Predicting the Influence of Adverse Weather on Pedestrian Detection with Automotive Radar and Lidar Sensors
0
🔎
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Pedestrians are vulnerable in road traffic, and their detection by sensors like radar and lidar can degrade in adverse weather conditions.
- This paper addresses the challenges of understanding the effects of rain and fog on pedestrian detection performance, through comprehensive measurements and a new "Weather Filter" model.
- The Weather Filter model predicts the impact of weather on radar and lidar sensors, building on a baseline physical model while incorporating empirical data.
Plain English Explanation
Pedestrians are among the most at-risk people in road traffic. Sensors like radar and lidar can usually detect pedestrians well, but their performance gets worse in bad weather like rain and fog. To understand this problem, the researchers in this paper did extensive testing to measure how rain and fog affect pedestrian detection. They also created a new "Weather Filter" model that can predict how weather will impact a specific radar or lidar sensor's ability to detect pedestrians.
The Weather Filter model builds on an existing physical model, but adds in real-world data to better account for things like changes in how pedestrians reflect signals in bad weather, or water droplets on the sensors. The researchers found their Weather Filter outperforms the baseline physical model at predicting weather effects, and requires less testing to use.
Technical Explanation
The paper first conducts comprehensive measurements to collect empirical data on pedestrian detection performance under varying rain and fog intensities in a controlled environment. This data is used to improve upon a state-of-the-art baseline model that represents the physical relation of sensor specifications, but lacks representation of secondary weather effects like changes in pedestrian reflectivity or sensor occlusion.
The authors introduce a dedicated Weather Filter (WF) model that predicts the effects of rain and fog on user-specified radar and lidar sensors' pedestrian detection performance. The WF model adjusts the baseline physical model with the empirical data collected, allowing it to account for the secondary weather impacts.
The results show the measurement data aligns with existing literature on weather degradation of sensor performance. Crucially, the WF model outperforms the baseline physical model in predicting weather effects on pedestrian detection, while requiring significantly less testing effort.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive and empirically-grounded approach to understanding the impact of adverse weather on pedestrian detection. By collecting real-world data and incorporating it into an enhanced predictive model, the researchers have addressed a key limitation of prior work that relied solely on physical principles.
However, the study is limited to a specific set of radar and lidar sensors, and it remains to be seen how well the Weather Filter model would generalize to other sensing modalities or future sensor configurations. Additionally, the controlled environment testing, while necessary for isolating weather effects, may not fully capture the complexity of real-world driving scenarios.
Further research could explore the Weather Filter's performance in more diverse and dynamic conditions, as well as its integration with other sensor fusion techniques like those discussed in ContextualFusion or Radar Ghost. Validation against real-world autonomous driving data in rain could also help assess the model's practical viability.
Conclusion
This paper presents an important step forward in understanding and mitigating the effects of adverse weather on pedestrian detection for autonomous vehicles. By combining physical modeling with empirical data, the researchers have developed a Weather Filter model that can more accurately predict sensor performance degradation in rain and fog. This has significant implications for improving the safety and reliability of self-driving cars, which must be able to detect vulnerable road users like pedestrians in all driving conditions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔎
0
Predicting the Influence of Adverse Weather on Pedestrian Detection with Automotive Radar and Lidar Sensors
Daniel Weihmayr, Fatih Sezgin, Leon Tolksdorf, Christian Birkner, Reza N. Jazar
Pedestrians are among the most endangered traffic participants in road traffic. While pedestrian detection in nominal conditions is well established, the sensor and, therefore, the pedestrian detection performance degrades under adverse weather conditions. Understanding the influences of rain and fog on a specific radar and lidar sensor requires extensive testing, and if the sensors' specifications are altered, a retesting effort is required. These challenges are addressed in this paper, firstly by conducting comprehensive measurements collecting empirical data of pedestrian detection performance under varying rain and fog intensities in a controlled environment, and secondly, by introducing a dedicated textit{Weather Filter} (WF) model that predicts the effects of rain and fog on a user-specified radar and lidar on pedestrian detection performance. We use a state-of-the-art baseline model representing the physical relation of sensor specifications, which, however, lacks the representation of secondary weather effects, e.g., changes in pedestrian reflectivity or droplets on a sensor, and adjust it with empirical data to account for such. We find that our measurement results are in agreement with existent literature related to weather degredation and our WF outperforms the baseline model in predicting weather effects on pedestrian detection while only requiring a minimal testing effort.
