A Preliminary Roadmap for LLMs as Assistants in Exploring, Analyzing, and Visualizing Knowledge Graphs
2404.01425
0
0
Abstract
We present a mixed-methods study to explore how large language models (LLMs) can assist users in the visual exploration and analysis of knowledge graphs (KGs). We surveyed and interviewed 20 professionals from industry, government laboratories, and academia who regularly work with KGs and LLMs, either collaboratively or concurrently. Our findings show that participants overwhelmingly want an LLM to facilitate data retrieval from KGs through joint query construction, to identify interesting relationships in the KG through multi-turn conversation, and to create on-demand visualizations from the KG that enhance their trust in the LLM's outputs. To interact with an LLM, participants strongly prefer a chat-based 'widget,' built on top of their regular analysis workflows, with the ability to guide the LLM using their interactions with a visualization. When viewing an LLM's outputs, participants similarly prefer a combination of annotated visuals (e.g., subgraphs or tables extracted from the KG) alongside summarizing text. However, participants also expressed concerns about an LLM's ability to maintain semantic intent when translating natural language questions into KG queries, the risk of an LLM 'hallucinating' false data from the KG, and the difficulties of engineering a 'perfect prompt.' From the analysis of our interviews, we contribute a preliminary roadmap for the design of LLM-driven knowledge graph exploration systems and outline future opportunities in this emergent design space.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper discusses a preliminary roadmap for using large language models (LLMs) as assistants to explore, analyze, and visualize knowledge graphs.
- Knowledge graphs are structured data representations of information and relationships, which have become increasingly important for tasks like question answering and semantic search.
- The paper proposes ways LLMs could be leveraged to enhance knowledge graph exploration, analysis, and visualization.
Plain English Explanation
Knowledge graphs are digital representations of information and how different pieces of information are connected. Imagine a giant web of facts, with each fact represented as a node and the relationships between them as lines connecting the nodes. This allows computers to understand not just individual facts, but how those facts relate to each other.
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful AI systems that can understand and generate human-like text. The paper explores how these LLMs could be used as assistants to help people better interact with and make sense of knowledge graphs. For example, an LLM could assist in exploring a knowledge graph by answering questions, summarizing key information, or suggesting related topics to investigate further. It could also help analyze the graph by identifying important entities, relationships, or patterns. And it could facilitate visualization by generating natural language descriptions of the graph's structure and content.
The goal is to leverage the strengths of LLMs - their language understanding, reasoning, and generation capabilities - to make knowledge graphs more accessible and useful for a wide range of applications and users.
Technical Explanation
The paper provides a high-level roadmap for integrating LLMs into knowledge graph exploration, analysis, and visualization workflows. It does not present any new technical experiments or implementations.
For exploration, the authors suggest LLMs could be used to answer natural language questions about the knowledge graph, summarize key information, and recommend related entities or topics to investigate further. This could help users efficiently navigate and make sense of the graph's contents.
In the analysis phase, LLMs could assist in identifying important entities, relationships, and patterns within the graph. They could also generate natural language descriptions of the graph's structure and semantics, which could aid in understanding complex knowledge graphs.
For visualization, the paper proposes that LLMs could generate text-based summaries, explanations, and annotations to accompany graphical representations of the knowledge graph. This could make the visualizations more interpretable and useful for end-users.
The paper argues that combining the strengths of LLMs and knowledge graphs could lead to more effective knowledge discovery and decision-making across a variety of domains.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a conceptual roadmap rather than any concrete implementations or evaluations. As such, it does not address potential challenges or limitations in deploying LLMs for knowledge graph exploration, analysis, and visualization.
Some key issues that could be worth considering:
- The accuracy and reliability of LLM-powered interactions with knowledge graphs, especially for sensitive or high-stakes applications
- The computational and storage requirements of integrating large language models into knowledge graph systems
- Potential biases or mistakes that LLMs could introduce when interpreting or describing the contents of a knowledge graph
- The difficulty of aligning LLM outputs with user intent and knowledge graph semantics
Further research and development would be needed to fully realize the vision outlined in this paper. Carefully designed user studies and technical evaluations would help validate the potential benefits and address the challenges of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper proposes a high-level roadmap for leveraging large language models as assistants to enhance the exploration, analysis, and visualization of knowledge graphs. By combining the strengths of LLMs in natural language understanding and generation with the structured knowledge represented in graphs, the authors argue that users could more effectively discover, interpret, and apply insights from complex information networks.
