Principled Penalty-based Methods for Bilevel Reinforcement Learning and RLHF
2402.06886
0
0
🏅
Abstract
Bilevel optimization has been recently applied to many machine learning tasks. However, their applications have been restricted to the supervised learning setting, where static objective functions with benign structures are considered. But bilevel problems such as incentive design, inverse reinforcement learning (RL), and RL from human feedback (RLHF) are often modeled as dynamic objective functions that go beyond the simple static objective structures, which pose significant challenges of using existing bilevel solutions. To tackle this new class of bilevel problems, we introduce the first principled algorithmic framework for solving bilevel RL problems through the lens of penalty formulation. We provide theoretical studies of the problem landscape and its penalty-based (policy) gradient algorithms. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our algorithms via simulations in the Stackelberg Markov game, RL from human feedback and incentive design.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a penalty-based bilevel gradient descent method for solving optimization problems with a nested structure.
- The method aims to address the computational challenges of traditional bilevel optimization approaches by reformulating the problem into a single-level optimization problem with a penalty term.
- The authors provide theoretical guarantees on the convergence and optimality of the proposed method, as well as experimental results demonstrating its effectiveness on various test problems.
Plain English Explanation
Optimization problems often have a nested structure, where the solution to one part of the problem depends on the solution to another part. For example, in machine learning, the parameters of a model might need to be optimized based on the performance of the model on a given dataset. This type of problem is known as a bilevel optimization problem, and it can be computationally challenging to solve.
The penalty-based bilevel gradient descent method proposed in this paper is a new approach to solving these types of optimization problems. The key idea is to reformulate the bilevel problem as a single-level optimization problem with a penalty term. This penalty term helps to ensure that the solution satisfies the constraints of the original bilevel problem, without requiring the explicit computation of the inner optimization problem.
The authors provide theoretical guarantees on the convergence and optimality of their method, and they also present experimental results showing that it outperforms traditional bilevel optimization approaches on a variety of test problems. This suggests that their method could be a useful tool for solving complex optimization problems in fields like machine learning, reinforcement learning, and beyond.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose a penalty-based bilevel gradient descent method for solving optimization problems with a nested structure. The key idea is to reformulate the original bilevel optimization problem as a single-level optimization problem with a penalty term.
Specifically, the authors consider a bilevel optimization problem of the form:
min_x F(x, y) s.t. y = argmin_y f(x, y)
Where x and y are the decision variables, F(x, y) is the upper-level objective function, and f(x, y) is the lower-level objective function.
To solve this problem, the authors introduce a penalty term that enforces the constraint that y is the optimal solution to the lower-level problem. This leads to the following single-level optimization problem:
min_x,y F(x, y) + λ * (f(x, y) - f(x, y*))^2
Where y* is the optimal solution to the lower-level problem, and λ is a penalty parameter.
The authors prove that under certain assumptions, this penalty-based formulation converges to the optimal solution of the original bilevel problem as the penalty parameter λ goes to infinity. They also provide a gradient-based algorithm for solving the penalty-based problem, and they demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on a variety of test problems.
Critical Analysis
The penalty-based bilevel gradient descent method proposed in this paper is a promising approach for solving complex optimization problems with a nested structure. The authors provide strong theoretical guarantees on the convergence and optimality of their method, which is a important contribution to the field of bilevel optimization.
However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research. First, the method relies on the assumption that the lower-level problem can be solved efficiently, which may not always be the case in practice. The authors mention that the method can be extended to handle more general lower-level problems, but further investigation would be needed.
Additionally, the authors only consider a specific form of the bilevel problem, where the upper-level objective is a function of both the upper-level and lower-level variables. It would be interesting to see how the method might be extended to handle more general bilevel problem formulations, such as those where the upper-level objective only depends on the upper-level variables.
Finally, while the experimental results are promising, it would be useful to see the method applied to larger-scale, real-world optimization problems, rather than just synthetic test problems. This could help to further validate the practical utility of the approach.
Overall, this paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of bilevel optimization, and the penalty-based approach is a promising direction for further research and development.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a penalty-based bilevel gradient descent method for solving optimization problems with a nested structure. The key idea is to reformulate the original bilevel problem as a single-level optimization problem with a penalty term, which helps to address the computational challenges of traditional bilevel optimization approaches.