Read more5/22/2024
0
Snowy Scenes,Clear Detections: A Robust Model for Traffic Light Detection in Adverse Weather Conditions
Shivank Garg, Abhishek Baghel, Amit Agarwal, Durga Toshniwal
With the rise of autonomous vehicles and advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), ensuring reliable object detection in all weather conditions is crucial for safety and efficiency. Adverse weather like snow, rain, and fog presents major challenges for current detection systems, often resulting in failures and potential safety risks. This paper introduces a novel framework and pipeline designed to improve object detection under such conditions, focusing on traffic signal detection where traditional methods often fail due to domain shifts caused by adverse weather. We provide a comprehensive analysis of the limitations of existing techniques. Our proposed pipeline significantly enhances detection accuracy in snow, rain, and fog. Results show a 40.8% improvement in average IoU and F1 scores compared to naive fine-tuning and a 22.4% performance increase in domain shift scenarios, such as training on artificial snow and testing on rain images.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Effect of Fog Particle Size Distribution on 3D Object Detection Under Adverse Weather Conditions
Ajinkya Shinde, Gaurav Sharma, Manisha Pattanaik, Sri Niwas Singh
LiDAR-based sensors employing optical spectrum signals play a vital role in providing significant information about the target objects in autonomous driving vehicle systems. However, the presence of fog in the atmosphere severely degrades the overall system's performance. This manuscript analyzes the role of fog particle size distributions in 3D object detection under adverse weather conditions. We utilise Mie theory and meteorological optical range (MOR) to calculate the attenuation and backscattering coefficient values for point cloud generation and analyze the overall system's accuracy in Car, Cyclist, and Pedestrian case scenarios under easy, medium and hard detection difficulties. Gamma and Junge (Power-Law) distributions are employed to mathematically model the fog particle size distribution under strong and moderate advection fog environments. Subsequently, we modified the KITTI dataset based on the backscattering coefficient values and trained it on the PV-RCNN++ deep neural network model for Car, Cyclist, and Pedestrian cases under different detection difficulties. The result analysis shows a significant variation in the system's accuracy concerning the changes in target object dimensionality, the nature of the fog environment and increasing detection difficulties, with the Car exhibiting the highest accuracy of around 99% and the Pedestrian showing the lowest accuracy of around 73%.
Read more8/6/2024
0
Robust ADAS: Enhancing Robustness of Machine Learning-based Advanced Driver Assistance Systems for Adverse Weather
Muhammad Zaeem Shahzad, Muhammad Abdullah Hanif, Muhammad Shafique
In the realm of deploying Machine Learning-based Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ML-ADAS) into real-world scenarios, adverse weather conditions pose a significant challenge. Conventional ML models trained on clear weather data falter when faced with scenarios like extreme fog or heavy rain, potentially leading to accidents and safety hazards. This paper addresses this issue by proposing a novel approach: employing a Denoising Deep Neural Network as a preprocessing step to transform adverse weather images into clear weather images, thereby enhancing the robustness of ML-ADAS systems. The proposed method eliminates the need for retraining all subsequent Depp Neural Networks (DNN) in the ML-ADAS pipeline, thus saving computational resources and time. Moreover, it improves driver visualization, which is critical for safe navigation in adverse weather conditions. By leveraging the UNet architecture trained on an augmented KITTI dataset with synthetic adverse weather images, we develop the Weather UNet (WUNet) DNN to remove weather artifacts. Our study demonstrates substantial performance improvements in object detection with WUNet preprocessing under adverse weather conditions. Notably, in scenarios involving extreme fog, our proposed solution improves the mean Average Precision (mAP) score of the YOLOv8n from 4% to 70%.
Read more7/4/2024