zhang
Without direct access to the client's data, federated learning (FL) is well-known for its unique strength in data privacy protection among existing distributed machine learning techniques. However, its distributive and iterative nature makes FL inherently vulnerable to various poisoning attacks. To counteract these threats, extensive defenses have been proposed to filter out malicious clients, using various detection metrics. Based on our analysis of existing attacks and defenses, we find that there is a lack of attention to model redundancy. In neural networks, various model parameters contribute differently to the model's performance. However, existing attacks in FL manipulate all the model update parameters with the same strategy, making them easily detectable by common defenses. Meanwhile, the defenses also tend to analyze the overall statistical features of the entire model updates, leaving room for sophisticated attacks. Based on these observations, this paper proposes a generic and attack-agnostic augmentation approach designed to enhance the effectiveness and stealthiness of existing FL poisoning attacks against detection in FL, pointing out the inherent flaws of existing defenses and exposing the necessity of fine-grained FL security. Specifically, we employ a three-stage methodology that strategically constructs, generates, and injects poison (generated by existing attacks) into a pill (a tiny subnet with a novel structure) during the FL training, named as pill construction, pill poisoning, and pill injection accordingly. Extensive experimental results show that FL poisoning attacks enhanced by our method can bypass all the popular defenses, and can gain an up to 7x error rate increase, as well as on average a more than 2x error rate increase on both IID and non-IID data, in both cross-silo and cross-device FL systems.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Tracing Back the Malicious Clients in Poisoning Attacks to Federated Learning
Yuqi Jia, Minghong Fang, Hongbin Liu, Jinghuai Zhang, Neil Zhenqiang Gong
Poisoning attacks compromise the training phase of federated learning (FL) such that the learned global model misclassifies attacker-chosen inputs called target inputs. Existing defenses mainly focus on protecting the training phase of FL such that the learnt global model is poison free. However, these defenses often achieve limited effectiveness when the clients' local training data is highly non-iid or the number of malicious clients is large, as confirmed in our experiments. In this work, we propose FLForensics, the first poison-forensics method for FL. FLForensics complements existing training-phase defenses. In particular, when training-phase defenses fail and a poisoned global model is deployed, FLForensics aims to trace back the malicious clients that performed the poisoning attack after a misclassified target input is identified. We theoretically show that FLForensics can accurately distinguish between benign and malicious clients under a formal definition of poisoning attack. Moreover, we empirically show the effectiveness of FLForensics at tracing back both existing and adaptive poisoning attacks on five benchmark datasets.
Read more7/11/2024
0
A GAN-Based Data Poisoning Attack Against Federated Learning Systems and Its Countermeasure
Wei Sun, Bo Gao, Ke Xiong, Yuwei Wang
As a distributed machine learning paradigm, federated learning (FL) is collaboratively carried out on privately owned datasets but without direct data access. Although the original intention is to allay data privacy concerns, available but not visible data in FL potentially brings new security threats, particularly poisoning attacks that target such not visible local data. Initial attempts have been made to conduct data poisoning attacks against FL systems, but cannot be fully successful due to their high chance of causing statistical anomalies. To unleash the potential for truly invisible attacks and build a more deterrent threat model, in this paper, a new data poisoning attack model named VagueGAN is proposed, which can generate seemingly legitimate but noisy poisoned data by untraditionally taking advantage of generative adversarial network (GAN) variants. Capable of manipulating the quality of poisoned data on demand, VagueGAN enables to trade-off attack effectiveness and stealthiness. Furthermore, a cost-effective countermeasure named Model Consistency-Based Defense (MCD) is proposed to identify GAN-poisoned data or models after finding out the consistency of GAN outputs. Extensive experiments on multiple datasets indicate that our attack method is generally much more stealthy as well as more effective in degrading FL performance with low complexity. Our defense method is also shown to be more competent in identifying GAN-poisoned data or models. The source codes are publicly available at href{https://github.com/SSssWEIssSS/VagueGAN-Data-Poisoning-Attack-and-Its-Countermeasure}{https://github.com/SSssWEIssSS/VagueGAN-Data-Poisoning-Attack-and-Its-Countermeasure}.
Read more5/22/2024
🔎
0
Mitigating Malicious Attacks in Federated Learning via Confidence-aware Defense
Qilei Li, Ahmed M. Abdelmoniem
Federated Learning (FL) is a distributed machine learning diagram that enables multiple clients to collaboratively train a global model without sharing their private local data. However, FL systems are vulnerable to attacks that are happening in malicious clients through data poisoning and model poisoning, which can deteriorate the performance of aggregated global model. Existing defense methods typically focus on mitigating specific types of poisoning and are often ineffective against unseen types of attack. These methods also assume an attack happened moderately while is not always holds true in real. Consequently, these methods can significantly fail in terms of accuracy and robustness when detecting and addressing updates from attacked malicious clients. To overcome these challenges, in this work, we propose a simple yet effective framework to detect malicious clients, namely Confidence-Aware Defense (CAD), that utilizes the confidence scores of local models as criteria to evaluate the reliability of local updates. Our key insight is that malicious attacks, regardless of attack type, will cause the model to deviate from its previous state, thus leading to increased uncertainty when making predictions. Therefore, CAD is comprehensively effective for both model poisoning and data poisoning attacks by accurately identifying and mitigating potential malicious updates, even under varying degrees of attacks and data heterogeneity. Experimental results demonstrate that our method significantly enhances the robustness of FL systems against various types of attacks across various scenarios by achieving higher model accuracy and stability.
Read more8/20/2024