The authors provide strong theoretical guarantees on the convergence and optimality of their method, and they demonstrate its effectiveness on various test problems. This suggests that their approach could be a useful tool for solving complex optimization problems in fields like machine learning, reinforcement learning, and beyond.
While the method has some potential limitations, it represents an important step forward in the field of bilevel optimization, and it opens up interesting avenues for future research and development.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Bilevel reinforcement learning via the development of hyper-gradient without lower-level convexity
Yan Yang, Bin Gao, Ya-xiang Yuan
0
0
Bilevel reinforcement learning (RL), which features intertwined two-level problems, has attracted growing interest recently. The inherent non-convexity of the lower-level RL problem is, however, to be an impediment to developing bilevel optimization methods. By employing the fixed point equation associated with the regularized RL, we characterize the hyper-gradient via fully first-order information, thus circumventing the assumption of lower-level convexity. This, remarkably, distinguishes our development of hyper-gradient from the general AID-based bilevel frameworks since we take advantage of the specific structure of RL problems. Moreover, we propose both model-based and model-free bilevel reinforcement learning algorithms, facilitated by access to the fully first-order hyper-gradient. Both algorithms are provable to enjoy the convergence rate $mathcal{O}(epsilon^{-1})$. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that AID-based bilevel RL gets rid of additional assumptions on the lower-level problem. In addition, numerical experiments demonstrate that the hyper-gradient indeed serves as an integration of exploitation and exploration.
5/31/2024
A Primal-Dual-Assisted Penalty Approach to Bilevel Optimization with Coupled Constraints
Liuyuan Jiang, Quan Xiao, Victor M. Tenorio, Fernando Real-Rojas, Antonio Marques, Tianyi Chen
0
0
Interest in bilevel optimization has grown in recent years, partially due to its applications to tackle challenging machine-learning problems. Several exciting recent works have been centered around developing efficient gradient-based algorithms that can solve bilevel optimization problems with provable guarantees. However, the existing literature mainly focuses on bilevel problems either without constraints, or featuring only simple constraints that do not couple variables across the upper and lower levels, excluding a range of complex applications. Our paper studies this challenging but less explored scenario and develops a (fully) first-order algorithm, which we term BLOCC, to tackle BiLevel Optimization problems with Coupled Constraints. We establish rigorous convergence theory for the proposed algorithm and demonstrate its effectiveness on two well-known real-world applications - hyperparameter selection in support vector machine (SVM) and infrastructure planning in transportation networks using the real data from the city of Seville.
6/18/2024
🐍
A Unified Linear Programming Framework for Offline Reward Learning from Human Demonstrations and Feedback
Kihyun Kim, Jiawei Zhang, Asuman Ozdaglar, Pablo A. Parrilo
0
0
Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL) and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) are pivotal methodologies in reward learning, which involve inferring and shaping the underlying reward function of sequential decision-making problems based on observed human demonstrations and feedback. Most prior work in reward learning has relied on prior knowledge or assumptions about decision or preference models, potentially leading to robustness issues. In response, this paper introduces a novel linear programming (LP) framework tailored for offline reward learning. Utilizing pre-collected trajectories without online exploration, this framework estimates a feasible reward set from the primal-dual optimality conditions of a suitably designed LP, and offers an optimality guarantee with provable sample efficiency. Our LP framework also enables aligning the reward functions with human feedback, such as pairwise trajectory comparison data, while maintaining computational tractability and sample efficiency. We demonstrate that our framework potentially achieves better performance compared to the conventional maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) approach through analytical examples and numerical experiments.
6/5/2024
🛠️
Functional Bilevel Optimization for Machine Learning
Ieva Petrulionyte, Julien Mairal, Michael Arbel
0
0
In this paper, we introduce a new functional point of view on bilevel optimization problems for machine learning, where the inner objective is minimized over a function space. These types of problems are most often solved by using methods developed in the parametric setting, where the inner objective is strongly convex with respect to the parameters of the prediction function. The functional point of view does not rely on this assumption and notably allows using over-parameterized neural networks as the inner prediction function. We propose scalable and efficient algorithms for the functional bilevel optimization problem and illustrate the benefits of our approach on instrumental regression and reinforcement learning tasks.
6/14/2024