While the ideas presented are conceptual, they point to an interesting direction for future research and development. Realizing this vision would require addressing technical challenges and conducting rigorous evaluations to ensure the reliability and usefulness of LLM-powered knowledge graph tools. Overall, the paper outlines a promising area for further exploration at the intersection of large language models and structured knowledge representations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Research Trends for the Interplay between Large Language Models and Knowledge Graphs
Hanieh Khorashadizadeh, Fatima Zahra Amara, Morteza Ezzabady, Fr'ed'eric Ieng, Sanju Tiwari, Nandana Mihindukulasooriya, Jinghua Groppe, Soror Sahri, Farah Benamara, Sven Groppe
0
0
This survey investigates the synergistic relationship between Large Language Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs (KGs), which is crucial for advancing AI's capabilities in understanding, reasoning, and language processing. It aims to address gaps in current research by exploring areas such as KG Question Answering, ontology generation, KG validation, and the enhancement of KG accuracy and consistency through LLMs. The paper further examines the roles of LLMs in generating descriptive texts and natural language queries for KGs. Through a structured analysis that includes categorizing LLM-KG interactions, examining methodologies, and investigating collaborative uses and potential biases, this study seeks to provide new insights into the combined potential of LLMs and KGs. It highlights the importance of their interaction for improving AI applications and outlines future research directions.
6/13/2024
LinkQ: An LLM-Assisted Visual Interface for Knowledge Graph Question-Answering
Harry Li, Gabriel Appleby, Ashley Suh
0
0
We present LinkQ, a system that leverages a large language model (LLM) to facilitate knowledge graph (KG) query construction through natural language question-answering. Traditional approaches often require detailed knowledge of complex graph querying languages, limiting the ability for users -- even experts -- to acquire valuable insights from KG data. LinkQ simplifies this process by first interpreting a user's question, then converting it into a well-formed KG query. By using the LLM to construct a query instead of directly answering the user's question, LinkQ guards against the LLM hallucinating or generating false, erroneous information. By integrating an LLM into LinkQ, users are able to conduct both exploratory and confirmatory data analysis, with the LLM helping to iteratively refine open-ended questions into precise ones. To demonstrate the efficacy of LinkQ, we conducted a qualitative study with five KG practitioners and distill their feedback. Our results indicate that practitioners find LinkQ effective for KG question-answering, and desire future LLM-assisted systems for the exploratory analysis of graph databases.
6/12/2024
Assessing LLMs Suitability for Knowledge Graph Completion
Vasile Ionut Remus Iga, Gheorghe Cosmin Silaghi
0
0
Recent work shown the capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to solve tasks related to Knowledge Graphs, such as Knowledge Graph Completion, even in Zero- or Few-Shot paradigms. However, they are known to hallucinate answers, or output results in a non-deterministic manner, thus leading to wrongly reasoned responses, even if they satisfy the user's demands. To highlight opportunities and challenges in knowledge graphs-related tasks, we experiment with two distinguished LLMs, namely Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1, and gpt-3.5-turbo-0125, on Knowledge Graph Completion for static knowledge graphs, using prompts constructed following the TELeR taxonomy, in Zero- and One-Shot contexts, on a Task-Oriented Dialogue system use case. When evaluated using both strict and flexible metrics measurement manners, our results show that LLMs could be fit for such a task if prompts encapsulate sufficient information and relevant examples.
5/28/2024
š§
HOLMES: Hyper-Relational Knowledge Graphs for Multi-hop Question Answering using LLMs
Pranoy Panda, Ankush Agarwal, Chaitanya Devaguptapu, Manohar Kaul, Prathosh A P
0
0
Given unstructured text, Large Language Models (LLMs) are adept at answering simple (single-hop) questions. However, as the complexity of the questions increase, the performance of LLMs degrade. We believe this is due to the overhead associated with understanding the complex question followed by filtering and aggregating unstructured information in the raw text. Recent methods try to reduce this burden by integrating structured knowledge triples into the raw text, aiming to provide a structured overview that simplifies information processing. However, this simplistic approach is query-agnostic and the extracted facts are ambiguous as they lack context. To address these drawbacks and to enable LLMs to answer complex (multi-hop) questions with ease, we propose to use a knowledge graph (KG) that is context-aware and is distilled to contain query-relevant information. The use of our compressed distilled KG as input to the LLM results in our method utilizing up to $67%$ fewer tokens to represent the query relevant information present in the supporting documents, compared to the state-of-the-art (SoTA) method. Our experiments show consistent improvements over the SoTA across several metrics (EM, F1, BERTScore, and Human Eval) on two popular benchmark datasets (HotpotQA and MuSiQue).
6/11/2024